WiFom City: Don't Trust Titus - GAME OVER

[The Blue Blur]

2 Town Investigative Roles (Klingon and Triforce)
2 Town Protecting (Farside)
1 Town Killing (Drizzx)
1 Town Messaging
1 Town Miscellaneous PR (Prolasped)
3 Town Anything Roles
5 Vanilla Townies (Ronit, Muffin)

1 Scum Manipulator (Grat)
1 Scum Chaos Creator (Singer)
1 Scum Investigative (St. constantine)
2 Scum Anything
1 Third-Party Killer (Arson)

Unconfirmed Roles:

The Blue Blur: Doctor
Pisskop: Neighborizer
Quoth the Pidgeon: Roleblocker
Matsina: VT
Ika: Pretender

[The Blue Blur]

also i have this pending theory that sala is the arson and he is going to win

Yeah with a doctor claim.

[ika]

also i have this pending theory that sala is the arson and he is going to win

Yeah with a doctor claim.

"shrugs"

im just kinda board and hate how stupid the game is turing out with everyone being derps.

I would not be advers to lynchign Plot/frogger slot cus they feel off and i would figure if they were town they would of reached out to me by now

[Quoth The Pidgeon]

wait....

TTH?

Hi. ^_^

[ika]

wait....

TTH?

Hi. ^_^

TTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

TTH did you rb me? where have you been and how have you been?

[Quoth The Pidgeon]

I did on night 4. You took over the Atum slot and I was scum reading that slot.

[ika]

I did on night 4. You took over the Atum slot and I was scum reading that slot.

go figure.

so are you still scum reading me or not?

[ika]

mannnnnnn tth is gone

[BBmolla]

This ika lynxh seems pretty awful

[mastin2]

NO.

Facts don't lie.

I voted for scum every day except D1. (Well I voted singer so technically I VOTED scum D1, I just didn't stay there.) And you can argue yesterday depending on ika. I was on Grat D2. I was on Grat/Honey Bee D3. Both times, among the first to join the wagon, and, critically, never leaving it. (I don't think even you hold that.)

I was on Constantine after that. Both on D4 and D5. You know, the scum YOU DEFENDED which I was calling scum. Then on D6, I wasn't on the PB wagon. I also wasn't on the Bulb/whatshisname wagon that happened D4 against my desires.

So let's recap.
On D1, I called singer scum. I missed the mark otherwise.
On D2, I correctly called not only Grib/Constantine scum, but also was one of the first voters on Grat/Honey Bee.
On D3, I immediately voted Honey Bee and never left the wagon.
On D4, I went to Grib/Constantine and resisted the mislynch wagon because I knew it was a mislynch.
On D5, I was still on Grib/Constantine early and often, not on policy but because I thought he was scum and was right. (Yes. Iso me. I was calling Constantine scum. NOT a policy-vote. SCUM. I happened to think that if he were town I wouldn't miss him, sure, but I still thought he was scum all the same and was right.)
On D6, I thought the role evidence against PB was enough that a wagon there was justified, given PB was a null read, but I didn't actually join the wagon because I didn't feel like it.

What about that record is crap?
D1, sure.
But if anything, you have reason to call my record

too damn good

, as in, suspiciously

accurate

.
Sure as hell isn't crap.

Whereas with you...

Honeybee

(10): mastin2, Quoth The Pidgeon, Banana Frog, Flubbernugget, pisskop, MaxwellPuckett, The Blue Blur, farside22, Prolapsed Brain, Firebringer

I'm literally the first name on the lynch. You are near the rear. Which meant you unvoted and came back much later wagon-wise.

ronit (10): TriforceP, farside22, The Blue Blur, ika, singersigner, Banana Frog, MaxwellPuckett, Prolapsed Brain, St Constantine the Hermit, Flubbernugget
St Constantine the Hermit (1): mastin2

Look at me, I'm voting scum Constantine, whereas you're voting town ronit.

St Constantine the Hermit - mastin2, pisskop, Banana Frog, Quoth the Pidgeon, The Blue Blur, Prolapsed Brain, PeregrineV, ika

And here I am as the first voter on Constantine again.

That was not me policy-lynching.

Seriously, control-F me on Constantine.

I don't know about singersinger. What I do know is that I didn't die last night, and Drizzx

DID

try to solicit information out of me half a dozen times. He also went back and forth on what he originally stated about his ability.

I want both Constantine and singer dead.
I happen to also want the Gratuitous slot dead, but I want Constantine and singer dead, too.

Oh, look at me, NAMING THREE DEAD SCUM AS MY PREFERRED LYNCHES.

Anyone wanna remove constantine from the game?

If I thought he was town, I'd WOTC him.
But I happen to think he's scum, soooooooooooooooooooo...yeah. Lynch away!

This is me explicitly stating I'd WOTC him if I thought his play was town, but that I don't, that I think he's scum.

The Blue Blur
elusive/Firebringer
The Goat/pisskop

MaxwellPuckett
Quoth The Pidgeon
Riku/Flubbernugget
Oversoul

LittleGumball/farside22

PeregrineV
Prolapsed Brain

Banana Frog
Atum/ika
Grib/Constantine

Actually bothered to do a readslist. Approximately this should be up-to-date. The bottom's the most accurate.

Oh, look, Constantine is at the bottom of my readslist, meaning he's my NUMBER ONE SCUMSPECT.

My reads have not been perfect.

But to call them crap is downright insulting.
Objectively, they have been better than yours since D2.

