Newbie 1368 - Will there ever be a title? (GAME OVER)

[Grimgroove]

Ok, fine, I'm willing to move my vote to him.

But if he's lynched and it's not him, and I would die before LyLo, I

BEG

you to lynch Majiffy.

Enomis is not scum. Syryana is not scum. Homertve is not scum.

[Grimgroove]

Fuck it.

VOTE: Core_H86

This is

L-1

!

[homertve]

Grim, can you explain again your case on majiffy? (You can either explain it again or refer me to the relevant post)

Also, I do not think we're on L-1.

@mod, can we get a vote count?

[Grimgroove]

Majiffy, Homertve and Grimgroove are voting him, and with 6 palyers, you need four for a lynch, so this is definitely L-1.

[Grimgroove]

I'm not sure if he checked the topic, but I know for a fact Majiffy was online during this endphase, so it is possible he

chose

not to hammer.

pedit: Good!

Are you still the same enomis? your posting style seems to have changed considerably?

I'm reading enomis as town now by the way. His L-1 on Rach was crucial to getting her lynched, the alternative could have easily ended up in a stalemate with nobody the wiser.

Reading Core's posts he really seemed very intent on moving the wagon away from RachMarie and on to enomis. Core lost his strong townread.

Buit MAjiffy remains my number 1 suspect for the time being.

"random" lurker? Are you seriously bringing that up again? Please don't offend, thank you, definitely if you haven't read the first 30 pages.

I still think Majiffy is the more obvious choice though. Look at his posts. He claimed toh ave a strong townread on her, yet never explained why. After some shenanigans at the end of the first daystage her read her a slight town. He called me "dumb as bricks" for believing RachMarie was scum. If anyone was defending her, it was him.
He was online during the end of the previous day. He posted in other topics at the time,b ut not here, choosing not to be seen, choosing not to hammer. He was hoping for a no lynch rather thans ee his buddy lynched.

That's my main hypothesis.

My second is Core being scum with RachMarie. He was too ambiguous during the moment of truth, pushing for an enomis-lynch and not hammering RachMarie despite intent.

It's one of these two.

My townreads on enomis, Syryana and homertve are too strong to even consider voting them. I really don't see enomis' elaborate plan coming from scum simply trying to stall, homer.

What do you guys make of Majiffy and Core yourselves?

I think these posts summarize my thoughts on both lynch-candidates.

And if Core is the wrong lynch, simple PoE is enough to point to Majiffy-scum. All the others are obvtown in my book.

[Core_H86]

This is how I see it:

Core did one thing wrong: he did not include Majiffy in his theory of the triangles as possible scum, based on a flimsy argument that Majiffy was too much of a dick to be scum.

This was obviously a mistake, but how is it a scumtell?

No, I really don't see it.

Have you got anything else on Core? You do realize this is not enough right, even if it is 100 procent valid?

I want more people to share their thoughts on Majiffy. I have the impression that the mere fact he's being well, less than kind, makes him town. Along the lines of Core's thinking not to put him in the triangle. This is NOT enough.

I want to see more reasons why MAjiffy is town or why Core is scum before I even begin considering moving my vote.

what mistake cant i just play how i play the game does evolve as you learn new things

[homertve]

what mistake cant i just play how i play the game does evolve as you learn new things

Tell me one new thing you learn to make you suspect Majiffy.

[enomis]

I will get to this on friday. Spent too much of my energy on the other thread. I will only have mobile access to this thread tmr so expect from me short posts tmr.

[Edosurist]

VC 3.2

Core_H86

(1):Majiffy, homertve, Grimgroove

No Lynch

(1): enomis

Not voting

: Core_H86, Syryana

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

While I set my status to V/LA, I should be able to continue on for the rest of the game. If something happens and I don't have wifi where I'm going, ask Bitmap to take care of the thread while I'm unavailable.

Day 3 ends in

(expired on 2013-07-21 18:49:00)

.

[Majiffy]

you didn't read the game yourself

False

You did not know the set-up.
How can you not know the set-up if you read the game?
We were talking about a jailkeeper and you had no clue what that was all about, you didn't know a doctor had died earlier, an event that should leave a moment of pause that you have ignored.
You don't give two shits about this game and it is obvious. You probably even forgot to send in the night kill because you couldn't be bothered.

Simple question: is it necessary to read the OP to read what the players in the game have said and done? This is a yes or no question.

[Grimgroove]

No.

A simple question for you: Do you find nights and their outcomes irrelevant in a game of mafia?

[Majiffy]

In most games; definitely not. In newbies; less so. But still important.

[Grimgroove]

Then why didn't you read the night reports?

[Majiffy]

I am a minority of MS frequenters that feels night kill analysis (NKA, or NK analysis) is useful. Most players on this site dismiss it at WIFOM, but I think it is VERY useful. Along with VCA.

-pedit: Night reports?

Might I remind you that I give zero shits about this game, so please remind me of things I've missed.

[Grimgroove]

Oh this setup is 2 of 4 so yeah we don't know if it was doc or jk that stopped the kill, or if mafia no killed (unlikely) altogether.

Setup spec is unlikely to help us here.

You toyed with the possibility that the doc assured the absence of a kill in N2. The doc died in N1.
From someone who thinks night kills are important for analysis, this comes as a surprise.

[Grimgroove]

That said, I find Core's reply to the allegations and to the L-1 far too meek. We probably hit scum with that one.

[Majiffy]

Oh this setup is 2 of 4 so yeah we don't know if it was doc or jk that stopped the kill, or if mafia no killed (unlikely) altogether.

Setup spec is unlikely to help us here.

You toyed with the possibility that the doc assured the absence of a kill in N2. The doc died in N1.
From someone who thinks night kills are important for analysis, this comes as a surprise.

You toyed with the possibility of me being scum.
Considering you knew that I forgot the doc had died, this comes as a surprise.

That said, I find Core's reply to the allegations and to the L-1 far too meek. We probably hit scum with that one.

No shit.

[Grimgroove]

Oh this setup is 2 of 4 so yeah we don't know if it was doc or jk that stopped the kill, or if mafia no killed (unlikely) altogether.

Setup spec is unlikely to help us here.

You toyed with the possibility that the doc assured the absence of a kill in N2. The doc died in N1.
From someone who thinks night kills are important for analysis, this comes as a surprise.

You toyed with the possibility of me being scum.
Considering you knew that I forgot the doc had died, this comes as a surprise.

I'm so sorry. I feel so stupid now. You're absolutely right.
Let's lynch Core now and get this over with.

[Syryana]

VOTE: Core_H86

[Majiffy]

I'm so sorry. I feel so stupid now. You're absolutely right.
Let's lynch Core now and get this over with.

See, life is so much easier if you just listen to me in the first place.

[Syryana]

It would be so much easier to listen to you if you didn't turn every time someone didn't listen into a war.

[Majiffy]

Well, you know, if they just listened to me in the first place, we wouldn't have these problems, now would we?

[Grimgroove]

We hammered without a claim! That may have been a bit silly.
But ok. I've convinced myself this is the rgiht lynch, so until the flip I shall live in ignorant bliss.

If this isn't over, lynch Majiffy.
GG to everyone if it is over!

[Core_H86]

gg wish i could have put more time into it

[Core_H86]

and if you meta me you will know i am ALWAYS SCUM