Mini 1648: Mafia in the Noose Factory. (Game Over)

[Cheery Dog]

Official Vote Count

randomidget

(3): ploben, tip, MonkeyMan576

Zebulin

(3): Luca Blight, Boonskiies, pisskop

MonkeyMan576

(3): Slandaar, House, Ponystar17

tip

(2): randomidget, Kaboose

ploben

(2): BlueBloodedToffee, Zebulin

Not Voting

(0):

None.

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-03-08 19:53:20)

Prodding tip and Kaboose

[Randomnamechange]

Nah, I don't replace out that easily. I just wait for something worth reading before I bother posting.

[Luca Blight]

Almost finished catching up, bear with me.

[House]

Gotta be honest, the only thing stopping me from voting Random is Monkey being on his wagon.

[Boonskiies]

Yeah, Monkey always screams scum to me. When I was scum in a game, The Burning, and I knew he was town, I still legitimately felt he should have flipped scum.

[Kaboose]

Oh snap, didn't know it's been that long since my last post. Catching up today.

[Kaboose]

Can someone debrief me on Zebulin? And Monkey?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

459 - How are you town-reading House? Show me specific posts that point to Town!House.

460 - House isn't a scum-read of mine but I would PL him.

468 - Not even a Day in most cases. Like, D1 is mostly a shot in the dark anyway. PL's are best done D1 imo.

477 - Your current thoughts, Luca?

478 - Why you wanna vote Random, House?

[Kaboose]

I agree 100% about policy lynch on D1.

[pisskop]

459 - How are you town-reading House? Show me specific posts that point to Town!House.

460 - House isn't a scum-read of mine but I would PL him.

468 - Not even a Day in most cases. Like, D1 is mostly a shot in the dark anyway. PL's are best done D1 imo.

477 - Your current thoughts, Luca?

478 - Why you wanna vote Random, House?

I don't think House is town. I said he's acting townier than usual; likely because he isn't posting at all.

The major difference between Rando and House, to me, is that House hasn't done anything scummy; he just hasn't done anything pro-town either.

. A House lynch wouldn't be the worst thing I've ever done as town.

I am interested in House's interest in Rando.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Acting townier than usual doesn't equal town-read?

[pisskop]

You can polish a turd . . .

[BlueBloodedToffee]

In fact, you said 'even townier' than usual.

Not sure how this doesn't equate to a town-read.

[MonkeyMan576]

Yeah, Monkey always screams scum to me. When I was scum in a game, The Burning, and I knew he was town, I still legitimately felt he should have flipped scum.

You failed to mention that my scum reads were pretty spot on that game by the end of the day, my issue was convincing everyone else of them. I even ended up voted...*gasp* ScumBoon.

[Boonskiies]

I mean, that's part of the game. It doesn't matter if your reads are on-point if you can't convince others to vote people other than you.

[MonkeyMan576]

Yep, it's somethign I need to improve on. But it shows that my scumhunting skills are more than adequate.

[Boonskiies]

You had one out of two as a possibility, in a situation where you should have known 100% who both scum were.

[Boonskiies]

But anywho, why don't you vote Zebulin?

[MonkeyMan576]

You had one out of two as a possibility, in a situation where you should have known 100% who both scum were.

Evidently not, since most of the other players weren't voting scum.

[MonkeyMan576]

Can you recap the case on Zeb?

[Ponystar17]

Can someone please explain to me what tip has done which warrants two people voting him over people who have actually acted scummily? Sure, he's lurking to a PL-worthy degree, but I hardly think policy lynches are more important than actual attempts to catch scum. I can see the viewpoints of all the other cases (even if I don't entirely agree with them), but I don't see what tip really did besides fail to contribute. I'd be okay with lynching him later on if he continues to provide nothing of substance - no content means that alignment is impossible to judge - but isn't it more important to lynch people who are actually likely to be scum?
Apologies for lack of content, had a busy day and it's past when I should be in bed. Will try to provide an analysis of someone tomorrow.

[Cheery Dog]

Prodding ploben

Also keep potential person attacks out of the thread please.

[Randomnamechange]

Can someone please explain to me what tip has done which warrants two people voting him over people who have actually acted scummily? Sure, he's lurking to a PL-worthy degree, but I hardly think policy lynches are more important than actual attempts to catch scum. I can see the viewpoints of all the other cases (even if I don't entirely agree with them), but I don't see what tip really did besides fail to contribute. I'd be okay with lynching him later on if he continues to provide nothing of substance - no content means that alignment is impossible to judge - but isn't it more important to lynch people who are actually likely to be scum?
Apologies for lack of content, had a busy day and it's past when I should be in bed. Will try to provide an analysis of someone tomorrow.

He OMGUS'ed and trued to cover it up.

[Slandaar]

Tipsie did you OMGUS poor midget?

[ploben]

I haven't seen much in 2 days IRL that makes me want to change me vote. Tip going silent peaks my interest a little.