Ok you misunderstood, I meant I really cant add much with whats going on and that I wouldnt comment once everybody has gotten through there claim, I cant add anything helpful to that. I was meaning I was going to read over from my first post from day 2 which I now have done.hasdgfas wrote:Catching up. At least not much has happened >.>
I don't like posts 242-244 that all comment on how nothing's happening, but don't do anything to cause things to happen.
Post 248 - Yos2: I prefer maximizing the amount of town-controlled kills. Sure, it might also be scum-controlled, but I still prefer using it. Maybe calling it scummy was a bit harsh, but I don't like a no-kill here.
Post 251 - Ruck: Although Mega did express suspicion of fuzzy during day 1, so I don't find it all that strange.
Post 252 - Yos2: Still want me to claim my target?
Post 259 - Gorrad: Hmm, role arguments in a smalltown aren't usually a good idea, IMO. Scumhunting is still pretty important, and everyone has a role, it's not like we can say "oh, vanilla, easy choice for a vig kill"
Post 268 - Gorrad: I don't like the argument of "I might die quickly if I take a good role". Isn't getting killed due to role better than being killed because the scum think you can scumhunt for them more easily?
Post 277 - Yos2: If you really think someone is scum, why shouldn't you kill them, even if it might lose the game for the town? Would you rather control it or have to convince the town you're right?
Post 279 - Yos2: I agree with Yosarian2 about Gorrad.
Post 285 - Gorrad: Why do you find him suspect? I haven't seen you express any reasoning for it, and with the fact that Yos was supicious of you first, this seems like pure OMGUS to me. I also don't think it's a bad idea to keep him from killing if we mislynch.
Post 288 - Porochaz: I find it very strange that you don't haveanythingto add to what's been said today.
I'm going toFoS: Gorrad and Porochaz
I feel them as scum right now. I really don't like Post 285 where he expresses suspicion of Yos2 with no reasoning and says that a self-vig is a good idea.
Porochaz has done nothing, which is probably the best scum play right now.
So in answer to yos2's question. I dislike Master Ruck, his reasoning to me hasnt been the best and his logic is essentially flawed. I dontlike many of his posts at the start of this page, simply because of the way he went about suggesting it.
However Gorrad is top of my list currently, Im trying to get the reasoning behind his actions so far and I am failing badly. The reason he didnt pick tracker just screams non sensical to me. As is the wanting to wait for a protective role... I think at the moment he would be my candidate and thusly