New York 181 -- Game Over

[RIP]

VC mod

[Egg]

RIP, if you want to know why I'm pretty sure Anen and AP are town, check my ISO. There's some stuff in there about pisskop being likely town too. After dragonspawn, who I'm voting, that only leaves you and tex. You replaced ABR who I've been at least slightly scumreading since about Day 1. Tex was actually a town read for me early in the game. But my reasoning is all in my ISO and shouldn't be hard to find considering how many times I repeated most of it.

[Aneninen]

Nope. I don't townread AP. I don't townread you, either.

I would lynch Dragon, as I said earlier.

So, as others have already pointed out, it seems that you're willing to lynch almost everyone.

Just one question, AP.
Did you think that you had been lynched?
(Because I thought so.)

(1) No, I knew who was voting me.
(2) Also since when did people stop caring about RIP? <- Mostly asking because its kind of surreal now that I think about it. Although he hasn't been here which is pleasant.

(1) What a pity! Had you thought so, you'd be more or less conf-town now.
(2) Basically, it's RIP's style. Even if I haven't seen his scumplay yet, what he's doing is really close to his town-game I watched. I mean certain bits, like "the Nightkill just confirmed that I'm town" things.

Also, I think I can phrase what my problem with the scum-ABR idea is.
A lurky-gamestyle like the one he did might help him live 'till LyLo... if there were Mafia living. In that case, more than half of our effort would be spent on finding Mafia member(s). (More than half, because it's an easier task, due to associative tells.) I think if that slot were SK, ABR's gameplay would have changed when only one Mafia had left... or at latest, when no Mafia had left. No such thing happened.

I give AP the credit of being capable of saying genuine things as scum :\

Bad reasoning and WIFOM, too.
Even if a player is said to have a good scumplay, that tells NOTHING about the game they're in.

Damn there are like 3 RCs now. Red Coyote is p cool. Rapid canyon who siteflaked in early 2013 (rip) and I assumed you mean Radiant Cowbells.

OFF
Yes, I too find this phenomenon annoying. There are so many players with similar or the same abbreviations. To tell the truth, even the ABR / ARS pair gave me hard times, not even once.
There's a list on the wiki with the common abbreviations, but it's hopelessly outdated. Needn't we refresh it or built a kind of "periodic table of players"?
ON

AP, your 4748 contains interesting thoughts.

Egg. I have two problems with your 4749. Firstly, the Ika-kill tells us nothing since it was a pretty obvious kill. The Titus-kill tells us very little. She obviously fake-claimed Doc at Twilight, which made her obv-town. It must have been an obvious choice for the SK to Nightkill her since it was obvious that the Mafia would Nightkill the real Doc.
Secondly, the list doesn't include you at all!

My top reads for SK were Delta and Pisskop and ABR. I didn't want to lynch them when they could still help us find mafia.

Pigeon poop.
Because:

Because Delta, Pisskop, and ABR have been so helpful this game....

Also, that ISO nearby. Eg. 3191 (soft-town on ARS), 3276 and 3319 in themselves, 3408 (now ARS is Mafia and voted), 3514 in itself... Generally, too much care about the SK.

________

I don't think RIP is SK (explained above) and the same goes for AP (even if he was aware of the VC, I doubt that he'd have reacted in that way to his wagon if he were SK).
I start developing doubts on the DragonSpawn-SK read, because of factors I can't explain.
Egg is a possibility. I can't point out

anything

delicately SK-ish, but I can't rule him out either.
According to the recent bits found about Texcat, she's a possibility.
My other guess might be Pisskop, because of his constant vote-hopping and his general recent posting style.

[4nxi3ty]

pisskop - 2 - dragonspawn, texcat

AngryPidgeon - 1 - RIP
Aneninen - 1 - AngryPidgeon
dragonspawn - 1 - Egg
texcat - 1 - pisskop

Not Voting: Aneninen

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2015-05-29 17:35:59)

V/LA:

[pisskop]

Ugh. Everyone's all like 'PK is votehopping like a boss, he must be the SK'. All of you are jealous of my inhibition. Its a proven hunting strategy, you know.

So Since its Anen's Listed Birthday I'd lynch him.

vot: Anen

Happy Birthday!

[Aneninen]

A question we may need to think about.

Why did ARS die?

I can see these possibilities:
(1) the SK thought we'd never lynch him
(2) the SK thought he was the Cop
(3) ARS had an SK-read on the SK
(4) ARS had no SK-read on the SK, therefore he/she wanted to WIFOM-ize the game
(5) the SK rolled a die

We can't do anything about (5) so I'm ignoring it now.
Both (5) and (4) seem to be bad idea; or at least I think trying to find the Cop would have been a better idea. So I ignore (4) too. (I'm aware of the fact that I'd fit (4) because on his last Day he was townreading me!)

(3) : his other read was DragonSpawn.

What do you think about (1) and (2)?


________

Post-edit
Pisskop: I hope you're kidding right now. Thanks anyway!

[pisskop]

I woulda lynched him.

[dragonspawn]

Anen why aren't you voting for anyone?

[Aneninen]

I'm thinking.

[texcat]

ARS was SilverWolf? I'm guessing 1 or 2, or more likely 1 and 2.

[pisskop]

CAn you vote for Tex, Anen?

[dragonspawn]

I'm thinking.

I've said that before as scum to control where the vote goes before.

[Aneninen]

Pisskop: After all...

VOTE: Texcat

________

Post-edit

Dragon: maybe you did so. You can find plenty of games in my meta where I was not voting for a long time or forgot my vote somewhere. You'll find out that it's not an alignment tell in my case.

[pisskop]

Two more please.

[Aneninen]

Three, Pisskop. You're voting for me. ^_^

[pisskop]

lol

[Aneninen]

@All

Do you know what my problem is?
I strongly think there's something... anything out there which would tell us who the SK is. And we'd only need to find that thing. But I'm simply unable to do it.
Right now I think the SK must be amongst these: Texcat, Pisskop, Egg. Can I bring up anything which proves something? No. Can I be wrong about my list? Yes.
That's it.

[Egg]

Anen, ABR always lurks. I'd be shocked if he changed it up as SK. And yeah, I said in that post I was putting very little stock in the ika part. Titus is kind of irrelevant too because she threw at least a little suspicion towards pretty much everyone who is still alive. And I didn't analyze myself because there is no point. I did that to determine who the SK might be and I know it's not me and was working with a time limit that I just barely stayed inside. The info is in the thread if anyone wants to do me.

(5) the SK rolled a die

Lol imagine if they did. I'd be pissed at myself for reading into the kills.

[texcat]

@All

Do you know what my problem is?
I strongly think there's something... anything out there which would tell us who the SK is. And we'd only need to find that thing. But I'm simply unable to do it.
Right now I think the SK must be amongst these: Texcat, Pisskop, Egg. Can I bring up anything which proves something? No. Can I be wrong about my list? Yes.
That's it.

I agree with all of this. I'd say the SK must be amongst: Pisskop, Egg, RIP.
Lurking ABR is a non-tell, but replacing out? He slipped down my list because of the replace out. Egg moved up because of his reaction to my switching over to vote AP.

[Egg]

Tex you have to realize your AP vote looked horrible

[texcat]

Well, I said I was voting AP for his hat, so...

[Egg]

It also put him at L-1 on Day 6 and you haven't talked about him in forever.

[texcat]

Pisskop had already put him at L-1 on Day 6 once. And my suspicion wasn't really raised by your reaction to my vote, it was raised the next day by the retraction.

[pisskop]

If you like then you should put a vote on it

[Egg]

Tex, I overreacted and acknowledged that.