NY 172: Another Large Normal (GAME OVER)

[Mister Rogers]

Did I say that? Its and actual, real live question. Please answer it.

[Mister Rogers]

I can also confirm that talah was not burned by me whatsoever. Rogers, what was it that gave you that impression? Also, why are you so interested in the game? What do you hope to gain from having the link to it?

As I mentioned, it does provide a meta sample of Talah's town game for a reference, right?

[DeasVail]

Did I say that? Its and actual, real live question. Please answer it.

I don't know how many times I have to say I'm not going to before you get the hint.

I can also confirm that talah was not burned by me whatsoever. Rogers, what was it that gave you that impression? Also, why are you so interested in the game? What do you hope to gain from having the link to it?

As I mentioned, it does provide a meta sample of Talah's town game for a reference, right?

Yes, it does.

[Mister Rogers]

Taleh, is this DV dotting i's and crossing t's?

I really dislike that first sentence and

that question about why someone would ask for a link to a game odd

.

[DeasVail]

Are you trying to scumread me?

[Mister Rogers]

@DV:

You played with Talah in Gundam. Why didn't you notice the difference in his play here?

Are you referencing something specific here or just throwing out general tips?

Did you answer my question

that you have dodged once (twice?) already?

I am referencing your previous post.

I

didn't and

don't intend to

(basically it's a question to which there is no reasonable answer and I think discussing it would be wasting everyone's time).

So its OK, that Taleh is not scum hunting here but is normally a scum hunting bunny?

Its an actual, real live question.

Please answer it

.

I don't know how many times I have to say

I'm not going to

before you get the hint.

So far once for each of two questions. But don't worry, I won't ask you the same question twice.

@DV: Don't you find it odd that you are doing more scum hunting than Talah and that you defend better against the meta case than he does? <=== How about this?

[Mister Rogers]

Are you trying to scumread me?

Are you scum? If you are, then yes.

[Mister Rogers]

And if you are town, it would be very helpful if you would just please be forthright about Talah not scum hunting.

[DeasVail]

So far once for each of two questions. But don't worry, I won't ask you the same question twice.

@DV: Don't you find it odd that you are doing more scum hunting than Talah and that you defend better against the meta case than he does? <=== How about this?

Oh well I don't really care for that one either.

Me defending better than he does probably is more an indicator of town-Talah than scum-Talah and since I also tend to have much poorer scumhunting when I'm being hounded, I don't find it incredibly odd, no.

PEdit: I think that saying that Talah is not scumhunting is an exaggeration.

[Mister Rogers]

So far once for each of two questions. But don't worry, I won't ask you the same question twice.

@DV: Don't you find it odd that you are doing more scum hunting than Talah and that you defend better against the meta case than he does? <=== How about this?

Oh well I don't really care for that one either.

Me defending better than he does probably is more an indicator of town-Talah than scum-Talah and since I also tend to have much poorer scumhunting when I'm being hounded, I don't find it incredibly odd, no.

PEdit: I think that saying that Talah is not scumhunting is an exaggeration.

Ok but at least you answered this one, thanks. Ok, but its clear he isn't scum hunting like his normal happy go lucky, vociferous self, wouldn't you say?

Are you saying you buy his excuse that people attacking him prevented him from scum hunting? Becauase you know, I had him as Very Strong Town for a very long time until he posted, "I'm lost". He had DAYS to get into the groove but he didn't.

So what is your explanation for that since really nobody was hounding him and certainly not me? <===

[DeasVail]

Ok, but its clear he isn't scum hunting like his normal happy go lucky, vociferous self, wouldn't you say?

I think it's pretty understandable, as I can relate to a few of his feelings and I'm not even the one being attacked.

[Mister Rogers]

Yes I can relate to his feelings too. But seeing as how this is a game and we play to win, its important to play well. The point is

frustration

is null generally speaking. Scum feel frustrated too. The truth is though a proper defense avoids much frustration. More than that, proper play makes a proper defense easy.

Meh. Anyway, I can tell you like Talah and you want him to be town and that's about it I guess.

I have suggested several reasons why he isn't town. I hope you will consider them.

Good day and thanks for the help.

PS Are you town aligned neighborhood encryptor?

[DeasVail]

Meh. Anyway, I can tell you like Talah and you want him to be town and that's about it I guess.

Please do not disrespect my opinion.

[Mister Rogers]

Ok. Kewl. Please be honest and as objective as possible. Heck if you are willing to do that I'll even lynch Luca right now.

[Mister Rogers]

You know, on being objective and everything, do you have town meta of Talah similar to his play this game?

[DeasVail]

No.

[Mister Rogers]

Meh. Well I mean notice how people like AP & Snor are actively scum hunting (and yourself too!). They have town profiles. It means they are most likely town. Talah doesn't have this profile and you have never seen him play like this; I think I have demonstrated in many different ways why his profile is scummy.

Would you lynch Talah at deadline?

[Mister Rogers]

You know DV is kind of peaceful talking to you. I like ur exclamation points in your posts. I even used that in one of my posts too lol.

[Mister Rogers]

Its true. I try to be nice to people but I play very aggressively. I just assume people can handle it.

[RachMarie]

My head aches something fierce and I ended up skimming several pages here due to the amount of vitriol.

Could we please tone it down and remember that it IS a game and focus on the playstyle and not the player. thanks.

[ThAdmiral]

I go away for one day and there's 14 fucking pages, are you kidding me?

Page 33: rip in peace Anxiety wagon. You know what's funny is that no one seems to have a problem with the wagon itself, just the people on the wagon. It's like no one even mentions anxiety or anything to do with anxiety about why the wagon isn't good. I'm mainly looking at snowstorm, ap, pisskop here.

