Open 566: Murder on the Oriental Express (Game Over)

[scrambles]

Moving cdb back to null pending this input on acryon

[scrambles]

The only qualm I have with AFF is I

still

don't believe she's a newbie.

She's not. I believe she said so previously.

You may have but I have yet to see your evidence AFF is not new.

Meanwhile, I posted two posts that strongly imply you are not new. Plus our discussion of your homesite implies you are not new.

Where did I saay I was new.
Please Titus, enlighten me on your inability to read posts.

You said you had one completed game and it wrapped on Tuesday.

QUote me.

[Riddleton]

Scrambles

: Regarding "Where do you say you were new", you said on Post #232: "Hello everyone. This is my

second game

. So excited!
Catching up now."

[Riddleton]

Time elapsed: 40 seconds

[scrambles]

Scrambles, can you comment on what you think about Acryon's titus case?

acryon posted a wall of evidence, and I don't agree on all of it as it's partially wifom, but I do agree on the wishy-washy reads. For instance, there was that post about amy overreacting. Titus said she's probably scum, though as town he frequently overreacts as well but it really depends on the circumstances.

[scrambles]

Scrambles

: Regarding "Where do you say you were new", you said on Post #232: "Hello everyone. This is my

second game

. So excited!
Catching up now."

Thanks, I'll let titus respond.

[Riddleton]

Why can't you respond?

[Titus]

Forgot about that Riddleton. I was looking through his ISO that pinged me too. I already did respond but yeah I can go back.

[Riddleton]

Also I interpret "Second Game" as very misleading, regardless of whether you have off-site experience. 'Second Game' implies second game

ever

not second game on this site.

I'd like you to find where AFF has said she's not newbie, Scrambles. I can't find it in her ISO.

[Amy Farrah Fowler]

Amy did you ever answer these questions and I miss it? If you did just give the post number.

And last but not least, I'm happy with my 'elaborate' triple scumread. It works, and I connected the dots that way, and we have one scum down.
You're scum #2, I know that much.
CKD has been slowly reducing in scumminess, although I'm not happy with that. I think I'm less inclined to scumread people who contribute a lot of non-fluff. But I'm still aware of the associative tell (or at least that's kind of how I interpreted it) and with Beli flipping scum, I'm going to point out that that's still out there.

(consider this comment a reverse WIFOM post)Okay going to help you out there a little bit. As Scum, I also post a lot of “non-fluff”, if you meta my scum games, you will see that I will go after a scum buddy mightily if I feel like they might be coming off scummy to the town. So I know you are saying I am townish for non-fluff posting, but I am telling you I do that as scum too. Now that I am telling you this, what are your thoughts on me now? Still less inclined to scumread me?

CKD = scum then Beli = scum (defence of Beli, deflected wagon)
Beli = scum then Chaos = scum (protectiveness, made up an imaginary wagon earlier in the game), a little more so than CKD (as mentioned above)
Chaos = scum then Beli = Scum (defence, as mentioned above)

I guess I am confused how I got downgraded in my scumminess between 588 and 948. I mean with Bel flipping scum, given your rationale I should have been MORE scummy right?

I am asking this, because I am trying to understand your reasoning for scumreads (for everyone/or in general/for CD) in this game.

Ah, my apologies, I thought I replied to that. Guess I didn't.

a) I'm not directly townreading you for non-fluff. I'm just less inclined to scumread people who post logic. It's not something I want to do, but I subconsciously think townier of said person.

b) According to rationale: yes. Do I see it right now... no, not really.

[scrambles]

I already posted it riddleton.

[Amy Farrah Fowler]

I'd like you to find where AFF has said she's not newbie, Scrambles. I can't find it in her ISO.

Of course you haven't, I'm not and I've never said so.

[Titus]

Hello everyone. This is my second game. So excited!
Catching up now.

Scarmbles, random question. Can you link me to all finished games you have and include the proximate timeframe.

