Newbie 996 - Starting Small [Game Over]

[drmyshottyizsik]

Oh and cause(and I know I did this too and I'm sorry) he called mist jims maybe scum partner, but didnt vote jim. I mean why call someone obv scum, but vote for someone else?

[jimfinn]

I decided to reread the thread several times, even after my PBPA, before deciding who to vote on, and as for the late unvote, I forgot I still had a vote out, but promptly unvoted it even before deciding who was most deserving.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Jim I still find you scummy, but Moose is just more so

[moose200x]

aww doc , I do want to be your friend

[Black Mist]

Okay now I'm not all that certain about your Doc. I didn't really see where you stated your reasons for voting me(I'll reread to check), but you switch vote to Moose for voting me, even though he posted his reasons. I'm confused now.

[moose200x]

Okay now I'm not all that certain about your Doc. I didn't really see where you stated your reasons for voting me(I'll reread to check), but you switch vote to Moose for voting me, even though he posted his reasons. I'm confused now.

Nice point. I want to know why Mr. sikshotty is joining (mostly)random bandwagons. Gotta love his reasoning "moose seems scummy" Very thought provoking.

[jimfinn]

I still think Moose is a bit scummy and he and Doc are too buddy-buddy with each other. I'm going to go ahead and switch my vote from one of my top suspects to the other, since Doc's recent wagon hopping is a bit much for me. UNVOTE: mooseVOTE: :docshotty

[kunkstar7]

:: VoteCount 1x6 ::

moose200x (1) -

drmyshottyizsik

chaodck (1) -

Johannes583

Doubtful (1) -

chaodck

Johannes583 (0) -
Black Mist (1) -

moose200x

jimfinn (1) -

Parama

Parama (0) -
drmyshottyizsik (3) -

Doubtful, Cliquey, jimfinn

Cliquey (0) -

Not Voting (1) -

Black Mist

With 9 Alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline - September 2, 2010 5:00PM EST.

[Parama]

I still think Moose is a bit scummy and he and Doc are too buddy-buddy with each other.

I think you're more buddy-buddy with Doc than moose is, to be honest.

DMSIS's vote hop is really bad, though. It looks like he's trying to jump of the BM wagon now that it's breaking down and jump onto another easy target with weak reasoning. I think it warrants an

unvote, vote: DMSIS

.

ZOMG HE PUT HIM AT L-1!!! *shock and awe*
Yes, L-1. Don't hammer lest ye face my wrath.

[moose200x]

WoW... I feel like my hands are tied! If I don't lynch doctor shot gun then I will look like we are partners. If I hammer and he isn't mafia... I am going to the big rope swings night 2............

[Parama]

Wait for a defense and a claim, please.

[moose200x]

Who started this docshotty lynch anyways?

[Black Mist]

I think it was Cliquey that voted for him first. I'm tempted to place my vote on the Doc, but I think I will to see his reaction.

[moose200x]

He is all but getting lynched so let's just take it slow until he has time to respond. If doc is the mafia scum, what's our next step? I am rereading trying to figure who could be his

life partner

mafia partner.

If he is town I already have two scum in mind that I shall be zeroing in on for the rest of the game.

[Black Mist]

I find it abit Ironic that you are doing the exact thing you accused me of doing Mr. Moose. I say we look at the possible ways they could have presented themselves. Like the method or style they played.

[moose200x]

I find it abit Ironic that you are doing the exact thing you accused me of doing Mr. Moose. I say we look at the possible ways they could have presented themselves. Like the method or style they played.

Ah, see, I am not planning lynches, I am talking about what i plan to do during the down time from n-1 to d-2.

[Doubtful]

He is all but getting lynched so let's just take it slow until he has time to respond. If doc is the mafia scum, what's our next step? I am rereading trying to figure who could be his

life partner

mafia partner.

If he is town I already have two scum in mind that I shall be zeroing in on for the rest of the game.

Black Mist, the difference between what you were doing and what Moose IS doing right now is that you just stated: Lynch X. If town, lynch Y. If scum, lynch Z, without any real reason behind why you think Y and Z have to do with X.

What Moose is doing, he said he will be analyzing player again and deciding what to do in the case that DMSIS is indeed lynched. He didn't state any people in particular, so he doesn't need to provide reasons yet. Right now, all you can say is that he thinks DMSIS is scum.

[Johannes583]

I am not planning lynches, I am talking about what i plan to do during the down time from n-1 to d-2.

So, are you claiming to be either a powerrole, or mafia?

[moose200x]

I am not planning lynches, I am talking about what i plan to do during the down time from n-1 to d-2.

So, are you claiming to be either a powerrole, or mafia?

Rolefishing much?

I am rereading trying to figure who could be his mafia partner.
If he is town I already have two scum in mind that I shall be zeroing in on for the rest of the game.

Ah, see, I am not planning lynches, I am talking about what i plan to do during the down time from n-1 to d-2.

I am talking about how I plan to reread during the night and scum hunt. I don't see how this is a scumtell or claiming to be a pr.

[Johannes583]

The thing is, you could reread the thread at any time after the lynch. Anyone could. It doesn't make sense to me why you would mention that you are

specifically

referencing the fact that you will be doing this

during

the night phase. The only people who would have extra incentive to do would be one of those mentioned above.

We can't always assume there will be powerrolles in every game, but we know there will always be mafia. Assuming random selection of role distribution, the ratio of mafia to powerroles is 8:4. So if you really do have a good reason to reread the thread at night, the odds state that it is most likely because you are mafia looking for a victim.

[moose200x]

Ok. Let me break this down slowly

List time! Facts of our recent conversation.

1. Lynch is forthcoming.
2. Lynch's end the day.
3. At End of the day we get new info, MAJOR INFO
4. End of the day begins the night.
5. During the night we cannot post.
6. If we can't post how can we scumhunt?
7. Rereading can help me scumhunt.

Your question:

why you would mention that you are specifically referencing the fact that you will be doing this during the night phase. The only people who would have extra incentive to do would be one of those mentioned above.

Answer: By the 7 facts you can see that I am anticipating the night phase (fact #1&2) and am preparing myself to scumhunt at night (fact #6 & 7) so I was asking what everyone else is thinking to give me their thoughts while I do #7. Combine people's thoughts on the lynch AND #3 and we all are getting a lot of new stuff to double check.

I hope this answer's your question.

[moose200x]

Where is good ole, doc shotty?

[Johannes583]

I realize that. I'm just saying that your original statement implied that you had a decision to make at night. And everything you've mentioned could be accomplished at any time after the lynch, unless you needed to finish doing it before night ended. I'm only pointing that out.

Night will come, no matter what. The game cannot end without somebody being lynched, whether it's DMSIS as you expect, or somebody else.

[moose200x]

I'm just saying that your original statement implied that you had a decision to make at night. And everything you've mentioned could be accomplished at any time after the lynch, unless you needed to finish doing it before night ended. I'm only pointing that out.

Rolefishing, again.

[moose200x]

Let me rephrase that. Since there MAY only be 2 power roles it's doubtful you'd rolefish to find who is which one, more like your fishing to see if I'm any power role.

So I will call it "Non-vanilla townie" fishing.