Elf's only post.xofelf wrote:Hi... gonna do some reading here quick, anything anyone wants me to focus on please say so now.
Oh and just in case:Unvote
We'd like you to give us your thoughts on who's left please.
Elf's only post.xofelf wrote:Hi... gonna do some reading here quick, anything anyone wants me to focus on please say so now.
Oh and just in case:Unvote
saberwolf wrote:I think I have found something. Notice that two of them say mafia, but one of them says mafia goon. Two teams of scum I believe I have just confirmed. That means we have one mafia left, as well as a vig/SK, and 3 town roles.Empking wrote:4. Far_Cry
5. XofelfRealityFan
9. Saberwolf
10. manho
13. DeathNoteChacoRobotPirateninja
Dead:
3. Devestator - Townie
8.MichelsabreheartPimj- Townie - Killed Night 1
12. PyromaniacSudaiMafia- Killed Night 1
1. RisingJackinthebox-Mafia- Killed Night 1
11. Donkeyz12212 - Vannilla Townie - Lynched Day 2
2. Santos -Mafia- Killed night 2Goon
6. Flava FlaveToast- Vanilla Town - Killed night 2
7. BogreBoxman- Vanilla Town - Killed night 2
Roles Going Out
_________________
it is likely to be our last day and we may be in lylo, so i think we should have the mass roleclaim. and i have some thought about the game setup, which may help find the scum by mass roleclaim. and you are also asking the vig to claim, which is next to asking a mass roleclaim.Far_Cry wrote:I don't think so. Why do you want this?manho wrote:i think we should have a mass roleclaim first.
i will be waiting for you...xofelf wrote:sorry about my non activity... for a while i was confused whether i had really replaced in here or not as Emp had forgotten to change the one post.. but i'm gonna have to get on this either tomorrow or Saturday. I'm rather tired and i haven't really caught up yet... so yeah. Expect stuff from me then.
I don't think we should do this quite yet. It's to early in the day to do so.manho wrote:it is likely to be our last day and we may be in lylo, so i think we should have the mass roleclaim. and i have some thought about the game setup, which may help find the scum by mass roleclaim. and you are also asking the vig to claim, which is next to asking a mass roleclaim.Far_Cry wrote:I don't think so. Why do you want this?manho wrote:i think we should have a mass roleclaim first.
To tell the truth, either you or deathnote is lying. Since we have like 1 more scum, an SK/vig, I would find it hard to believe that are last roles are all townies.manho wrote:where is everyone? i will roleclaim vanilla town then.
See, the problem with this post is that, had Reality been contributing more to the game, then perhaps this vote would have been ok. But he had said barely anything up to that point, meaning that this post was sort of out of order and without reason.RealityFan wrote:Unvote, vote: jackinthebox
Hasn't really said anything game related. Seems to be actively lurking.
Once again, this looks like posting just to post. I don't understand the gut read at all, once again, because he hasn't posted enough.RealityFan wrote:I have a really big gut read on FC-town. I think that saber vs. FC was Town vs. Town. I don't like Santos buddying up to me and voting jack. In my opinion, the supertown argument is dumb. It depends on if they give off any scum-tells WHILE posting a lot of content, people aren't scummy for posting a lot of content...
Newbie scum slip? Why did u think so right away? I very much didn't like pimj and toast, but I did not call them off as scum right away. To tell the truth, this just looks like taking sides and doesn't have much though behind it.manho wrote:vote: pimj, he is too defensive on toast, and he even vote FC for attacking toast. probably a newbie-scum slip.
This looks like a scum town list. He was wrong for almost everything on this list.manho wrote:FC has 4 votes already? but i really can't see why he is scummy. can anyone give me some reasons so that i can have a better look at FC?
i'll give a brief look at all the people so that something may come out from it.
