NY 171: An Education in Telling Jokes (Game Over!)

[Porochaz]

(Also I wanted to hammah)

[Untrod Tripod]

I'm gonna be honest, if she honestly is a town encryptor who gives daytalk to any groups that could have it

lynching her would hurt scum

and she's been a useless lurker

[Green Crayons]

I'm gonna be honest, if she honestly is a town encryptor who gives daytalk to any groups that could have it

I don't even know what her role claim means, but I definitely don't understand this mechanic.

Explanations, please.

[Green Crayons]

(2) Why should we think a Mala mislynch would be easier?

2 - A mislynch on a prod dodger IN GENERAL [ie. not just because it's Mala] is typically pretty easy in lieu of a solid scum suspect or lead.

I'm confused. Are you saying that this general rule is applicable here?

(3) So if Elyse's point is a good one (your words), and you're claiming that you're pretty much the only person who she could be talking about in making her point, why shouldn't we lynch you tomorrow if Mala flips scum? If Mala flips town, why isn't your observation a duplicitous, self-serving statement -- that is, you were the lone voice of reason speaking out against the misguided Mala-wagon?

3 - If she flips scum I'm sure I'll be lynched tomorrow so I'll worry about that if she flips scum. If she flips Town I don't care if you think my observations were "duplicitous" or "self-serving" so long as my actions enable me to figure out who the scum driving the wagon is. I note that you phrased this as a "heads I win, tails you lose" sort of question. Were you aware of this when you were typing it out?

I found your post suspicious, and then deduced that it is suspicious regardless of how Mala flips. I think more scummy if she were to flip scum, but still scummy if she were to flip town.

(4) Why are you voting Mala?

4 - Lack of options in a game with marginal activity and 1 day left.

Cop out answer. Who would you rather lynch instead?

[Untrod Tripod]

I'm gonna be honest, if she honestly is a town encryptor who gives daytalk to any groups that could have it

I don't even know what her role claim means, but I definitely don't understand this mechanic.

Explanations, please.

The encryptor is passive and won't be blocked or stopped unless I die. I give daytalk to anything that needs daytalk. (Don't even start any role speculation because we don't need unncessary claims.)

read the motherfucking thread etc.

[Green Crayons]

read the motherfucking thread etc.

I don't even know what her role claim means, but I definitely don't understand this mechanic.

Explanations, please.

You first. You jackass.

I don't understand what her role means.

"I give daytalk to anything that needs daytalk." What does that mean? What is a thing that "needs daytalk"? As far as I know, nothing needs daytalk.

[pirate mollie]

scum, masons, neighbors, etc

[pisskop]

Can we lynch her or move on to one of:

Marquis
Nikanor
UT

???

[pirate mollie]

we are lynching her I am waiting for notty before I hammer

[Untrod Tripod]

trying to push me as a lynch candidate is laughable

[Untrod Tripod]

what are you waiting on him for? ain't nobody going to nightkill him.

[pirate mollie]

cos I want to get a read on him.

[DeathNote]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: notscience

for being pacman and not seeing me as obvtown when he knows better by now

dont hammer please, looking something up that I want to post in thread before day ends.

[DeathNote]

Oh... sorry, I had quoted that last post because I was wanting to say this was relevant to my interests.

DONT HAMMER YET

[DeathNote]

a) i doubt that zekrom25 is anything but a town vig. the only exception i can think of is if the scum have daytalk and coached him into making that claim when he did.
b) i doubt that marquis is anything but town, period. seriously, why are people voting him?

Ok found it.

This post looks hella scummy to me right now based on what Mala claimed and what she flips. Just wanted to point it out before day ends.

Hammer away.

[serrapaladin]

Pesky prods. Nika looks incredibly bad for leaking daytalk knowledge. I think that means mala isn't scum, at least not with Nika. Further, if mala is a scum-encryptor, I wouldn't expect her to also enable daytalk for other QT's, so that'd be a strange thing for her to add.

I'd be more comfortable with this for today:
VOTE: Nikanor

[Untrod Tripod]

holy shit serra that was awful

[pirate mollie]

ut we are so in tune this game it is scary

NOTTY I AM LOSING PATIENCE

[Green Crayons]

scum, masons, neighbors, etc

Alright. I'm guessing such roles aren't told that their daytalk ability is conditional.

-----

So when were you planning on voting Zek -- as soon as Cabd posted? Why the Mollie vote in the meanwhile? Would you have preferred a Mollie-lynch over a Zekrom-lynch on Day 2? (It's not the lack of an insta-Zek vote that I think has some traction in terms of scumminess, but the fact that you decided to vote for another player.)

I was planning on voting Zek yes, but I was waiting for people to post. I can't go after another scumread in the meanwhile to see how she would act? Zek wasn't not getting lynched and he was priority. Sorry, but I rather have my voice go on Mollie while I'm waiting for others so they know it's there.

I see a difference in following up on suspicions of another player while an obv lynch is ongoing, and actively pursuing another player (via vote) in the face of an obv lynch. I know conflating the two makes your defense easier, but I don't think that's a valid position to take.

VOTE: Malakittens

[Green Crayons]

Oh, that quote box is messed up. The inside quote is me, and then the response is Mala.

[pirate mollie]

I wasn't ready yet.

[notscience]

SORRY I KINDA FORGOT I REPLACED INTO A GAME TODAY

FUCK

/repent

[notscience]

I'm sad now

SORRY MOLLIE

[notscience]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: notscience

for being pacman and not seeing me as obvtown when he knows better by now

Oh, you're so eating rope tomorrow for this post

[Untrod Tripod]

glad we're on the same page notty