droog
's first mention of acryon is a challenge to one of his early points, followed by questioning one of Acryon's weirder posts (#161 challenging #145). This is followed by #256 challenging #176, and... there's a theme developing here. #463 is a bit WIFOMy- or rather, seems to be accusing Acryon of being either WIFOMing scum or a townie who's awful at arguing, and it sort of continues in the same vein. Essentially, droog seems to have thought there was something fishy about most of what Acryon said, and that transitioned into a scumread. That sounds reasonable to me, and droog was listed (though this may be inaccurate) as the first vote of the wagon, so I'm not seeing droog as scum at all off the back of this wagon. This compounds with my existing town read.
Thor665
made things hard by sometimes referring to Acryon as Acro, but hey, why would you shorten a name to a subset of the characters in the name... In any case, #408 is the start of a flurry of mentions of Acryon- up until that point, I can't spot any explicit reads on the slot, but I may be missing something. Most of the early mentions of said flurry are to do with Acryon's push on Thor, which was called out as bad by droog too. It's pretty staggeringly obvious from #451 and #453 that something approximating a scumread has been formed, and it's in #711 that it turns into a vote- the delay because he still wanted a Blair lynch, which is fair enough. So no inconsistencies here.
shaddowez
first mentions Acryon in #364 as a townread. These reads are then updated in #586, showing precisely why the read has decayed from town to leaning scum, which seems to follow as a progression. There's little interaction there, but the thought processes are clear to see. I could sort of believe, given Acryon's not mentioned much in between the two posts, that that was Shaddowez jumping onto a mislynch, but I'm honestly not buying it. Largely because at the time there were NO votes on acryon. He then shifts onto the wagon itself at #713, to put it at L-1. Which is a bit bad given it opened the wagon up for a quickhammer before acryon got back, but honestly if scum were dumb enough to do that then they'd given themselves away, which makes for an easy lynch, so that action itself is null. All in all, consistent, coherent thought processes are evident here.
DCLVXI
's first mention of Acryon is that they're a scumread, immediately followed by a vote. This is backed up by their thought processes, which, while I don't agree with them, seem valid. They then unvote once to avoid a quicklynch, say their piece, then go back on. I see no issues with this whatsoever.
Fink
is still scum, and I have already gone into some detail on the matter.
If I'm still alive when I get back, I'm more than happy to go into detail/answer any questions that you, collectively, may have.
