Bulbazak's Catchup Reads
Town
Kytoxid
: He's been actively scumhunting, and you can tell that he is actually trying to figure things out. Definitely town.
Thor665
: He's a strong player in general, and I agree with my predecessor's logic in relation to the night actions. Thor was more than likely targeted by the scum team, which suggests that scum do not want him in this game. This also makes newbie scum more likely, as most experienced scum know better than to aim at the IC n1 in a Newbie game. I like how he's trying to figure people's motivations out, and I agree with him in regards to Burn and Zipper. I also think that his interaction with Sakura during twilight of d1 is more likely to come from town than scum. Sorry, but I'm not lynching him under any circumstances today.
: I've recently come to understand how he thinks a little bit more, and he genuinely looks like he's trying to figure things out, although not effectively. He's probably town.
Cxinlee
: I liked Micc and got a general town feel from him. Cxinlee hasn't really done much overall, but I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for his predecessor's sake.
: Gale looked like he could have been a Newbie honestly trying to learn how to play. Sure, there were a few things that pinged, but that could have been the result of his newbiness. So overall, null. His replacement really didn't leave much of an impression either.
: I thought it was funny how many people called Zipper town because of his catchup posts. That just goes to show that they really didn't read them. Many players will actually write off walls as coming from town, regardless of the content, simply because they hold the notion that scum wouldn't put forth the effort. However, that is not the case. Take Zipper's catchup posts, for instance. All they are composed of are a bunch of quotes followed by filler. There's no critical analysis from these posts, just throwaway lines. It's simply put together for appearence's sake, rather than to actually scumhunt. Not to mention his votes have simply been following the general flow of the game, i.e. where the majority was going anyway. Then there is the Thor push, which is probably the most opportunistic thing in this entire game, using the momentum from a dead townie's final reads, which even she wasn't 100% positive on since she interacted with Thor in twilight AS IF HE WAS TOWN. I'm really not seeing the town motivation here.
Burn_209
: Where do I start... His posts are not genuine, rather very calculated and manipulative, meant to look like a lot, but saying very little. He also hasn't had very strong stances, always keeping his options open. You'll see things like, "Well, she might be scum, but she might not.", or that 48/52 crap. It's all meant to keep everyone on the table as possible lynch targets. His play just doesn't feel natural. He's trying too hard to act like town, rather than just being town. A good example of this is all of his complaining about nobody posting. If he actually had a problem with that, then why didn't he do something to try to stir up activity. Complaining about it does nothing, except put on the appearance of being pro-town. The same thing goes with his recent push to have everybody post reads lists. He was the only one that was asked to post one, but he then thinks "Hey, this looks like a thing a townie would do. I'm going to do it as well, so that maybe someone will think I'm town.". It's not done naturally, i.e. it's fake. And did anybody else catch him commenting on the lack of the night kill at the beginning of the day? I'm surprised Thor or somebody else didn't try to nail his feet to the floor for that one. Last but not least, let's look at what he's pushing others on. We're talking about things like sheeping, tunneling, and "trying to get a lynch on page 2", which are mostly null tells, but can seem significant enough for scum to try to push mislynches on. Face it, he's done zero serious scumhunting. He's just repeated the reasoning on others and waffled a lot until it looked like that person's wagon might take off. This is not town behavior. This is scum behavior, through and through.
Vote Zipperflesh
