NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[Huntress]

Vote Count 3.3

Albert B. Rampage (6) - Thor665, Zdenek, Sotty7, inHimshallibe, Aegor, HighShroomish
kabooooom (2) - Albert B. Rampage, Rainbowdash
HighShroomish (1) - Bulbazak

Not voting (6) - Chevre, kabooooom, emeraldemon, Garmr, Matias, Nero Cain


With fifteen players alive, it takes eight votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Three is now Tuesday, 11th March 20.00 GMT, (in (expired on 2014-03-11 20:00:00)).

Note:

Matias hasn't picked up his prod. Did anyone see a v/la message from him before the posts went missing?

Still looking for replacements for Garmr and Albert B. Rampage.
More prods will go out shortly.
Nero Cain is v/la till Friday.

[Zdenek]

I think that Kaboom has a higher than random chance of flipping scum, but not by a wide margin.

[Sotty7]

@Rainbowdash
The last two times we lynchee some one who was lurking, we got town. kabooooom is playing anti-town, yes, but not scummy, and I'm not about to lynch another lurker just to have them flip town. Our numbers are dwindling. We have 16 slots left in game, and 14 that are usable. Tomorrow, it's more than likely we'll be at 14. And if we still haven't caught any scum and we mislynch tomorrow, if there are six, which seems highly likely for a big game, the games over.

To people saying not to lynch the ABR slot- if I think it's scummy I'm gonna try to. And I do.

VOTE: ABR-SLOT

Why are you voting for the ABR slot if it isn't for lurking?

I like ABR more for scum than Kabooooom at this point which is why my vote is there. Switching to Kabooom would be more for his annoying info-less playstyle than me thinking he is scum.

[Zdenek]

Oh, I forgot to mention it before. Shroomish towntold big in that post. Scum will have to NK him.

[inHimshallibe]

vote: Albert B Rampage

I also have to admit I feel like the pony is misrepresenting their read since they're acting like Albert is still in the game.

This referencing the "culling the useless/lurker pool" bit?

Inhim goes from defending ABR to attacking him upon ABR saying that he'll replace out.

inhim is scum with ABR knowing that after ABR is replaced, he'll get to put his vote anywhere while pretending to be happy with the replacement.

We should lynch one of them.

Aegor, inhim, matais are all good scum picks.

but not ABR?

kaboom lynch is acceptable - primarily because of the awkward L-1 vote on emog.

I intend to continue voting ABR's replacement... ABR Day 1 is what I defended, I didn't ask for his Days 2 & 3.

Don't really have much of an opinion on kabooooom tbh.

[Bulbazak]

Oh, I forgot to mention it before. Shroomish towntold big in that post. Scum will have to NK him.

I didn't see a towntell. I saw a contradictory stance and opportunistic behavior.

[emeraldemon]

Time is freeing up for me, let's kick this game's ass!

VOTE: Aegor

@kaboom
The mod still hasn't officially called 1468 over so I wouldn't talk about that game yet.

@Aegor
It's one thing to go for the biggest wagon when there's three days left. We have more than a week left. I refuse to believe we can't do better than a policy lynch. Yet your favorite wagons have been Zekrom, Kaboom, ABR. What are your reads? You didn't like Chevre's vote Day 1, have you changed your mind?

TOWN
Thor665
Sotty7
Garmr
Bulbazak
inHimshallibe
HighShroomish
Rainbowdash
Zdenek
Albert B Rampage
Kaboom
Matias
Nero Cain
Chevre
Aegor
SCUM

I'm not convinced on the ABR lynch. At least Thor and Zdenek are posting reasons, but I feel like way too many people just see ABR as a lurker slot with votes on. If you want to policy lynch a lurker, you should start a wagon on Matias.

[Zdenek]

Oh, I forgot to mention it before. Shroomish towntold big in that post. Scum will have to NK him.

I didn't see a towntell. I saw a contradictory stance and opportunistic behavior.

Getting the number of scum oh so very wrong.

[emeraldemon]

I was voting kab earlier in the game. ABR is at L-1. Forgive me for thinking that he is the easiest lynch at this point. Nothing would give me greater pleasure than lynching kab tomorrow.

Are you looking for the easiest lynch or a lynch on scum?

Both? Either?

Bulba, vote Aegor, this is scummier than Highshroomish by a mile.

[Zdenek]

It's a bad stance for Aegor to take, but I'm thinking that it's genuine and that there's no reason for him to take it as scum.

[emeraldemon]

It's a bad stance for Aegor to take, but I'm thinking that it's genuine and that there's no reason for him to take it as scum.

Scum has a good motivation to keep lynching lurkers, especially town ones. The longer scum can keep town lynching based on activity level, the longer scum can stay alive just by posting semi-frequently.

[Zdenek]

Yet you were defending The Fonz yesterday - calling him your strongest town read, while he was pushing the lurker NS lynch.