1. Jackinthebox777 - not much content from his posts.
2. Santos - again not much content, but his latest post has some good point.
3. Devestation - really a hypocrite but accusing sudai of being hypocritical
4. Far_Cry - attacking toast and pimj for some valid reasons and contribute a lot in other ways, which is pro-town, imo.
5. RealityFan - not much content again, but trying to be useful, which is pro-town.
6. Toast - that conversation-starting post is neutral to scummy. lurking and leaving the game under attack.
7. Boxman - not much content again. voted FC to give pressure.
8. Pimj - see my previous post which explain my vote on him. lurking and leaving the game under attack, like toast.
9. Saberwolf - pretty much leading the town. maybe town or scum trying to act pro-town.
10. manho - definitely innocent, imo.
11. Donkeyz - contribute lots to the game. my gut tell me he is innocent.
12. Sudai - is there someone think sudai is scummy, can that someone tell me why.
13. Chaco (replacing RobotPirateNinja) - looking for his posts.
if anyone agree or disagree my opinion, let me know.
i actually think that the last roles are all townies. i don't believe there are doctor or cop in this setup. there may be a vig but it is unlikely imo. that's why i'm asking for a mass roleclaim. i'll lynch all those not claim to be townie, but now you force me to bring it up...Far_Cry wrote:To tell the truth, either you or deathnote is lying. Since we have like 1 more scum, an SK/vig, I would find it hard to believe that are last roles are all townies.
it says "probably". and you have voted toast also if i remember correctly. so, you voted them without calling them off as scum?Far_Cry wrote:Newbie scum slip? Why did u think so right away? I very much didn't like pimj and toast, but I did not call them off as scum right away. To tell the truth, this just looks like taking sides and doesn't have much though behind it.manho wrote:vote: pimj, he is too defensive on toast, and he even vote FC for attacking toast. probably a newbie-scum slip.
can you point out where it is wrong?This looks like a scum town list. He was wrong for almost everything on this list.manho wrote:FC has 4 votes already? but i really can't see why he is scummy. can anyone give me some reasons so that i can have a better look at FC?
i'll give a brief look at all the people so that something may come out from it.
1. Jackinthebox777 - not much content from his posts.
2. Santos - again not much content, but his latest post has some good point.
3. Devestation - really a hypocrite but accusing sudai of being hypocritical
4. Far_Cry - attacking toast and pimj for some valid reasons and contribute a lot in other ways, which is pro-town, imo.
5. RealityFan - not much content again, but trying to be useful, which is pro-town.
6. Toast - that conversation-starting post is neutral to scummy. lurking and leaving the game under attack.
7. Boxman - not much content again. voted FC to give pressure.
8. Pimj - see my previous post which explain my vote on him. lurking and leaving the game under attack, like toast.
9. Saberwolf - pretty much leading the town. maybe town or scum trying to act pro-town.
10. manho - definitely innocent, imo.
11. Donkeyz - contribute lots to the game. my gut tell me he is innocent.
12. Sudai - is there someone think sudai is scummy, can that someone tell me why.
13. Chaco (replacing RobotPirateNinja) - looking for his posts.
if anyone agree or disagree my opinion, let me know.
Far_Cry wrote:saberwolf wrote:um....no? scumslip?Far_Cry wrote:
Here's the problem: you're hunting for information, not scum. Which is why if you don't find me (or Boxman) scummy, you shouldn't vote. You may claim that information will be useful for town,but lynching town is even better, right?
so...you not town then, so the rules don't apply to you? Just earlier your vote was an information vote.Far_Cry wrote:
I have to say, Bogre is right with this post. However, this "why are you a better lynch than ......" is stupid.Town does not need to lynch for information.
I wish I could say more but I have to go to school.
but wait a minute....Far_Cry wrote:
Rising's faction is probably already dead.So we can not be sure if what you said above happened. We have to take it into consideration, though.
But here at ISO 50:Far_Cry wrote:
Manho, you are basically cleared as scum(or at least scum in Rising's faction), but that doesn't mean you are town. For now, I don't believe you are part of another scum faction or the SK, but I will hold you in check.
So all of a sudden you go from uncertain to very certain, certain enough to classify someone in rising's faction or the other faction? What gives?Far_Cry wrote:
Two mafia factions seems unlikely, but still possible. However town shouldn't care about the setup a lot. We should just hunt scum/SKs.