Scummies 2007 Nominations Closed!

[klebian]

I'll nominate
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 905#538905

for funniest role claim. I know it's not going to win, but it's funny. I know it's an ongoing game, but man, it's a newbie game...

[remussaidow]

I was going to wait until the game ended, or at least he died, to nominate that...

[Zindaras]

You cannot nominate ongoing games.

[Mr. Flay]

* Funniest player - "The Coffee on the Monitor award"

Nominate Thestatusquo for, among other reasons, his current avatar, general hilarity, and making a previous winner snort her drink through her nose.

[Glork]

If TSQ wins, can we rename the award "The Coffee Up MeMe's Nose Award"?


EDIT (3/15): Second TSQ's nomination:

(14:15:33) GlorkTheInvader: rofl
(14:15:36) GlorkTheInvader: Shea
(14:15:40) GlorkTheInvader: Your "reading is a scumtell" post
(14:15:50) GlorkTheInvader: made me almost spit out my juice
(14:15:55) GlorkTheInvader: shit
(14:15:55) GlorkTheInvader: brb

[Thok]

Nominate Mr. Stoofer and Space Monkey Mafia for "Best Implementation of a Concept".

(I feel like this was a well-designed game but not a well-played game, and I want a nomination that specifically honors the set up design. A game with a uninformed majority that believes it's scum is hard to set up/balance well.)

[Trojan Horse]

Seconded.

Also for Space Monkey Mafia, I nominate petroleumjelly for Best Role Claim, for this claim.

[Thok]

I think Funniest role claim is more appropriate for PJ's claim than Best role claim.

[Trojan Horse]

Eh, have it your way. Funniest, then.

[Zindaras]

Best Implementation of a Concept is not a Scummie award. If you want to nominate it, I'd say that Best Role is the way to go.

And I'll second PJ for funniest claim.

[Thok]

Best Implementation of a Concept is not a Scummie award. If you want to nominate it, I'd say that Best Role is the way to go.

I'm making up an award to fit what I think best describes what should be honored. Phoebus will hack out the details later. (Best Role might be right, but somewhat misses the point.)

[TBuG]

1 d0|\|'7 7|-|1|\||< 1'LL 937 |\|0/\/\1|\|473D 7|-|1$ '/34r, 317|-|3r

[Mr. Flay]

I'd say Most Enjoyable Game Regular [free market/normal] is the category for it, Thok, even though you aren't talking about gameplay (regular there talks about size, not "normality").

We used to have the Best Theme/Adaptation Scummie, didn't we?

[Thok]

I'll nominateJoke PBug and MOS for "Least likely to be nominated for a scummy".

Of course, this completelyTotally disqualifies them from winningCelebrating.

[TBuG]

1 \/\/1|\|.

[GreenLiquid]

Joke nominations are strictly

forbidden

!

[klebian]

I'll nominate
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 905#538905

for funniest role claim. I know it's not going to win, but it's funny.



How about a best setup award?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

No ongoing games, klebian.

[Quagmire]

I second cubsfan's thoughts about scummies and their worth (or lack thereof).

[remussaidow]

well, the said funny claim was lynched...

[Primate]

Nominate Kelly Chen for funniest player.

[klebian]

No ongoing games, klebian.

Bah! I screwed up again!

[Mastermind of Sin]

*double post*

[Mastermind of Sin]

I'll nominateJoke PBug and MOS for "Least likely to be nominated for a scummy".

Of course, this completelyTotally disqualifies them from winningCelebrating.

I refuse this nomination.

[Dragon Phoenix]

Don't we have newbie nominations anymore?

If we do:
Nominate Whome? for his performance in he end game of Newbie 312:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4754