Reck's Retrospective Rehash - OVER (thx obama)

[50 Shades of Purple]

I HAVE NO IDEA HOW TO COPYPASTA ON THIS KEYBOARD

[wgeurts]

Nexus's defence is a little odd as it seems more like an attempt to divert people to ZZZX, I'll look at chevre's later.

[SleepyKrew]

Amished tell is bad

[xRECKONERx]

Official Vote Count

wgeurts

(9): Triforce, Untrod Tripod, Majiffy, SleepyKrew, 50 Shades of Purple, vezokpiraka, 4burner, ooba, Aegor

BROseidon

(2): Shinobi, ActionDan

ZZZX

(2): BROseidon, Nexus

Nexus

(2): ChannelDelibird, Iecerint

Untrod Tripod

(2): Chevre, wgeurts

Bella

(1): ZZZX

ChannelDelibird

(1): PeregrineV

Not Voting

(5): Kise, Bella, Juls, jmj3000, Ward

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2014-11-05 15:15:00)

[wgeurts]

Why is nobody answering my tripod case?
He's still done nothing than post ****.

[vezokpiraka]

Amished tell is bad

QFT

[Nexus]

Is unvoting to vote someone who I thought was scummier a defence?

Clearly I'm completely out of site meta with this loopy statement.

Did I specifically say "wgeurts is not scum"?

I don't recall ever saying that!

Man, this defence thing is really hardcore!!!!!!!!!!

Whatever.

[Nexus]

I have asked wgeurts questions that he has ignored. If he continues to ignore them, my vote will move. Otherwise, I will keep my vote on ZZZX until he provides some content, and if he provides something good, my vote will move back to wgeurts! That's how the game goes!

[Nexus]

Wgeurts

why did you claim when you weren't even at L-1? What did you expect it to achieve?

[Chevre]

Didn't see that wgeurts had claimed, but look at this, from ooba's list of scum roles:

List of all scum roles.

Game	Mafia Roles	Third Party Roles
Lost Season 5	Mafia Goon (3) [Kill every 72 hours – not sure how applicable here]

According to ooba's research, those are the only scum roles from Lost Season 5.

So it's definitely worth talking out, even though it's a lot of WIFOM, but we now have to wonder whether or not Reck had any reason to modify this power. I don't think so given that this game was advertised as unbalanced and once we realized deaths were happening every 72 hours or so we would pick through the roles until we found the culprit. Thus if no one else claims to have a role from Lost Season 5 we then have to wonder if wgeurts and co. as scum are strategic enough to not kill and potentially hide this power for a while. Seeing as all y'all are convinced that his 2/3rds lynch line was a poorly crafted newb scum strat I guess you could worm this in there as well.

After typing this all out I must admit I'm not sold myself; it seems the benefits of killing of 72 hours do not outweigh the negatives. Also the way wgeurts said "to end my wagon" was really fishy. But no one had brought this up yet at least to my knowledge so I think it is something definitely worth the consideration of the whole town.

[ooba]

Didn't see that wgeurts had claimed, but look at this, from ooba's list of scum roles:

List of all scum roles.

Game	Mafia Roles	Third Party Roles
Lost Season 5	Mafia Goon (3) [Kill every 72 hours – not sure how applicable here]

According to ooba's research, those are the only scum roles from Lost Season 5.

So it's definitely worth talking out, even though it's a lot of WIFOM, but we now have to wonder whether or not Reck had any reason to modify this power. I don't think so given that this game was advertised as unbalanced and once we realized deaths were happening every 72 hours or so we would pick through the roles until we found the culprit. Thus if no one else claims to have a role from Lost Season 5 we then have to wonder if wgeurts and co. as scum are strategic enough to not kill and potentially hide this power for a while. Seeing as all y'all are convinced that his 2/3rds lynch line was a poorly crafted newb scum strat I guess you could worm this in there as well.

After typing this all out I must admit I'm not sold myself; it seems the benefits of killing of 72 hours do not outweigh the negatives. Also the way wgeurts said "to end my wagon" was really fishy. But no one had brought this up yet at least to my knowledge so I think it is something definitely worth the consideration of the whole town.

Apparently I goofed up.. It's
a) Make a scum team member investigation immune for 72 hours
b) Kill every week (or) 168 hours

[Chevre]

ugh I knew I was going to regret not personally researching that.

Still there's something worth considering here

[wgeurts]

I have asked wgeurts questions that he has ignored. If he continues to ignore them, my vote will move. Otherwise, I will keep my vote on ZZZX until he provides some content, and if he provides something good, my vote will move back to wgeurts! That's how the game goes!

Wgeurts

why did you claim when you weren't even at L-1? What did you expect it to achieve?

As my wagon was still accelerating and I'm town. I didn't want the town to lynch town so I claimed, I expected to achieve that some people would see that I'm speaking the truth. As said before, I believe scum are driving my wagon.

[Nexus]

But the site meta is to claim at L-1. Do you not know this?

[wgeurts]

But the site meta is to claim at L-1. Do you not know this?

And do I care about the site meta?
No, people should play how they play. Not by some floating ruleset in the sky.

[Iecerint]

Why is nobody answering my tripod case?
He's still done nothing than post ****.

I answered it with the counterpoint "born this way."

[4burner]

Prod dodge. Thoughts incoming in about 12 hours time. Love you.

[Kise]

@MOD sorry, but I have to replace out also I;m just kidding.

I'm willing to bet both my nuts that Iec is town.

Why the FOS kise?

Should I kill you as SK N1 again?

Well, I misinterpreted his post and had to click the quote/post 446 to remind myself of what Iec fully said in the beginning. I thought Iec was copping out to the accusation that he contradicted himself, but a reread of old stuff makes it clearer that Iec isn't backtracking. I apologize, have mercy on me.

So Juls are you SK or cult? Fans are dying to know.

And would it be correct to say that if wgert is mafia, he would be able to kill in (expired on 2014-10-29 16:14:09)?

[Kise]

@ every1

I think there is meat to cdb's scumread on nexus.

And idk. Last time I played with CDB onsite, there was a lot of swearing. I'm waiting for that.

[50 Shades of Purple]

@ every1

I think there is meat to cdb's scumread on nexus.

And idk. Last time I played with CDB onsite, there was a lot of swearing. I'm waiting for that.

don't be a tease kise, give us a link

[SleepyKrew]

Is unvoting to vote someone who I thought was scummier a defence?

Clearly I'm completely out of site meta with this loopy statement.

Did I specifically say "wgeurts is not scum"?

I don't recall ever saying that!

Man, this defence thing is really hardcore!!!!!!!!!!

Whatever.

I have asked wgeurts questions that he has ignored. If he continues to ignore them, my vote will move. Otherwise, I will keep my vote on ZZZX until he provides some content, and if he provides something good, my vote will move back to wgeurts! That's how the game goes!

One of those wagons is nearing a lynch and one of them is not.

[Nexus]

There is a week left until deadline, and there are people who have done fuck all thus far today.

If you want to ride my dick, you have to buy me dinner first.

[Juls]

I'm still not caught up had a busy busy day/night yesterday and will today. But I am free tonight and will do my best. I am trying to keep up with posts since I replaced in though and wgeurts really looks town to me. But nexxus is coming off really disingenuous, especially his vote on wgeurts. I'd probably put a vote on Nexxus if this was all I had to go on. But I will wait until I read the thread.

[SleepyKrew]

He wasn't producing anything when pressured earlier either

Just a reminder

[SleepyKrew]

Why is wgeurts really town to you? Just the offsite account thing?