Mini Normal 2334: trees (Day 6)

[Elements]

Bmopp

[Elements]

Nooooooooo

[Dannflor]

I empathize with Elements' Rational vote even though I think Rational is probably town

[Hu Tao]

Nooooooooo

Ahahahahaha

[Hu Tao]

I empathize with Elements' Rational vote even though I think Rational is probably town

Why

[Hu Tao]

What do you think my reaction would be

I don't want to say yet

[Hu Tao]

I did a quick read and I still want to eliminate salty. I'm getting vibes there of scum. I'm also getting small pings from gibdo

[Hu Tao]

Anyone not voting salty can they tell me why salty could be town?

[Dannflor]

I empathize with Elements' Rational vote even though I think Rational is probably town

Why

Because I think Rational's posting is actively harmful to Town EV at worst and annoying/creating disengagement at best

[Dannflor]

What do you think my reaction would be

I don't want to say yet

okay, well, I just kinda think you're making that read up

[KayJayQueue]

I’ve definitely felt disengaged from this game and I’m not sure where to naturally come back in confidently. I don’t have a ton of concrete reads outside of Thom and Elements as town.

[Dannflor]

Anyone not voting salty can they tell me why salty could be town?

I think his posting feels unagenda'd and like he's trying to figure out the game

[Thomith]

Anyone not voting salty can they tell me why salty could be town?

Haven't seen enough yet.
Seems like he is making an effort to solve in 409 and 410

[Hu Tao]

I empathize with Elements' Rational vote even though I think Rational is probably town

Why

Because I think Rational's posting is actively harmful to Town EV at worst and annoying/creating disengagement at best

Who cares? He's obvious town. Why would we want to eliminate him.

[Hu Tao]

What do you think my reaction would be

I don't want to say yet

okay, well, I just kinda think you're making that read up

I could just make something up if that was the case

[Dannflor]

Why would we want to eliminate him.

same reason I half wanted to eliminate Random Nurse, the innocent child, in our last game

[Elements]

I’ve definitely felt disengaged from this game and I’m not sure where to naturally come back in confidently. I don’t have a ton of concrete reads outside of Thom and Elements as town.

Why not have a look at Salty as that seems to be the current topic?

[Hu Tao]

Anyone not voting salty can they tell me why salty could be town?

Haven't seen enough yet.
Seems like he is making an effort to solve in 409 and 410

Thoughts on gibdo?

[Dannflor]

I could just make something up if that was the case

sure, I also don't think it's unlike scum!you to be cagey for no reason

[Hu Tao]

Why would we want to eliminate him.

same reason I half wanted to eliminate Random Nurse, the innocent child, in our last game

Tbf RN wasn't reading the game

[KayJayQueue]

I empathize with Elements' Rational vote even though I think Rational is probably town

Why

Because I think Rational's posting is actively harmful to Town EV at worst and annoying/creating disengagement at best

Who cares? He's obvious town. Why would we want to eliminate him.

I agree about not wanting to vote Rational but I definitely see a world where scum just continues to let him cause distractions that could cause TvT issues which I think may already be happening today. I don’t know. I just know if things turn toxic again, I might step back.

[Hu Tao]

I usually see a scumread and lock in. But I don't have anything too strong right now. It's sad

[KayJayQueue]

Why would we want to eliminate him.

same reason I half wanted to eliminate Random Nurse, the innocent child, in our last game

That would’ve been so helpful lol

[Hu Tao]

I empathize with Elements' Rational vote even though I think Rational is probably town

Why

Because I think Rational's posting is actively harmful to Town EV at worst and annoying/creating disengagement at best

Who cares? He's obvious town. Why would we want to eliminate him.

I agree about not wanting to vote Rational but I definitely see a world where scum just continues to let him cause distractions that could cause TvT issues which I think may already be happening today. I don’t know. I just know if things turn toxic again, I might step back.

Idk. He's town and possible a pr so I see no reason to eliminate

[Dannflor]

Dann and Elements (possibly can throw in Grovyle) are thinking almost exactly as I am, seem town enough for me for now

I've played a few games with only Dannflor, and maybe I'm misremembering, but criticizing others' reads of him doesn't seem like his scum playstyle.

I haven't talked about gibdo yet but I think they lean town after these posts

For context, Gibdo is an IRL friend I invited specifically to play this game. As far as I know he has no experience in forum mafia, his experience with me is relegated to a few face-to-face mafia games we played years ago.

- I think his attempting to pull some meta (no matter how outdated it might be) from those face-to-face games is probably indicative he's genuinely trying to solve me
- I think his statement that he's thinking almost exactly how 3 other players are thinking is somewhat unlikely to come from scum. I think that framing looks kind of blatantly sheepy and pockety and I think scum, especially scum that might feel a bit awkward about this format would be hesitant to avoid that
- above all I think Gibdo not really playing or even mentioning the newbie card at all and just throwing himself into figuring things out as he goes is indicative he's just interested in solving the game rather than looking town