[emeraldemon]

Exactly that. There is the issue.

Most of the ABR wagon seems to be going "oh yeah but kab wagon is fine" but have been avoiding it

. Never even mentioning him until I press the issue and the rest of the game is lurking not even talking about the wagon. The fact that I am probably fighting the wagon the most while saying "yeah its an okay lynch" it feels wrong. Good for information still yes, but wrong.

I agree completely. But all those posts are now part of this game's record, and their authors can be held accountable if they refuse to vote kab tomorrow.

This also, trying to set up a second policy lynch tomorrow? Weren't you talking about lynching Garmr tomorrow?

[emeraldemon]

Yet you were defending The Fonz yesterday - calling him your strongest town read, while he was pushing the lurker NS lynch.

In my mind NS wasn't just a lurker lynch. Obviously he was town and my read was wrong, but two things in particular bugged me: hopping blindly on the ABR wagon at the start of day 2 (957), and calling Chevre town (1035) but then backing off when I pressed him about it (1203). Also there were a few posts that just felt like fake-contributing, like 1074 and 1174.

[HighShroomish]

Oh, I forgot to mention it before. Shroomish towntold big in that post. Scum will have to NK him.

I didn't see a towntell. I saw a contradictory stance and opportunistic behavior.

Getting the number of scum oh so very wrong.

How the fuck is that a town-tell. Why does scum "need to NK me unless I'm actually about to screw them over.

[Zdenek]

Because scum know the number of scum. I think if you were faking it, you would have gone with a smaller number than 6.
Because you will never be lynched.

[Zdenek]

I really find how angry that made you upsetting.

[Aegor]

@Aegor
It's one thing to go for the biggest wagon when there's three days left. We have more than a week left. I refuse to believe we can't do better than a policy lynch. Yet your favorite wagons have been Zekrom, Kaboom, ABR. What are your reads? You didn't like Chevre's vote Day 1, have you changed your mind?

Chevre is basically null at this point. If you want reads, here is my lynchpool:

ABR, kab, Matias, any other lurkers, Garmr, inHim

Bulba's case on Garmr is sadly lost at the moment but basically convinced me. It would be sheeping, but I would have no problem voting Garmr. inHim's posts have been weakly-reasoned and just off all game.

[HighShroomish]

Because scum know the number of scum. I think if you were faking it, you would have gone with a smaller number than 6.
Because you will never be lynched.

Why would I have gone with a smaller number if I was faking it. I could have said seven, and have a chance to make everyone scramble around to try to lynch scum.

[Zdenek]

I think this is a stupid discussion. If you think I am scum ruling out your lynch, you can vote me.

[Zdenek]

vote: Albert B Rampage

I also have to admit I feel like the pony is misrepresenting their read since they're acting like Albert is still in the game.

This referencing the "culling the useless/lurker pool" bit?

Inhim goes from defending ABR to attacking him upon ABR saying that he'll replace out.

inhim is scum with ABR knowing that after ABR is replaced, he'll get to put his vote anywhere while pretending to be happy with the replacement.

We should lynch one of them.

Aegor, inhim, matais are all good scum picks.

but not ABR?

kaboom lynch is acceptable - primarily because of the awkward L-1 vote on emog.

I intend to continue voting ABR's replacement... ABR Day 1 is what I defended, I didn't ask for his Days 2 & 3.

Don't really have much of an opinion on kabooooom tbh.

Zd - inhim is scum with ABR and will move his vote saying that he is happy with the replacement.
inhim - no I won't
Zd - what you aren't going to try to read the slot based on the new person?

Unvote
Vote: inhim

[inHimshallibe]

what you aren't going to try to read the slot based on the new person?

Probably not.

Thor's given credible meta to continue pressuring the replacement. You read nothing into ABR's change of play?

[Bulbazak]

Oh, I forgot to mention it before. Shroomish towntold big in that post. Scum will have to NK him.

I didn't see a towntell. I saw a contradictory stance and opportunistic behavior.

Getting the number of scum oh so very wrong.

I agree that there is most likely 4 scum, but I don't see how saying there are 6 completely clears him.

I was voting kab earlier in the game. ABR is at L-1. Forgive me for thinking that he is the easiest lynch at this point. Nothing would give me greater pleasure than lynching kab tomorrow.

Are you looking for the easiest lynch or a lynch on scum?

Both? Either?

Bulba, vote Aegor, this is scummier than Highshroomish by a mile.

I might, but I want to do some analysis first regarding the ABR wagon.

[Zdenek]

We *know* that there are 3 scum from the Role PMs in the first post.

[Zdenek]

what you aren't going to try to read the slot based on the new person?

Probably not.

Thor's given credible meta to continue pressuring the replacement. You read nothing into ABR's change of play?

I think ABR is scum. Do I think he could have been scum deciding to lurk - of course.