Of Gods And Men (GAME OVER!)

[Fate]

I ALWAYS LYNCH SCUM. SOMETIMES THEY"RE JUST NOT MAFIA.

THEY'RE FUCKING SURVIVOR

[Nikanor]

It's a wasted lynch.
We've got 6 mafia and a cult in this game, Fate. Do you really think we can spend lynches on survivors?

[Fate]

So you want to play the "oh let's hope the survivor doesn't turn on us in LyLo" BECAUSE SHE WILL.

THEY ALWAYS FUCKING WELL.

SOMEONE GET AN ASSASSIN VIG SHOT I SWEAR

[Iecerint]

Back!

There's no guarantee this game will make it to lylo. Fate is approaching suspension of disbelief for intentional-scumminess-as-town.

I have crap daytalkers.

[Fate]

K Iec is definitely scum now.

Throw him in the "I don't want to lynch the survivor that will help me win later" bin

Anyone else?

[Nikanor]

Are you calling me scummy as well, then?
Fate, we are not lynching Plum today.

[Fate]

No, you're already in the townie bin.

You guys are going to get fucked by Plum endgame and I'll be RIGHT HERE WAITING with my "I FUCKIN TOLD YOU SO" sign

Unvote
Vote: TNM

[manho]

we can just ask the vig to nk plum, and if she is actually un-nk'able, we can lynch her before lylo.

[Mighty Orbots]

FINALLY someone calls for me NK, thanks Papa Z.

YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAH I changed my mind. Bunny, shoot Chronopie instead.

UNVOTE: Chronopie
VOTE: Fate

we can just ask the vig to nk plum, and if she is actually un-nk'able, we can lynch her before lylo.

Welcome to manhoville. Population: tire.

[Fate]

TROLL DID YOU APPROVE OF THAT WASTE?

[manho]

do anyone know whether we will get our iso tab back?

[Faraday]

no point wasting a lynch on plum at this stage. she can be vigged I guess so that can always be dealt with in that way.

need to read back to get my bearings in this game though, hold on.

[Faraday]

I'd prefer to know what the modification on Plum's role is. If she's wanting to work with the town it'd be at least better to give full disclosure of her win con.

[Albert B. Rampage]

UNVOTE: Chronopie
VOTE: Fate

Hope you're a jester fate

[manho]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: fate

let's lynch the scum

[Plum]

I'd prefer to know what the modification on Plum's role is. If she's wanting to work with the town it'd be at least better to give full disclosure of her win con.

I've given full disclosure of my win condition. My modification involves no killing actions - in fact, no active actions at all. I have no actions to perform on a regular basis, and my modification cannot cause Town death (or scum death or anything death for that matter - or Limbo or anything like that). My modification merely helps me survive.

[Nikanor]

Unvote. Vote: manho.

I don't like the Fate wagon. I really don't like how manho posted, ignoring Fate, and then posted again to vote Fate after he saw a bandwagon building.

[dramonic]

arguably, Fate's play towards the survivor is awful
But it's not scummy. He has no reason scum to mind a survivor, just like he has no reason as town to mind one.

How... peculiar...

[Katy]

While I disagree with Fate's assertion that we need to lynch the survivor now, I don't really see it as a scum move, especially when taken in context with his play so far this game. It's entirely consistent with how he's been playing the whole time. So yeah, I'm not going to lynch Plum but I also don't think it's a great idea to immediately leap to lynching Fate.

I've taken a look at chronopie (you can kind of iso people using the advanced search, although you get their posts for all games within the subforum - but it tells you the topic at the side so it's not too hard to separate as long as they're not in a ton of games) and I had totally forgotten about his claim. I believe his claim but I think his power is suspiciously neutral in alignment as, depending on how it works, it's just as likely to be a power that could help scum as help town. I'm also worried about the possibility of him being able to resurrect people and recruit them. Add to that his: "let's just lynch this guy and I'll res him if we're wrong, lol" which seems rather lackadaisical for town, especially since there's no guarantee he will be able to use his power if we did need it for that reason. Add to that the fact that his posting is consistent with "active lurking" which is usually my best scumtell - I agree with whoever said it that he's posting a lot about roles and game set-up and mechanics and not a lot of analysis of other players.

Unvote
Vote: Chronopie

[Iecerint]

@ dram

1. It depends on the scum win condition. Survivor lynching may be only marginally less good than a total mislynch for scum. 3rd party lynches also generate less information for town.
2. Even that aside, bizarreness is parsimoniously attributed to scum alignment IMO, anyway.

That doesn't mean he's the automatic lynch, but these constant 2SCUM4SCUM excuses for his behavior can only go so far.

[Snow_Bunny]

Unvote, vote: Chronopie

I think its time I move my vote to a more serious place. I find Fate's reaction towards Plum a bit scummy, but not enough to push his lynch. In fact, it even seems more like a lyncher reaction than scum. Any roads, tonight I can always go for either of them (:P), and settle this as grown ups.

[dramonic]

lack of iso is annoying.
What's the evidence against Chrono?

[Iecerint]

I think it's from when he was like "let's lynch whoever; then you can worship me and I'll fix any mistakes we make via resurrection" plan. Katy also speculated that he's the cult leader and can revive/recruit from the dead, which seems more than a little swingy, but ye never know.

People have countered the former by claiming 2SCUM4SCUM IIRC. Or maybe I just imagined it; it seems like there's a lot of scummy behavior that's just kinda gliding by. <_<

[BlazezRb]

MOD: VOTE COUNT PLZ!!!

I'm lost.

[Iecerint]

^ What do you mean?