NY 184: a help (done)

[Lostaway]

Any idea on when Oversoul's slot will be filled? I'd really like to hear from whoever takes it over.

[The Bulge]

Any idea on when Oversoul's slot will be filled? I'd really like to hear from whoever takes it over.

About what exactly?

[Lostaway]

Any idea on when Oversoul's slot will be filled? I'd really like to hear from whoever takes it over.

About what exactly?

About Matt's dissection of Oversoul himself.

I'm curious, because until Oversoul got into it with Matt, he seemed pretty town to me. Early on he makes some good points on PK, queries Bro about implying there's a Vig in the game, engages with RC and Jake, and gets into a lengthy analysis of why Jake is wrong about PK not engaging in scumhunting... I mean, OS was fairly active kind of going after people.

He seemed mostly town as far as I was concerned until Matt started pointing out inconsistencies regarding his take on the Flubber push. It's a very good argument, I think, but I want to see the new player's take on the slot and that argument before I start leaning one way or another myself. Right now I'm ambivalent.

[The Bulge]

How would a replacement be able to tell you Oversoul's thought process any better than what we can interpret?

[Bicephalous Bob]

Boonskiies replaces Oversoul! The deadline has been set to three days from now.

Official Vote Count

RadiantCowbells

(5): evilpacman18, Lostaway, The Bulge, Flubbernugget, Grimmjow

Ankamius

(3): Boonskiies, RadiantCowbells, Kinetic

Lostaway

(2): Elyse, BROseidon

Boonskiies

(2): MattP, Ankamius

The Bulge

(1): pisskop

Elyse

(1): VysePresident

Not Voting

(0):

None.

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-06-01 06:28:14)

[RadiantCowbells]

How would a replacement be able to tell you Oversoul's thought process any better than what we can interpret?

Lostaway's opinions are total garbage and I wouldn't put much stock in them.

[Kinetic]

Thanks Bob. Note I'll have some limited access over the weekend, but should be able to post from my phone.

Welcome new blood.

Matt, Bro, Elyse, Lost, PK, would you comment on your likelihood to support an Ank wagon?

Ank: in response to why I think you're scum. I have felt strongly that Jake looked scummy. I do not believe your posts since replacing have changed that read, and if anything, has supported that read. I do not believe you're town, and while I do not have direct posts to point out to show why, I believe I've given several reasons throughout my history that yore welcome to dispute. In particular, your sheeping and buddying up toward Matt is very damning in my eyes. The other points are Jakes play, and I understand it's difficult to defend and answer for the play of another player when you can't read his mind or know why he made the choices he did, but they still reflect on the alignment of the slot.

[Kinetic]

Any idea on when Oversoul's slot will be filled? I'd really like to hear from whoever takes it over.

About what exactly?

About Matt's dissection of Oversoul himself.

I'm curious, because until Oversoul got into it with Matt, he seemed pretty town to me. Early on he makes some good points on PK, queries Bro about implying there's a Vig in the game, engages with RC and Jake, and gets into a lengthy analysis of why Jake is wrong about PK not engaging in scumhunting... I mean, OS was fairly active kind of going after people.

He seemed mostly town as far as I was concerned until Matt started pointing out inconsistencies regarding his take on the Flubber push. It's a very good argument, I think, but I want to see the new player's take on the slot and that argument before I start leaning one way or another myself. Right now I'm ambivalent.

I like this post. Ironically I've liked several of Lost's latest posts. I'm still not sure about him, but I'm less willing to lynch him today.

[Kinetic]

I should mention I like primarily because it's how I've read the OS slot, and it's a well reasoned post. Maybe not 100% indicative of alignment but I'm more comfortable with the Lost slot now.

[Ankamius]

Ok, so you're scumreading the very beginning of my time in the game. Everything else is just dust in the wind then?

[Kinetic]

Ok, so you're scumreading the very beginning of my time in the game. Everything else is just dust in the wind then?

Those are some rather big dust bunnies you're trying to sweep under the rug there.

[Ankamius]

I have no idea what that even means.

[Elyse]

I would support an Ank wagon.

[Elyse]

V/LA until Tuesday

[Boonskiies]

yippee kai yay. thoughts coming later.

[Lostaway]

How would a replacement be able to tell you Oversoul's thought process any better than what we can interpret?

I would think that the kind of response from the replacement may yield some additional insight to the slot, because that insight will necessarily take into account the true alignment of the slot.

[Lostaway]

Thanks Bob. Note I'll have some limited access over the weekend, but should be able to post from my phone.

Welcome new blood.

Matt, Bro, Elyse, Lost, PK, would you comment on your likelihood to support an Ank wagon?

Ank: in response to why I think you're scum. I have felt strongly that Jake looked scummy. I do not believe your posts since replacing have changed that read, and if anything, has supported that read. I do not believe you're town, and while I do not have direct posts to point out to show why, I believe I've given several reasons throughout my history that yore welcome to dispute. In particular, your sheeping and buddying up toward Matt is very damning in my eyes. The other points are Jakes play, and I understand it's difficult to defend and answer for the play of another player when you can't read his mind or know why he made the choices he did, but they still reflect on the alignment of the slot.

Sorry, I'm not so likely to support an Ank wagon, primarily because I'm loathe to let RC slip through our fingers. But then I'm reading RC as the scummiest of scum (and anti-town to boot) while you've pegged him as somewhat townish, so this should hardly be surprising. I have a hard time believing that initial and dreadful fight between RC and the Jake/Ank slot was a scum/scum ploy.

[Boonskiies]

Anyone want to give me some cliff notes?

[Boonskiies]

still going to read, but you know. It's nice to see people's thought process and interact with people directly rather than just reading.

[Grimmjow]

Vote:Lost

[VysePresident]

~66% done.

[Flubbernugget]

Prodge

[pisskop]

vote: Lost

[Ankamius]

Vote:Lost

vote: Lost

Maybe one of you two can tell me why we're voting Lost?

[pisskop]

Alternatively, you could read.