Conclusions of my reread:
Town
NintendoAddict1 - Posts
166 and
194 are clearly town sentiments. I don't know how anyone can read him as scum for those two posts alone. That being said, Nintendo you are chasing wild arguments all over the place and you need to be a little more objective in your scum hunting. You made cases on Seraphim and Trumpet of Doom that are extraordinarily weak. Seraphim saying he thinks someone is town but doesn't know is not a scum slip. Likewise, ToD giving a null read on someone is not a scum slip.
Nikanor - Town thoughts on band claiming and genuine reaction to the Furry fake-daykill. That being said, he hasn't posted since Tuesday in this game. I saw scum come in strong townie in Dynasty Warriors and then taper off. This read is very subject to change. It's primarily based on the first few pages.
Demonhybrid - On reread I see lots of townie thoughts from Demon that I didn't really pick up on the first time through.
Leaning Town
Trumpet of Doom - I had ToD in the "leaning town" column before he replaced in based on animorph. This is mainly because animorph, while yes a bit of OMGUS, actually tried to reason why Furry would day kill him as scum. Several of his reads are within the margin of error of my reads. Only a couple that are completely off.
Seraphim - his posts have been overall townie in nature. His defenses on cases against him do not read as scum to me.
Furry - The gambit reads town. I also really appreciate
this bit of scumhunting.
Null
Gorilla - I did have him leaning town when I initially made this list but for the life of me I can't find why now. It may have been the "call me out on lurking" post and the fact that he didn't rage about my daykill. I am moving him down to null to be sure.
Gaoth - Gaoth hasn't done anything overtly scummy or townie but our reads don't match up very well at all.
Regfan - Regfan is difficult to read for me because I disagree with his case on me. The most blatant argument I find is the one where he says I am "paranoid" for asking if something is scummy. This is just a ridiculous argument and feels like reaching.
Groundsel - I just don't know on him yet. I do like his postings but not enough to stick him in the town column yet. The fact that he keeps bringing up that he didn't get Serial Killer isn't sitting well with me but I can't put my finger on why.
Cogito Ergo Sum - I would like to put him in my town column but his reads are too vague right now. All his posts are short and some are just declarative "player x is scum". I'd like more in depth analysis from him but I do need to meta to see if this is his playstyle.
AntB- Post
212 is a different opinion which I can't tell if it is town or scum motivated. I think AntB is the only one that think BOTH daykills are scummy. I would like AntB to reconcile me and Furry on scum team together for the record. I also don't like her opportunistic jump on the Nintendo wagon.
Parama (CryMeARiver) - No read obviously. Non-existent.
CSL - Similar to CES. Short and declarative posts. I think this is CSL's playstyle though. I just don't have a read on it at the moment.
Leaning Scum
Parabollocks - Not alot of original thoughts coming from Parabollocks. He parrots in most all his arguments. His misrepresentation that I "disappeared" when I was sleeping really rubbed me the wrong way. Also post
227 reads as opportunistic scum to me.
Scum
Evilpacman18 - Argh. If EPM is town he is the most frustrating town EVER. And he is playing quite different than our last game together in speed mafia where he primarily lurked and didn't really get involved. Anyway, more specific examples are: Posts
137,
221,
265,
338,
366 and
443 followed by
494. Basic summary here is that he has inconsistent views and is floundering scum.
Diddin - I don't like
here where he declares furry town for daykilling but me scum for the exact same thing. He is also
clearly skimming the thread and I am intrigued by the "slip" i mentioned in Furry's section above.
Powerrox93 - I get a general bad feeling from reading Powerrox but his most telling problem is that he hops on bandwagons in the most opportunistic ways.
Pine - He was my original scum read so I will direct you to
here for the reasons. One more I picked up on reread is his change from
this to
this in less than half an hour. Also,
176 declares Nintendo scum based on meta but gives no examples or reasons. But this is by far the
most scummy post. He basically disappears after that.
All that said, I will happily
Unvote, Vote: EPM