Doing a review of yesterday.
Parama and ekiM and to a lesser extent SPS are the targets. ekiM is the only one who suspects cmar.
Mac's comment is:
My current read is that CMAR needs to go.
Then he has several questions for parama and horror.
His cmar vote:
Parama doesn't read as DDD's scumbuddy to me. CMAR definitely does. VOTE: CMAR. This is mostly based on a close skim, so deeper digging is required, but I want to plant a flag in a CMAR wagon for now.
At this point the day is up in the air. Staking out a claim on your buddies wagon is actually a very good move. And coincidentally that is exactly what Mac says ("plant a flag for now").
ekiM is pushing cmar, and I am saying that cmar is next most likely scum.
Horror puts Par at L-1 for shaky reasoning.
I think if you look at this day, after the parama lynch cmar is the next lynch. He hasn't claimed, and the other people are Jack, ekiM (both anti-cmar) the claimed cop and the claimed hider (who will look a lot better when Par flips town). So it is ideal play for Mac to push the cmar lynch. I actually think his reasoning here is very shoddy:
MacavityLock wrote:People, the following post does not come from scum buddied with DDD.
Parama wrote:WHOOPS DEADLINE PASSED AND I'M NOT CHANGING MY VOTE ANYWAYS. NOT THAT I NEED TO. I BET WE JUST LYNCHED THE MOST POWERFUL TOWN ROLE ON ACCIDENT OR SOMETHING. OR WE LYNCHED SCUM AND MY ML/EKIM THEORY IS WRONG. IF DDD FLIPS SCUM EKIM IS STILL SCUM THOUGH.
Okay, done with the caps for now.
The following is the
only
mention of DDD in WNH and CMAR combined play.
CryMeARiver wrote:
Page 4
...
DDD and Jack argument-I think Jack is just trying to be funny, but DDD has a good point +little town points
We lynch CMAR today.
It is not a good argument for Par's innocence and not a good argument for cmar's guilt. For Mac, it is ideal if Par is lynched while he is urging for cmar.
cmar's reaction to that case:
CryMeARiver wrote:
Sweeeeeeeeeeeeet, now show me one game where I ever buddied my scumbuddy
Good luck with that since I try to either stay away from them or bus them
Parama, more setup WIFOM and AtE is awesome
Not the slightest bit hostile.
********
So this smells like a bus from the start, with no power behind it in case the town wants to lynch parama. Which we very, very, very nearly did.
Additionally, by PoE:
Parama and Horror have roles that match the flavor and work together. Weird, but it works.
SPS--cop, role actually does match flavor, town seems underpowered without him.
ekiM--has been obv town all game, killed DDD at deadline.
Additionally parama and SPS have been tunneling on an obvtown player which in retrospect is too silly for them to be scum.
***************
Ok, I think that's everything on Mac. He has been on both scum wagons, but NOT AT ALL in the way a townie would be on those wagons. This is how you catch bussing scum people.
The "town seems underpowered without an SPS-cop" argument is still up in the air. I'm not good at setup analysis. I think it works though. 4 scum, and the town roles are doctor, hider, and limited namecop? Well I don't know what swordsman does unfortunately. In 3-1-8 games town can mislynch twice and lose.