Hyperion wrote:So you don't necessarily think he is scum (you have a neutral read on him) but you want to vote for him anyways? Just because he does not agree wth you? And you have a town read on Chronos after he posts twice, both being about theory and game mechanics. Can you say scumbudies? VOTE: Arinna
Hyperion wrote:OK, so to generate discusion, how does everyone feel about Arinna's town read on Chronos and vote on Axxle from Post 25 (<--- I think I did that right, if not just look at post 25). I think it seems rather scummy, anyone else see any validity in her town read, do you think she could be scumbuddies with Chronos and trying to protect him early? Does anyone want to submit any thought at all?
No, I do not think that anyone is necessarily scum right now, but I most certainly do not see a problem with voting for someone whose idea regarding the subject seemed anti-town to me. (I know that this isn't the case all the time, but disagreeing with someone regarding a certain type of policy lynch would mean that I think that the opposite view could potentially be harmful.) And I also do not think that a first vote on someone in such an early stage has to have very sound evidence backing it (we
Regarding my town read, it will probably change. However, he
Am I and Chronos scumbuddies? Maybe. Maybe not. I can't defend myself, as it would enter a WIFOM argument, which is not needed right now.
Axxle wrote:In post 31, wombat99 wrote:In post 24, Seacore wrote:That is patently false LC. You may think that an RVS isn't helpful, and I'd agree with you, but to say it doesn't exist as a concept is wrong. As an SE please try and be clear about when you're giving your opinion.
Also, it's a weekend , so let's not get worked up about some players not posting.
I think he's saying there's not an official RVStage with an ending time then suddenly mafia becomes serious.
Vote Seacorefor either skimming or being deliberately obtuse.
I don't like that LC said "There isno such thingas the RVS." Thatisa lie, one that can be confusing to new players. If he said something like "The Random Voting Stage is..." and then proceeded to the rest of that post that would be better. It was probably just a mistake made out of hatred for the RVS but don't attack someone for thinking it's misleading when itismisleading. I don't think LordChronos meant anything bad by it, but VOTE: wombat for attacking someone for being "obtuse" while himself not trying to understand.
Also just fyi:for voting you can use the[vote][/vote] tags instead of bold.(Do you mind if I use blue for things like this, Seacore?)
Regarding this whole branch of discussion, it seemed to me as though Wombat was indeed overreacting, but I think it was good, as it generated some discussion and material~
Axxle wrote:Arinna strikes me as one of those people with strong convictions fast and early, grabbing at every bit of evidence she can. And that's good. Especially at these early stages. I think she'll sound as convinced at every stage of the game, whether or not she is able to change those ideas of who's town or not remains to be seen.
This is actually a surprisingly good observation of what I had been trying to do. And yes, my opinions
---
And in fact, my town read on Lord Chronos has slid back to a null. Lord Chronos, Wombat, Seacore, Mortontfrh, Balnazzar, what do you think of Hyperion's attacks on me?
Axxle, Hyperion, Mortontfrh, Balnazzar, what do you think about this theoretical discussion that has been going on? (To clarify, I am not asking you about the RVS, but what has been going on between Chronos, Wombat and Seacore, and its implications, if any.)