Scummies 2010 Nominations

[animorpherv1]

Nominate the Town of SpyreX's Star Control Part 2 for Best Town

Honestly, I think (with the exception of my shit of a claim) town did amazing.

[wolframnhart]

Nominate

DrippingGoofball

for

Best Replacement

in

Kingdom Hearts Mafia

.

Replaced a player who had all-but-claimed his role D1, come under scrutiny, then lurked to replacement. Adapted beautifully to her situation by balancing measured suspicion-baiting to avoid the NK with town-leading to survive as an outed tracker nearly to endgame while catching pretty much every scum not caught by investigation along the way in a Large game.

third

[DrippingGoofball]

My favorite moment was catching two scums in row with shenanigans involving denying being roleblocked! I have to do this again sometime.

[Nicodemus]

I'm nominating Ythill for

Best Flavor Writer for New York 113: Mafia in Mendo

. The drug cartel flavor was really interesting and allowed for some great role claim opportunities.

[Hayker]

Nominate

DrippingGoofball

for

Best Replacement

in

Kingdom Hearts Mafia

.

Replaced a player who had all-but-claimed his role D1, come under scrutiny, then lurked to replacement. Adapted beautifully to her situation by balancing measured suspicion-baiting to avoid the NK with town-leading to survive as an outed tracker nearly to endgame while catching pretty much every scum not caught by investigation along the way in a Large game.

third

fourth!

[Deer]

I'm nominating Ythill for

Best Flavor Writer for New York 113: Mafia in Mendo

. The drug cartel flavor was really interesting and allowed for some great role claim opportunities.

seconding this

Great flavor, Ythill.

[ReaperCharlie]

Rescinded.

[animorpherv1]

Nominate: Knight of Cydonia

for Best Flavor Text ("Paperback Writer" award) for

Werewolf: Wisborg Asylum.

...and we are only in Night 1!

*headdesk* No talking about ongoing games. PERIOD.

[Deer]

I don't think discussing the flavor of the game gives away anything about it...

I do enjoy the flavor though, KoC.

[Starbuck]

I don't think discussing the flavor of the game gives away anything about it...

Mith's Forum Rules & Guidelines that everyone is supposed to read and stay updated on at all times.

Do not talk outside the game thread about an ongoing game except where allowed to do so by your role. Likewise, do not use bbcode to hide secret messages - this equates to discussion outside the thread.

[Knight of Cydonia]

Also: it's

flavour

. Bloody Yanks.

[ooba]

Nominate

Mini 943 - Greek Mythology

for

Most Enjoyable Game

[Andrius]

Nominate Mini 943 - Greek Mythology for Most Enjoyable Game

I second this.
Wonderful game, with great flavor and powers. But best of all were the other players. It was a wonderful game from start to finish (even though I replaced in), and I will miss every player there. lol Even the players I killed. lol

[Scummies]

Updated as of 362

[Shadow Dancer]

OK, +1 for Greek mythology... The absolutely hillarious finale alone made this game special (see Andrius' sig to get an idea).

Maybe we should also nominate it for worst town endgame or something...

[zoraster]

Nominate the Mafia of Pledge of Allegiance for Best Scum Team

I was thoroughly impressed by the TEAMWORK that these guys showed.

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... c&&start=0 for the thread, but almost more importantly, take a look at the QT:

http://www.quicktopic.com/44/H/Kit5bYqWBfn

[Andrius]

The absolutely hillarious finale alone made this game special (see Andrius' sig to get an idea).

Maybe we should also nominate it for worst town endgame or something...

lol Yeah, the ending is totally worth reading/playing. lol Given I had to get my surviving scumbuddies killed in order to win.

Is there an award for "Worst Town Endgame"? lol

[StrangerCoug]

Can a player nominated for one game be nominated in the same category for another?

Regardless,

nominate MacavityLock for Most Cunning Manipulation.

Start reading here, because that's the post that, once people started taking him as confirmed, sealed the game for us.

[zoraster]

Can a player nominated for one game be nominated in the same category for another?

Regardless,

nominate MacavityLock for Most Cunning Manipulation.

Start reading here, because that's the post that, once people started taking him as confirmed, sealed the game for us.

My theory: technically, they should not be. It should be amended to the original nomination. This is because the category is called "Body of Work" which refers to the play in general of the player. Most nominations, however, attempt to provide some evidence of that body of work through a game or games. Therefore, this should be added to the nomination he already has.

That said, I don't see macavitylock nominated for that award already.

[animorpherv1]

can nominate multiple people for the same game, I think.

[zoraster]

can nominate multiple people for the same game, I think.

I don't think that's his question.

[Mr. Flay]

zoroaster appears to be correct on this one. The award can consider more than one game, but it should be a single nomination.

[StrangerCoug]

I managed to confuse Ythill and Ythan, so I guess I do get to make it a fresh nomination. I'll be a good sport and

nominate Ythan for Best Mafia Catcher

, also for Mini 945. Even though he lost, it's not that often you jail three Mafiosi trying to make the kill in a row.

[Ythan]

What saved ML was the fact that there was a miller and no cop so he had a free claim.

[MacavityLock]

As it is a Body of Work award, I would also like to put forward my other scum wins this year: Little Golden & Jekyll.

Also,

second Ythan for Mafia Catcher

.