Yes they weren't good D1, yes they were bad D1, but every day since then I have, consistently, been on scum. (Aside from the unconfirmed ika who is scum if there's so much as a single PR claim.)

[mastin2]

You didnt do shit other than lurk until today.

Because I never have felt the need to.

People were lynching Honey Bee without me telling them that it needed to be done. But had they not, then yes I would have.
People were lynching Constantine without me telling them that it needed to be done. Had they not, I would have.
People were mislynching ronit, and I do hold fault for not stopping that, but honestly I just wasn't in the mood to fight at the time. Ronit was the weakest of the Oversoul/Firebringer/ronit townreads, so I figured no harm in letting it go through; we could afford to take the hit and it'd get people's heads out of their asses to lynch Constantine.
People were suspecting singer without me telling them she was scum. I won't lie and say I'd have pushed her if not, though, because admittedly I can't really read singer that well and I was mainly scumreading her off of Persivul. But she was there as a scumread.

Simply put, though, there's never been a need for me to step up my game and push someone hard. This is similar to Steven Universe mafia in that regard: I didn't feel the need to step up when it was just noisenoisenoise, until I was convinced the town was heading down the wrong path. Then, BAM, I nailed Frogger and Maxwell right off the bat and was suspicious of Titus. And after they died, I took the back seat again because I held no strong beliefs anymore that needed to be said, which allowed for the Sonic lynch. (Because I no longer felt he was town.)

I hold no disrespect for your abilities.
In fact I hold extreme respect for them.
I think you're a good scumhunter. Your skills are on par with mine.
But mine are not inferior to the point where you can call them crappy.

[mastin2]

Like.

The idea of calling one of

the objectively most accurate scumhunters in the game

a VI is...pretty laughable.

It's not like I waffled on those names.
Or unvoted them.
Or ever stopped suspecting them. (Okay I did kinda let off on singer once she became singer, but I still thought her posting was bad and still thought Persivul's posting was scum, so.)

I didn't push them as hard as I could, sure.
That is by no means a reason to call me a VI.
It's a reason to call me lazy, sure.
It's a reason to maybe suspect I'm scum, sure. (Well it'd require me being scum with immunity butstill.)
But VI?

Village idiot means being an idiot.
Being right in reads is the polar opposite of being a village idiot.

I've been content to be here humble about it. Prior to today, I've not bragged about having right reads (in contrast to you, Sala, who have tried rubbing your reads in our faces every day), I've not called into question the competency of a player (in contrast to you, Sala, who...has done plenty), I've been sitting content in my corner, knowing that I've done good but not perfectly, and never bringing it up because contrary to my reputation, I am not an arrogant asshole.

But there's only so much shitting on my posting I can take before I call you out on your bullshit.
I'm not perfect, sure. But I'm sure as hell no village idiot.

[mastin2]

Also, temporarily,
VOTE: BBMolla.

Until there's a PR counterclaim, ika shouldn't be voted because without a PR counterclaim, all town roles would be accounted for.

[mastin2]

(Which, again, is why I stress a PR, not-PR claim.
I'm not asking for a massclaim.
One isn't necessary.
Just a PR, not-PR claim.
If nobody fancies coming out and claiming to be a PR, then by necessity all our claimed PRs are town.)

[ika]

did anyone read any of masints post? cus i sure didnt

[ika]

stll sala is the one who chraged the lynch for us on scum

[mastin2]

(Technically speaking, of course, it's

theoretically

possible for ika to be scum if nobody else claims, thanks to the town anything potentially being a VT, buuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuut, as much fun as it would be to lynch ika, I cannot, because that is acting in a violation of occam's razor and also in violation of optimal town play, which is to assume he's telling the truth and to use his role.
Again, though. If there's a PR claim, ika's confscum. If no PR claims, ika

could

be scum but should NOT be lynched because that possibility is remote.)

[mastin2]

did anyone read any of masints post? cus i sure didnt

Though I still think ika's scum anyway.

Read Inorganic Chemistry.

This is how he treats me when he's scum.

Read any game where he's town with me.
That's how he treats me when I'm town.
Very sharp contrast.

Then there's his buddying of Sala, which is his scum meta.

Sadly, though. Again. Unless there's a PR claim, leaving him alive is the optimal play.

[BBmolla]

Also, temporarily,
VOTE: BBMolla.

Until there's a PR counterclaim, ika shouldn't be voted because without a PR counterclaim, all town roles would be accounted for.

What a lazy ass vote mastin

[mastin2]

Fitting for a slot that's been lazy-ass the whole game.

[ika]

did anyone read any of masints post? cus i sure didnt

Though I still think ika's scum anyway.

Read Inorganic Chemistry.

This is how he treats me when he's scum.

Read any game where he's town with me.
That's how he treats me when I'm town.
Very sharp contrast.

Then there's his buddying of Sala, which is his scum meta.

Sadly, though. Again. Unless there's a PR claim, leaving him alive is the optimal play.

ya mastin you dont know my meta at all.

if you really did you would of realzied by now that i treat you like this oustide of my alignment alltogether. it should already be obvious as well due to ~stuff~

im not even close to buddying sala as long as MS still exist in there (hes prob a bigger VI then you). if anything i would be trying to buddy TTH in here

[ika]

i would rather side with BBmolla at this point tbh.

i should of faked a cop guilty....

[pisskop]

also i have this pending theory that sala is the arson and he is going to win

We all did/do.

[BBmolla]

Fitting for a slot that's been lazy-ass the whole game.

Are you scum?

[BBmolla]

You literally look like you're just looking for a mislynxh