Mini 1671 - Eclipse Mafia - Total Eclipse (Game Over)

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Can you tell me why you think Juls is scum?

[Sotty7]

If you can tell me why you aren't reading the game?

I'm happy ABR is town and I echo Scrab's post above me.

Vote: Juls

I really want you to be town but there is something off the (limited) day one posting. A more detailed reasoning as to why you jumped on the PB wagon would be a good start.

Prolapsed Brain has been all over the map and I am half tempted to hammer just because of his terrible reasoning around both the Juls votes so far.

I pretty much said why and you parroted it. So why are you so confused all the sudden?

I'm not confused, I just want to know if there is anything more you have to add.

When I re-read the day you jumped on the Skold flash wagon, got overly emotional with Garmr and then voted PB. All of this combined really doesn't look so hot.

I mean, who's scum? You're a little too reactive right now instead of proactive.

[Kalimar]

Vote Count 2.5

Juls

(2): Albert B. Rampage, Sotty7

BlueBloodedToffee

(1): Scarab

Albert B. Rampage

(1): Skold

Clusk92

(1): BlueBloodedToffee

Not Voting

(6): Jeanne11, Juls, Clusk92, Ankamius, Zoronos, PeaceBringer

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-05-27 18:15:00)

Seeking replacement for Clusk.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

lalala

[Zoronos]

So, Mr Toffee, what do you think about Skold?

[Zoronos]

Anybody? Albert, want to talk about Skold? Want to talk about anyone at all?

[Sotty7]

I'm here. What are you thinking about Skold Zoro? How about Juls?

[Albert B. Rampage]

I guess I could swing a vote Skold's way if there's momentum. If everyone in the game voted, that would be a start.

[Juls]

I haven't had time to look at this game. A lot of end-of-school-year stuff going on for my daughter. If I can't find time for it by end of day tomorrow I will replace out. Will try to get to it though.

[Zoronos]

I'm here. What are you thinking about Skold Zoro? How about Juls?

Twice now in the middle of discussion on someone (yesterday when I was talking to Peace and now today when Mr Toffee was talking to/about ABR) he showed up, dropped a vote, and then peace'd back out. He hasn't showed attempts to engage the people he's voting on or explore their motivations.

I'd like to talk to him and investigate his reasoning, but he's making that hard.

I don't have a strong opinion on Juls at the moment. I'd like to see her push a case / dig for some scum. If you have a case for her, lay it on me.

[Kalimar]

Prodding the living PB.

[Sotty7]

I'd like to talk to him and investigate his reasoning, but he's making that hard.

Lets drag him in here then.

Vote: Skold

As for Juls she had a some what iffy day one, but really I just really want her to engage in the game to get a better read. If she's busy I'm not going to get that, no matter how long I park my vote there. Instead, lets try and get something going here.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

VOTE: Skold

[Albert B. Rampage]

VOTE: Skold

[Zoronos]

Haha, sounds good.
SKOLD COME ANSWER QUESTIONS!

[BlueBloodedToffee]

You wanna vote him?

[Sotty7]

I think you should vote him.

[PeaceBringer]

missed checking in on this one over the weekend, sorry...

[Zoronos]

Yes, I want to vote him. No, I don't want to put him at L-2 after yesterday's hammer shenanigans.
My vote is symbolically present. I want to talk to him and get answers before I put him into hammer range.

[Skold]

I probably should of V/LA'd for exam week. But that's done now. Zoro, you mentioned questions, where are they? I suppose my vote needs updated reasoning-
Look at Albert's ISO. There isn't town there. Take another look, there is plenty scum to be found. His reason for his vote on Juls seemed to me to be a perceived responsibility on Juls' part that Juls somehow had the power to prevent that quickhammer.
Sorry about inactivity, exams weren't fun.
@Albert's vote on me is so bad. Just look at it and his conditions for voting me. Cya in the morning.

[Kalimar]

Prodding Scarab.

Looking for a Jeanne11 replacement (yay -.-).

[Zoronos]

On my iPad so forgive lack of post links. I asked you questions in 240 and 285. I wanted you to expand on your reasoning and present a case.
Break it down for me in more detail, what is plenty of scum in this context. Why is commentary on Juls invalid / scummy?

[Kalimar]

RedCoyote replaces Ankamius.

[Scarab]

prod received, sorry

I'll post something in about an hour. I dreamt that Axxle is scum. I think I knew but he had this evil grin and then I died. You should have listened to me about him

[Scarab]

So the strange thing about Skold for me is that his early play reminds me a lot of how I sometimes play early on - a stubborn almost vote-bait-y style until the game opens up and then a sudden shift to trying to play off of how people interacted with it. His anti-anti-RVS comment though makes me think that wasn't an intentional style choice. However I do kind of sort of think he's town because of that - if you include only the game-relevant parts, I honestly feel like I could have written that exact post with that exact timing. Not because I share those opinions, but the way it's structured and the way reads are given is indicative of pretty much exactly the type of thought process I end up with when I play like that early on. Like...it's not a hard style to mimic as scum but the fact that Skold wasn't doing it intentionally I think it's a bit of a town tell. I dunno. I've been thinking about that since like halfway into day 1 and felt silly bringing it up but it seems relevant now.

@BBT
If you're still willing to engage with me after our fiasco of a communication attempt, can we talk about this:

Will lynch Clusk/Skold/Sotty toDay.

1. Given this, why am I not on your shortlist?
2. Can you walk me through your read on Sotty? My gut is giving me all sorts of weird feelings on her but aside from being able to pick out sporadic posts, I have no fracking clue why. Halp?