Well that's just your opinion man.
In post 1259, PointYBagelS wrote:
Vampirate seems to have legitimately scumread 2 people, Skold and Xayzeck (plus Ricastle, to an extent). Despite calling Xayzeck out for being anti-town, he never changes his vote. While I understand the worry that Xayzeck might be an easy mislynch due to his lurkiness, I don't understand why a town-Vampirate wouldn't think the same of Skold, who also lurked through most of his wagon. This double standard to me implies that he's not legitimately scumreading anyone, and is just putting up appearances.
You're twisting the story here. I voted Skold on the basis of survival, period. I didn't know one way or the other if he was scum but it was better than voting myself here, I was null on Skold, I didn't Scum read him. As for Xayzeck, I said he was the easy lynch straight away due to his lurky anti town behavior, I NEVER SAID I WAS SCUM READING HIM, AND THEREFORE DID NOT VOTE HIM. If I scum read him I would have switched my vote, 0/2 here. Are you referring to my reply to Elusive's post? Obviously, pretty much anyone would say that lynching someone they don't know the alignment of would be better than lynching themselves. How is this scum reading Xay? The only part you have right was I was scum reading Ricastle at the time due. I've since been pretty null on him though.
In post 1259, PointYBagelS wrote:
Additionally, Vampirate has done very little, if any, actual scumhunting. He's asked questions but nothing really substantial. Mostly he's just asked people to clarify what they were saying.
Fair enough but why are you signaling myself out when you already said you find House scummy, and are blaming me for the things Xayzeck has done.
In post 1259, PointYBagelS wrote:
So we have someone who reaches questionable conclusions, has not scumhunted, replaced in for someone who was already scummy, is borderline lurking. If quacks like a duck...
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Vampirate
It's a moose : P
Judging by this, you're scum reading House but you want to vote myself over him, you're also twisting the story to suit your own purposes and while reading Xay's and my ISO are scum reading me for the same things Xay was doing? This feels like you're setting me up to be honest, smells of manipulation. I haven't voted for you....yet.
Since you think i'm the most obvious scum over Xay, what is your take on him?
In post 1260, Ricastle wrote:I really only stopped hard scumreading Vamp's slot because I trusted House. It has since come to my attention that he has not actually done anything to prove the contrary. Suffice to say I'd be willing to sheep him over Kitz, but first.
Vamp, how are you reading Klingon?
I'll admit, I did find the post below to be a tab opportunistic. I'm not sure how much weight i'd put on that though.
In post 755, Klingoncelt wrote: In post 745, Vampirate wrote: In post 308, Ricastle wrote:Ugh. I'm really unconfident in nearly every read I've got so far. I've managed to scrounge together a full set of reads, but they're terrible and I probably won't post them unless someone insists on it.
VOTE: Grib
This is my best scumread for the foreseeable future.
If Grib flips non-mafia, Rubicon & elusive are probably town. If he flips mafia then the opposite.
Kitz, are you leaning towards a more harmless or more negative role with your neutral read? (I assume by neutral you mean third party rather than null)
Elusive: Thing is, how can you be sure everyone in a townbloc
is
town on Day 1? Obviously, if it was likely that was the case, I'd have no problems. I just can't see it in Grib though. Who's your top scumread?
Chainsawing is defending a player by attacking their attacker.
The bolded caught my eye here as it feels Ricastle is/was trying to manipulate future events. If Grib turned out to be non-mafia, Ricastle could later on say "well then the other 2 are probably town" hiding a mafia in them.
If Grib turned out to be mafia, then there's at least 1 easy mislynches after' and of course Ricastle gets the credit.
I honestly highly doubt the mafia would stack up 3 of themselves together like that.
So
VOTE: Ricastle
Anyways this is what I have so far as little as it is.
As for JBomber732, the only real defense I have against everyone voting me now is that the JBomb is an easy lynch target. He stands out way too much in his questionable logic. I'd think he'd be more careful on his words if he's scum. (of course i'm the only one who knows for the very truth so whatever) I'm basically saying i'm the easy mislynch.
I gotta say though, I find my current predicament totally hilarious. If you want go read my past history (there's not much) go ahead.
This is very likely the game's most sensible post so far.
I can see Scum "Townblocking" in a smaller game, but here it would be damn risky. So I see Elusive, Grib, and Rubicon as obvtown.
FoS: Ricastle
for trying to set up Grib.
Anyways, i'm heading home from work i'll look more into her ISO when I get home.
