@Prana
Prana wrote:We don't know if Devotress is scum or town. At the moment I don't think anyone finds her potential scum. By that logic we should ignore the Doom counter and let whoever is given it die without caring. Is that what you are suggesting? (I expect an answer here)
Yes because as much as it's dangerous for town, you can use the kill to confirm the people who's been doomed. Yes someone dies, and this is only bad if Devo is town or you have a strong town read on him. So yes I'm saying
Doom is something we can use to confirm the person
.
Issues though:
This is very likely scum directed, so we're hoping for cross kills using this angle. The other thing is to remove neutral reads via kills so we don't carry them through lylo, but that's weaker scum hunting.
Doom is dangrous, but we shouldn't be crippled by it. Just because someone dies within voting doesn't mean we should stop voting. Look at the lack of activity. Scum would thrive in this enviroment since they'll just sit back and let the town be in fear of it.
Pra wrote:With the kills, you're suggesting I'm saying that none of the other abilities could potentially be a vig or SK. It could, potentially, be that the Lightning is a vig/SK, the Doom is from one mafia, and the Drowned stuff from another group. I have no clue personally, others seem to have better ideas about that than I do. But Doom is definitely not likely to be a SK without making the game impossible for the SK to win.
Hello. Remember the Arguments on why it couldn't be vig? Glork remember that argument? You two are the most inconsistant in your theories.
I suggested this earlier and got hounded over it since the N1 kill. Also apparently many of the targets have been protown. Starbuck was a very, very poor choice in kill for any Vig. Reck by reputation is a poor choice, etc, etc.
@Glork
Glork wrote:Orange Mafia = Reduced to Nothingness / Doom kills
SK = Electrocuted Kills
"Red Mafia" = Iece Death Miller
"Drowning" kill = Vigilante
This is horrible. This means multiple kills have failed/hit the same person. This also gives Orange Mafia Day and Night kills. In fact this game is so swingy that town would lose in 3 days in a WCS. There is this thing called Balanced you know.
You know what, this post bugs me beyond belief.
To be continued since I'm at work.