Open 572: Nightless Vengeful Mayhem - Game Over

[droog]

Scummy:
YYR- I'd like to emphasize hard that this is NOT a solid scumread, it's just... it's about equal parts gut and the phrasing in posts #53 and #99 that just ever so slightly worry me. It's not much, but YYR's the only player who, to my eyes, has not done anything particularly townish while giving me a gut feeling on them of scum.

i feel the same way
if only because yyr's passes at scumhunting were so disappointing

would you lynch after wgeurts?
(if you're reading this i give you permission to hammer btw)

[Blair]

have fun you crazy couple you

No, I'm talking about his jump on the wagon at L-1 today.

My frustration with that is that it hasn't been hammered yet. I guess I could buy town being derp about L-1 after yesterday, and scum wanting to look derp. I don't care. Sure, he can be scummy.

I care (see my response to droog below), but you specifically asked me what I meant by the "illogical" comment and I explained - it was in reference to that specific post.

I want a town game link from you.
It would be very helpful to me.

I respectfully decline, people play under misnomers for a reason - is that scummy, too?

have fun you crazy couple you

The pleasure is all his, I assure you.

[Thor665]

I respectfully decline, people play under misnomers for a reason - is that scummy, too?

It's unhelpful.

Your playstyle is really clicking scummy to me, and you're asking me to buy that you would do some awkward answer mindsets. If I could see you, as town, doing the same it would go a long way towards calming me.
If protecting your alt is more important than that - then I find you scummy, but not for denying me the info, simply the issues already raised.

[droog]

I like Dys right now, but it could be the avatar.

I quick hammered because he already had 6 votes and I was impatient and am

new to mafia on this forum

I'm not buying the bolded part. Unless you've never, ever played mafia before, the theory should be the same wherever you played. Just because you're new on this forum isn't an excuse to quickhammer.

VOTE: wgeurts

I believe that's L-1.

in iso these are the only two reads of yours i found


please provide me with your list of reads before i decide you dont have one
because you dont have reads
because youre not scumhunting
because youre scum

[Thor665]

Aw, snap, you're presenting an either or situation - you being so illogical there Droog!

[Blair]

I don't see it, Thor, but I suppose I wouldn't.

Thor: Am I misunderstanding, or does Cheetory have poor internal logic? If he has poor internal logic, he just claimed scum.

Me: You are attacking Cheetory's poor logic illogically.

Thor: Wait, when and where was I illogical?

Me: When you said poor internal logic = 100% scum.

Thor: Why are you fixating on that one aspect of my play?!?!

[droog]

ehhhhhhhhhhh

i could see 103 from scum but
if blair thought i meant that wgeurts is town and we should lynch him blair's question makes sense

But obviously you didn't think wgeurts was town, because otherwise why would you want to lynch him? There's a big difference between "Not sure if he is town or scum, but he is worth lynching," and "I think he is town, and we should lynch him anyway." Your post clearly conveyed the former and she tried to insinuate the latter.

what kind of town credit does scum blair pick up by bussing?

I don't think she is bussing; I already said I think only one of them is scum.

or why does scum blair need to vote on a sure lynch?

the vote is null at best

I think it was opportunistic.

Nobody was really questioning wgeurts just yet, so she jumped in to start it.

In a vacuum, this isn't scummy, but in the context of her other posts, I think it is.

@the last part

huh? blair purposefully did not jump on wgeurts first chance she got
i think you have to reinvent several words to conclude that blair holding off makes her the one jumping in

[Thor665]

I don't see it, Thor, but I suppose I wouldn't.

Thor: Am I misunderstanding, or does Cheetory have poor internal logic? If he has poor internal logic, he just claimed scum.

Me: You are attacking Cheetory's poor logic illogically.

Thor: Wait, when and where was I illogical?

Me: When you said poor internal logic = 100% scum.

Thor: Why are you fixating on that one aspect of my play?!?!

Here's my version;

Thor: Am I misunderstanding, or does Cheetory have poor internal logic? If he has poor internal logic, he just claimed scum.

Me: You are attacking Cheetory's poor logic illogically.

Thor: How is my logic illogical?

Me: Dodgey dodge

Thor: No, seriously.

Me: When you said poor internal logic = 100% scum.

Thor: Why did that take so long to get out of you?

Me: Dunno.

Thor: Why did you not notice that I clearly didn't believe that?

Me: Well, I did, but I decided not to address that when you asked about my issue with your logic, basically I tried to answer as strangely and in as many drips and drabs as was possible.

Thor: So you don't even have an issue with my logic?

Me: Only with one comment that may or may not have been a joke and that i may or may not have realized was a joke.

Thor:

Me: Wheeee! But, by the way, you shouldn't call me scummy over any of that.

Droog: She makes contextual sense!

[Blair]

Oh good grief.

Enjoy tunneling, I'm done posting for tonight, and my activity will be scant at best over the weekend so feel free to reshape the narrative in my absence.

[Thor665]

When you get back, please point out which part of the narrative you think I skewed from the truth on.

[Dyslexicon]

I can tell I'm going to be lol and %) and mafia feeelz when I catch upø. But I'm not going to do that now.
My sister is visiting (I live abroad), and I won't be as active as I would like to just this weekend. But we have tiiiiime.

[Dyslexicon]

Hi Thor <3

[Dyslexicon]

Blair! *buddies*

[Dyslexicon]

That last version is really different than anything I ever got in my head (Thor), and I write drama for a living and it's pretty cool as such. And I will need to read again. BAIIII

[Thor665]

@Mod - I was looking for a list of players I need to hate. What's up with this Fokem cat? Can we get a prod? With a pointed stick?

Also, pretty sure at least one person on this list is being terrible. Probably all of them. Not sure specifically why yet but it *will* come to me I am certain.

Not Voting (5)- Phillammon, acryon, Dyslexicon, wgeurts, Fokem

[droog]

dyslexicon

reads list please

[Not_Mafia]

Fokem has been prodded. They have 24 hours to respond in thread before being replaced.

[Thor665]

Thank you.

[Thor665]

dyslexicon

reads list please

Out of curiosity though, as long as you're requesting this from a few people (and with an early caveat that I dislike providing them) has anyone actually done this yet besides one guy? I can remember someone doing one, but no one else. I know I've listed my lynch goal beyond today...but frankly I don't think anyone else has even done that.

I'm not thinking I'm crazy, yeah?

[droog]

ive been pretty clear i find you town, blair null, and yyr null-scum

[Thor665]

I don't think your Blair read was clear, I thought you had her and I both as town, myself. Is YYR your biggest lynchgoal after wpeurets?

[droog]

i think i said earlier blair was null
your exchange was a classic town v town exchange
still null on blair, maybe null-town?

sure but my yyr goal isnt huge. i want to hear more from dyslex and shaddowez
gut feeling after day 1 tells me there's scum somewhere in yyr/dyslex/shaddowez

[Thor665]

I would wager fair odds that at least one lurker is scum, that's usually a safe bet and Johnny wasn't particularly lurky, so yeah.

[Thor665]

Though actually I don't really support the YYR nor do I find him lurky, personally. Toss the non-posting guy and acryon in and you have likely scum.
I'd probably toss Phil in my town pool at the moment. He can't play in the deep end but I am unlikely to want to lynch him for a while just off his entrance, really.

[shaddowez]

Hey everybody - sorry for the disappearing act, today didn't go as planned. Also - this is a shameless prod dodge/extension, and I will be back Sunday night.