In post 570, jbomber732 wrote:@grey: I just can't see where you get this scumread on KK. He proves valid points, is helpful, genuine, and he was right when he said that it would be easier for scum to hop onto the wagon.
Honestly? He's not my strongest scum read (dats the guy my vote's on). Also honestly? He's a horrible human being, and if I had realized he was in the game I probably wouldn't have joined. And yes, he is a scumread.
He's previously attacked me outside of game, and then decided in this game to play 'condescending high road prick'. He has contributed LITERALLY NOTHING to this game. Here is the list of what is worth his attention:
- Anonymous Hydras
- The meme 'going full retard, never go full retard'
- Me playing off his name
- Incivility from other people
- Posts he deems fluff (that he never follows up on, but man he likes to note it)
- Calling yourself town
- Defending himself from any suspicion
Here is a list of things he's not interested in doing:
- Pushing wagons on people he claims to have scumreads on
- Discussing things with people to try and determine their alignment
I think he's doing the very common scum tactic where he takes a little bit of genuine emotion (annoyance over anonymous hydras, or my insults) and blows it up into some huge conflagration, so he can sit behind "look, I have tons of genuine emotion!"
So is the emotion genuine? Sure, it's genuine. But if he was town, he'd have WORKED PAST IT to try and win. As scum he's hiding behind it, because he can.
Go look over the valid points. Then start ticking the ones that are playstyle. Natirasha always self-voting. Posts he deems fluff. Etc. Go count the number of valid points when you've removed all playstyle critiques (and trust me, any player can critique a playstyle, town or scum). Go look over when he was helpful, and see how much of that help actually helped the town, and how much of it just helped people play more like what he'd like them to play like.
I think you'll find the list of actual helpful and insightful points starts dropping like a stone.