I actually have no finished games on mafiascum.
I just finished one on a different site and im currently modding a game.

I have massive arguments with players all the time. On my other site, im kinda known for it, and a lot of people call it detrimental.
however, normally in an argument like this I would say amy is town. Scum just dont argue this much or with such fervor.

Remind me to go to your home site and show them how to play scum.

I would love do you to join us sometime.
also my game ended on Tuesday.

There you go.

You say things like "in my experience" and have reads on whether or not players are new and then this shit.

[Amy Farrah Fowler]

*i.e. I'm not

not

newbie.

[ChannelDelibird]

Just sorting that acryon post at the moment but, for the sake of my sanity as I try to figure out this mess,

Amy

, I would appreciate it if you could respond to this:

Kudos to both Beli and one of CDB's posts for instantly making everyone vote for me. I'm not even going to bother right now because clearly I'm getting lynched. Yes I'm giving up, yes it's bad, but I completely lose it when people vote me when I'm town. WIFOM alert, but as scum I tend to actually play to my wincon in these situations and try to get the wagon off me.

Examples, please!

[scrambles]

Hello everyone. This is my second game. So excited!
Catching up now.

Scarmbles, random question. Can you link me to all finished games you have and include the proximate timeframe.

I actually have no finished games on mafiascum.
I just finished one on a different site and im currently modding a game.

I have massive arguments with players all the time. On my other site, im kinda known for it, and a lot of people call it detrimental.
however, normally in an argument like this I would say amy is town. Scum just dont argue this much or with such fervor.

Remind me to go to your home site and show them how to play scum.

I would love do you to join us sometime.
also my game ended on Tuesday.

There you go.

You say things like "in my experience" and have reads on whether or not players are new and then this shit.

Thanks.
It's my second game on mafiascum. I was just in a game with your hydra as well where I specifically talked about my experience. I've played before on another site, which I've mentioned here as well a couple times already.

[acryon]

Acryon, your case against Titus isn't valid. It's just complaints you have against his playstyle (ie. VCA)

My point is that she is

not even doing any analysis

. It's not a problem with her playstyle; it's a problem with her not actually saying anything. Unless your definition of VCA is throwing out naked reads and talking about how you're going to do VCA.

[Titus]

@scrambles, I have like five hydras...which one?

@acryon, ignoring my analysis does not make it go away.

[Amy Farrah Fowler]

Just sorting that acryon post at the moment but, for the sake of my sanity as I try to figure out this mess,

Amy

, I would appreciate it if you could respond to this:

Kudos to both Beli and one of CDB's posts for instantly making everyone vote for me. I'm not even going to bother right now because clearly I'm getting lynched. Yes I'm giving up, yes it's bad, but I completely lose it when people vote me when I'm town. WIFOM alert, but as scum I tend to actually play to my wincon in these situations and try to get the wagon off me.

Examples, please!

I think people may have stated this before, although not from my point of view. I know someone mentioned that Beli didn't vote for me even though I was the definite scum in his scenario, or something along those lines.

And your initial few posts (I probably had a specific one in mind when writing that but w/e) of Day 3 convinced two other people to vote for me before I'd posted that day.

[acryon]

@acryon, ignoring my analysis does not make it go away.

I think you're confused at what the word analysis means. It is not simply spitting out a conclusion. It includes how you got to that conclusion, which you never seem interested in producing.

[scrambles]

@scrambles, I have like five hydras...which one?

@acryon, ignoring my analysis does not make it go away.

MVP?

[Riddleton]

Hm. Pretty confident on two of (scrambles, acryon, CKD) as the final scummies. I think this day has revealed a lot.

[scrambles]

Wait no, it was you and someone else. Weird name having to do with good and evil. hang on.

[scrambles]

Depraved justice I think.

[Riddleton]

"hang on while I research the names of Titus' hydrae because

I can't remember

I'm making it up"