Mafia 42: Italian - Game over!

[Zippy]

i am in the sticks of arkansas with limited dial up access but will catch up...

[Gonzo]

We seem not to have hit any good potential lynches so far, as they are either correct information roles or testable pro-town roles.

So, let's try

unvote, vote Gonzo

, as he hasn't been to productive yet.

Should I be?

I'm plenty productive if i'm trying to be suspicious.

[JSexton]

Nothing, really. This wagon never sat well with me. At first I got what JSexton was saying, but I think Illumina has defended himself well enough.

Vote: JSexton

::waves::

As well as one can at this point in the game, sure. That's why I unvoted a few pages ago.

[BabyJesus]

I still think Illumina is scum.

[Fritzler]

Me too. I cna't believe I'm not voting him.

unvote vote: illuminia

[TSAGod]

We seem not to have hit any good potential lynches so far, as they are either correct information roles or testable pro-town roles.

So, let's try

unvote, vote Gonzo

, as he hasn't been to productive yet.

Should I be?

I'm plenty productive if i'm trying to be suspicious.

Do

you have a suicidal role? That'd be pretty awesome.

[Flying Dutchman]

Why is Ilumia still alive?! I'm just waiting untill enough players realize the incredibility of the claim.....

[zu_Faul]

What is so incredible about it?

[Gonzo]

We seem not to have hit any good potential lynches so far, as they are either correct information roles or testable pro-town roles.

So, let's try

unvote, vote Gonzo

, as he hasn't been to productive yet.

Should I be?

I'm plenty productive if i'm trying to be suspicious.

Do

you have a suicidal role? That'd be pretty awesome.

Hmm... You never know... Do ya...

[Blackberry]

Hmmmmmm, I'm very tempted to switch my vote to Gonzo.

How come NOBODY has responded to my post about me claiming?

[Phoebus]

Vote count:

Gonzo - 2 (PeaceBringer, TSAGod)

Illumina - 6 (micigante, Iammars, Nanook, d8P, Vesuvan, Fritzler)

Jabroni2000 - 1 (inHim)
PookyTheMagicalBear - 2 (Flying Dutchman, Gonzo)
Flying Dutchman - 1 (Monty)
LyingBrian - 2 (BabyJ, LyingBrian)
1 JSexton (Jabroni)

13 Votes to lynch

Deadline: 1200 ET, Thursday the 24th

[d8P]

Oh, I'd forgotten you asked. I have no objection to it.

[LyingBrian]

if you want to, go right ahead, i don't care...

[Fritzler]

Whatever. Your call thumper

[Gonzo]

Hmmmmmm, I'm very tempted to switch my vote to Gonzo.

How come NOBODY has responded to my post about me claiming?

Whatever. Doesn't matter to me if you tell the world what you are...

Reminds me of a quote!

"Superladies, they're always trying to tell you their secret identity. Think it'll strengthen the relationship, or something like that. I say: girl, I don't want to know about your mild-mannered alter ego. You say that you're a... Ultra Mega Lightning Babe or something like that, that's all right with me. I'm good. I'm good. "

[Yosarian2]

It's up to you Blackberry; none of the rest of us really have enough information to give good advice.

[inHimshallibe]

Ah. Sorry.

Unvote: Jabroni

Vote: Illumina

[NanookTheWolf]

Unvote: Gonzo, Not Vesuvan

... I only Fos'd Vesuvan, and

Vote: Illumina

.. I wasn't going to vote for you, but your constant avoidance of claiming has made me more interested in you.

Still good on that one,

Also in response to BB .. if you feel it's beneficial, then shoot.

[inHimshallibe]

And - activity will be spotty (as I assume will be the case for most) throughout this week.

[Flying Dutchman]

Why is Ilumia still alive?! I'm just waiting untill enough players realize the incredibility of the claim.....

What is so incredible about it?

He's claiming abilities a godfather is likely to have, and we have no way to prove or disprove them. I find it unlikely his claimed role is in this game....

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Cuz Godfathers are very likely to be able to investigate a player to see if they're out committing a nightaction or not!

Why yes sir, I've seen godfathers that can do that all the time!

*end sarcasm*

seriously FD, find me one game where a GF was able to do this.

[Illumina]

^ Exactly. It makes more sense to take advantage of the fact that my role's test-able, rather than killing me out of exaggerated suspicion created by this flimsy bandwagon.

Twice now I've asked the specific players voting for me to present their reasoning, and more are lurking than have bothered to reply. I wonder how many of the latter will actually respond, or if they're content to jump on a popular bandwagon and stay there.

We're at a stage where my role has been claimed, and people are still intent in killing me off. All of this because of

what

, exactly? Think about it. I've not seen nearly enough to warrant it.

(I'll still be around intermittently, I'm catching internet where I can.)

[StevieT92]

First, you had a kinda sketchy claim, and then you don't end up dead with a powerful role. That's people's reasoning, but I'm still undecided, really.

[Vesuvan]

one game where a GF was able to do this.

Mafia Vengeance (Misetings). Godfather also roleblocker.

Hate to say this, but agree with BabyJesus.

[Yosarian2]

one game where a GF was able to do this.

Mafia Vengeance (Misetings). Godfather also roleblocker.

Hate to say this, but agree with BabyJesus.

Then again, being a godfather and a roleblocker still wouldn't give you the information you'd need to pull off a fake "is X out of his house or not" every night. In order to properly fake that claim, he'd have to be a godfather who knew he was proof against nightkills and also be an investigator, or be scum buddies with an investigator.