Page 34: pisskop and snork fight. They both seem pretty abrasive so its entertaining, but otherwise unenlightening.

Page 35: pisskop v snork continues. As does rogers v nero. If I had to pick sides I'd go with snork and rogers, but I have little interest in lynching any of these people. Well, I could probably be convinced to vote pisskop if it came down to it.

Page 36: More rogers v nero.

Page 37: Rogers encourages nero to give input on people other than rogers. Rach states rogers v nero feels like t v t. I have to agree.
talah jumps off the anxiety wagon. What it's still the equal largest with a paltry 3 votes?
LIKE ITS ALL GOOD AND WELL TO BE DISSIN' PEOPLE'S WAGONS, BUT THEN YOU GOTTA PROVIDE A DECENT ALTERNATIVE. AND I THINK WE CAN ALL AGREE LUCA IS A FUCKING COP OUT.

Page 38:

LOOK HOW MUCH FUN WE'RE HAVING!!!

Haha that is funny. You are coming across as town to me, as is Pisskop, so I will go ahead and UNVOTE: Pisskop

VOTE: 4nxi3ty

This seriously needs lynching. This is the best contribution he could come up with? Not to mention he said he wouldn't post reads until giving the thread his full attention. This does not look like the post of someone who has given the thread 15 minutes.

Then vote him? My townread on gant is wavering.

Talah votes himself. Why do people do this? ffs

Page 39: Deas vail returns. his shortlist to lynch is: anxiety, pisskop, aptil. Not a bad list. Talah v snork forms, the ultimate battle of cat v dog.

Page 40: luca blight reappears and jumps on the growing talah wagon. He is a bit of a serial wagon jumper isn't he? I feel like he's going to cop flack for this, and he'll deserve it too.
I have to say I like snork's posting. He seems to be trying to get a genuine read on people, like talah, instead of just looking for ways to twist words and condemn them.

Page 41: this page is entirely rogers, talah, snork and is about the most inane shit you can imagine.

page 42: oh my fucking god will you idiots shut up! This was so frustrating to read.
so this is why I wake up to 14 fucking pages.

page 43:

WTF are you all arguing about?

snowstorm summarising my thoughts exactly

It's not worth reading, trust me. None of it.

Snork, to his credit, accurately describing the previous few pages

Snork and Snowstorm trade reads. Not terrible lists but I'm in both scum piles so I don't love them

that

much.

Page 44: Matt comes back in and votes luca blight. Gant also votes blight. I'll be surprised if luca isn't the lynch today but I still can't help feeling its a bit of a cop out.

Well, let me ask, what do you think of Luca?

Luca is scummy as heck. Obvscum. But he is also low hanging fruit. He's great bus material. He's a bad analysis wagon (imo -- am I wrong?); we'd probably be doing scum a favor by lynching him (I know sounds bizarre but if you don't get my point, meh).

Here's the other thing: On the off chance that Luca is town (I don't believe it for a second BUT he does seem to being scummy in a way, deliberately) that will DEFINITELY be a bad wagon to analyze because everybody and his brother wants to vote Luca -- and you know what? Something is wrong with that. But hey, don't get me wrong the dewd is obvscum.

This is a pretty good post that more or less describes my feelings about the luca wagon.

page 45:

@ZD: No, votes for Luca are not scummy but in my opinion, they are a great place for scum to be bussing & maybe even hiding (their votes).

Then again if luca does get lynched his wagon will be a pretty decent place to go looking for scum, no matter what he flips.

Looks like the Luca wagon is picking up steam. Still not sure why but whatever.

It's because he's not posting for stretches and then coming in to place a wagon vote. It's pretty obvious really.

I don't want to read the talah-bert rogers-snork threesome so was there anything important there?

No.
I read it all and... just no.

Nero jumps on the luca wagon, stating that regardless of alignment players like this should be lynched. I think that's something we've always disagreed with.
Rogers accuses nero of bussing.

page 46:

I sure hope pages 37 to 46 are less pedantic bullshit than p 36 was.

Uh I don't think you're going to like page 41-43 all that much...

page 47: I don't like mr rogers trying to bully deas vail in to scumreading talah. To be honest I'm not convinced that talah is scum either. I think he's acting stupid particularly in regards to the self-vote and the whole not answering snorks question for 3 pages, but that type of stubbornness reminds me of myself when I'm town and being attacked.

[Snork]

Was hoping to talk with AP today but seems I missed him. Was also looking for something from Rach, and found this lovely piece of townposting.

/sarcasm

My head aches something fierce and I ended up skimming several pages here due to the amount of vitriol.

Could we please tone it down and remember that it IS a game and focus on the playstyle and not the player. thanks.

Thanks for the update on your bodily status, as well as the unnecessary scolding from someone who has absolutely no place to be scolding anyone.

How about you provide some content? What are your reads? Where do you stand on the Talah wagon? The Luca wagon? Their supporters?

[Snork]

ThAd, despite how inane the argument with Talah was, I'm surprised you don't have a comment on his unwillingness to acknowledge the point and answer the question I had for him.

[Snork]

Disregard; I missed your last sentence.

[Nero Cain]

Nero jumps on the luca wagon, stating that regardless of alignment players like this should be lynched. I think that's something we've always disagreed with.

Luca has a great possibility to be scum. That right there is a good reason to vote him and on the off chance that he's town we aren't going to lose much and it already has atleast 3 town on it (me and two town reads in 4nx and pmatt) so you should join it.

But Bert is doing his best to scare everyone away from the Luca wagon by accusing them of bussing.

I don't like mr rogers trying to bully deas vail in to scumreading talah.

he also did this to me but with Mastin.