Newbie 1488: Igloo-Town Tragedy (Game Over)

[Randomnamechange]

Actually, it is certain we do. I know this as I am said tracker.

[Billi bilaði]

Counterclaim, anyone? What does jklash12 say now? (Maybe I should stay up a little longer!)

[Billi bilaði]

UNVOTE: dawn_to_dusk

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Vote Count 3.05

• randomidget (3) -
  jklash12, dawn_to_dusk, Jake from State Farm
  [L-1]
  
  
• dawn_to_dusk (1) -
  Debonair Danny DiPietro
  
• Debonair Danny DiPietro (1) -
  randomidget
  
• Billi bilaði (0) -
  
  
• Jake from State Farm (0) -
  
  
• jklash12 (0) -
  
  
  
  
  
• Not Voting (1) –Billi bilaði

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline is 11PM EST March 3

Countdown: (expired on 2014-05-03 23:00:00)

[/i][/area]

[Billi bilaði]

randomidget: please give us all your trackings for the game now.

[Billi bilaði]

That is, give us both of them.

[Billi bilaði]

VOTE: DDD

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

But of course you twist this to make the "accuser" feel a bit stupid.

If I made you feel stupid it because your point was stupid and you can't defend it. Hell, your "DDD was in the middle a lot" argument which makes no sense is basically the only argument anyone has put up against me. I also have no idea why you or anyone else forgets that I started the PrivateI wagon on Day 1. Sure, I think I'm good, I'm not good enough that I'll give up my scum partner on day one.

VOTE: No Lynch

There's not going to be enough time to sort out the claim and allow for the possibility of a counterclaim; the best thing to do is to get as much information from Random as we can today and then just go to night and see what happens.

[Billi bilaði]

I don't agree, DDD. A lynch now is better. Much better.
You defenately didn't make me feel stupid. But it seems like you try that often enough. There is a difference, to me at least.
I am going to wake up for this, because the current status is too important.

[Billi bilaði]

I take that back. No lynch today is better, if I'm thinking correctly.
I'll unvote in next post, and then think it thorougly over...

[Billi bilaði]

UNVOTE: DDD

[Billi bilaði]

But of course you twist this to make the "accuser" feel a bit stupid.

If I made you feel stupid it because your point was stupid and you can't defend it. Hell, your "DDD was in the middle a lot" argument which makes no sense is basically the only argument anyone has put up against me. I also have no idea why you or anyone else forgets that I started the PrivateI wagon on Day 1. Sure, I think I'm good, I'm not good enough that I'll give up my scum partner on day one.

VOTE: No Lynch

There's not going to be enough time to sort out the claim and allow for the possibility of a counterclaim; the best thing to do is to get as much information from Random as we can today and then just go to night and see what happens.

For your partner to keep you at null read and make sure to have some interaction with you makes perfect sense and is easily arguable. Might not be the case, but you not seeing that makes you much more suspicious.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

It's arguable in the sense that you can paint almost any interaction scum have whether it be positive, negative, or null as scummy if you want to. As far as I can tell you've yet to explain why your suggested theory is better than any other suggested theory; it certainly is a theory but in my experience it's not the most typical scum behavior (avoidance is) and it completely ignores my behavior (where I tried to get him lynched first thing day one).

[dawn_to_dusk]

That leaves either 1 shot or doc

If someone claims, this will be a lot easier to work out

[Billi bilaði]

Mislynch today would mean that day 4 is last chance.
Nolynch today means that we can mislynch day 4 and still get to play day 5.
Am I right in this?

VOTE: No lynch

[dawn_to_dusk]

UNVOTE: random I think
VOTE: No Lynch

[dawn_to_dusk]

So random, if you are still online, who did you track day one

If there is a doc, I suggest protecting random, if he's telling the truth, he may be a big help

[dawn_to_dusk]

Of course, that creates another WIFOM moment

These are getting quite annoying

[Billi bilaði]

It's arguable in the sense that you can paint almost any interaction scum have whether it be positive, negative, or null as scummy if you want to. As far as I can tell you've yet to explain why your suggested theory is better than any other suggested theory; it certainly is a theory but in my experience it's not the most typical scum behavior (avoidance is) and it completely ignores my behavior (where I tried to get him lynched first thing day one).

Because PrivateI tried hard to point us towards random and dawn with his vote jumping on day 2.
jklash12 has been a solid town read for me until today. His hammet on PrivateI is the "get out of jail free card". So, it is basically between you and Jake, DDD, and you have played a much more solid game in the sense that you could be a careful mafioso.
Voting for a lurking partner is exactly what I would do, so, me believing that you are an experienced player tells me you are a likely mafioso.

[Billi bilaði]

It's arguable in the sense that you can paint almost any interaction scum have whether it be positive, negative, or null as scummy if you want to. As far as I can tell you've yet to explain why your suggested theory is better than any other suggested theory; it certainly is a theory but in my experience it's not the most typical scum behavior (avoidance is) and it completely ignores my behavior (where I tried to get him lynched first thing day one).

If you look back at post 560, you see that Jake and jklash12 are next on the "ignore" list for PrivateI. So, if your avoidance theory is correct, and randoms clearence of dawn is also correct, wouldn't it be nice if you made a case against either or both of them?

[Billi bilaði]

If there is another tracker out there, or a role that says that there cannot be a tracker in the game, then come out and the game is won.
If he comes out and is mislynched, town wins as we can then lynch random tomorrow, otherwise random is lynched today (or tomorrow, in case of no lynch), and we win.
If no one counterclaims, random is confirmed!

[Jake from State Farm]

Only one we haven't heard from is jk but regardless we are going to end up NO lynching.

[dawn_to_dusk]

No vote I L-1 so why not just finish it at that?

[dawn_to_dusk]

*no vote is L-1 so why not just end it now jake?

[Jake from State Farm]

vote: no lynch

Well I was waiting for random but I doubt the mod is online right now