Open 610: Kill all Townies (Mafia Win)

[vettrock]

Official Vote Count

Performer

(3): pisskop, wgeurts, Ricastle

TellTaleHeart

(1): Sinsun1

Not Voting

(4): Vedith, The Silver Bard, Performer, TellTaleHeart

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-10-30 21:46:04)

[TellTaleHeart]

Also , I want to see Tell's thoughts on the situation - and who she has as her scumread, other than me.

I'm certain I already talked about this.

While The Silver Bard's basic assumptions are obviously flawed (mafia doesn't have a clear motivation to get rid of the cop since he's investigation immune), I agree with the conclusions for the most part.

I'm also a little concerned that Sinsun has been writing novels all game but won't bother explaining why he's voting me.

[pisskop]

Well no. Since he concludes that performer is most likely Wolfie, all his specualtion about making wolfie lists is just doubtcasting.

[The Silver Bard]

Also , I want to see Tell's thoughts on the situation - and who she has as her scumread, other than me.

I'm certain I already talked about this.

While The Silver Bard's basic assumptions are obviously flawed (mafia doesn't have a clear motivation to get rid of the cop since he's investigation immune), I agree with the conclusions for the most part.

I'm also a little concerned that Sinsun has been writing novels all game but won't bother explaining why he's voting me.

Scum have a clear motivation to get rid of confirmed towns, or players that are perceived by the rest of the players as town. This instead of getting rid of a player that might get mislynched.

The reason for mafia to kill cop and WW to kill seer is to make sure scum gets two kills. Instead of speculating on what the other faction does, they simply lynch with logic, seer is WW responsibility, cop is mafias responsibility.

The only reason to not follow this logic is if one of scummers fear another player more, and fear them enough to actually risking having a confirmed townie in the game, and risking to only get 1 NK.

[Performer]

@wg we have two Godfathers remaining. Have you considered he could be Godfather instead of Townie? I held a firm stance on Fire, Lal, and Dong. Going by TSB’s list, I’m most comfortable with piss now. My town lean on him was before more info. Now that there are more interaction posts from others, and, his meager reason for his vote because of a game he modded when I was there for 1 day only, I’m thinking he’s the best option.


Sin’s recent post 773, sounds odd. Talking about Tell being Werewolf GF, then TSB can’t be Mafia GF….how does one even imagine that connection between the two separate factions??

@Tell how is his vote on you bad? Sin stated his reasoning for scumreading you, upon you replacing in.

[Performer]

I'll prob be out but I will keep tabs. I await our tango to find out if I can trust you or not

Probably not. I just spent the last hour scum reading Maxous.

Right now, I just want to be super lazy and call pisskop and Performer scum.

Evolving the scumread list: piss/Tell

Did ISOs on Ric, Ved, piss, Tell.
Not feeling good about the latter two. The above by Tell, combined with her other posts, and her interactions between ika and I, are the reason.

[Performer]

From her posts, she is sounding like she doesn't care much or at all about town, which is a scum mindset.

VOTE: Tell

[The Silver Bard]

VOTE: TellTaleHeart

[wgeurts]

@wg we have two Godfathers remaining. Have you considered he could be Godfather instead of Townie? I held a firm stance on Fire, Lal, and Dong. Going by TSB’s list, I’m most comfortable with piss now. My town lean on him was before more info. Now that there are more interaction posts from others, and, his meager reason for his vote because of a game he modded when I was there for 1 day only, I’m thinking he’s the best option.


Sin’s recent post 773, sounds odd. Talking about Tell being Werewolf GF, then TSB can’t be Mafia GF….how does one even imagine that connection between the two separate factions??

@Tell how is his vote on you bad? Sin stated his reasoning for scumreading you, upon you replacing in.

I literaly said that in my post I would always get a town result.
Also this is positioning to go after sinsun.

[wgeurts]

Yeah the TTH wagon sucks besides sinsun.

[Sinsun1]

Also this is positioning to go after sinsun.

I already picked up on what he was doing, was going to wait for him to play the card fully before pointing it out. But Performer definitely just tried to set up a scenario where he could try going for me if town started to vote me.

I already pointed out why I don't think TSB is Mafia GF, so as long as we hit WW GF outside of him, he'll be clear in my mind and that will narrow down the suspect pool.

Forget to pointed it out, but another reason wgeurts might not have been shot is perhaps the Mafia GF is in his town reads and after all.

There is without a doubt at least one if not both scum between TTH and Performer. Also ISO'd TTH, here's something people might find interesting. 17 posts total since replacing in, in the night.

7 posts October 11th
2 posts October 12th
6 posts October 13th
1 post October 14th
1 post October 17th

Now the exact post count doesn't matter, it's the trend that does. She's getting less active once she begins getting noticed a bit more. Obviously this could be a townie just losing interest, but I like to go high stakes and say I am right on this gut feeling.

Performer's play is very questionable. I've seen town act like it before, so I can't rule him being 100% scum, but there's definitely one scum between these two. If we pick the wrong one, the opposing scum faction will probably just off the other for us because not shooting them will result in risking that night plus another possible night of being shot by them.

[Vedith]

VOTE: Performer

@performer - Talk to me about 781

[vettrock]

Official Vote Count

Performer

(4): pisskop, wgeurts, Ricastle, Vedith

TellTaleHeart

(3): Sinsun1, Performer, The Silver Bard

Not Voting

(1): TellTaleHeart

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-10-30 21:47:59)

[Vedith]

Oh, mine was L1 btw.

[Ricastle]

That face isn't very reassuring.

[Vedith]

Why not?

[TellTaleHeart]

Works for me.
VOTE: Performer

[wgeurts]

Oi UNVOTE:
VOTE: Performer
I wanted to do that

[vettrock]

Official Vote Count

Performer

(5): pisskop, wgeurts, Ricastle, Vedith, TellTaleHeart

LYNCH!

TellTaleHeart

(3): Sinsun1, Performer, The Silver Bard

Not Voting

(0):

None.

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Performer. a

Vanilla Townie

has been lynched Day 3.

It is now Night 3.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-10-20 12:45:42)

[vettrock]

Sinsun1,

Vanilla Townie

and

The Silver Bard,

Alpha Werewolf

were killed Night 3.

Day 4 Begins now. One Lynch is available today.
(expired on 2015-11-03 14:49:48)

[vettrock]

Official Vote Count

Not Voting

(5): Vedith, Ricastle, wgeurts, TellTaleHeart, pisskop

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-11-03 14:49:10)

[wgeurts]

I'm going to do VCA, give me a sec.

[wgeurts]

We lynch TTH
Ricastle and Pisskop are as good as town and (most notably) been on all mafia wagons and shadow/TTH avoids each of them while happily lynching all town/werewolves (which we have to consider as town due to multiball).
I'll post some coloured VC's to show my point.
VOTE: TTH

[TellTaleHeart]

Never mind the fact shaddow was completely absent and no one was filling the slot when the mafia lynch took place.

[wgeurts]

It's not only that, let me go post some VC's as promised.