Trouble in The Cougar's Den (Game over!)

[Reasonably Rational]

Hi LQ. Welcome to the game. I'm confused by this. Are you scumreading us because we were able to determine that a player who seems to always lurk as scum was being active and was thus likely town, or are you scumreading us because you think we'd spend a bunch of time talking about the person we wanted to kill in thread, leaving obvious clues, and then kill them?

this is not even a subtly false dichotomy

Unfortunately, those are the only things I feel he could possibly mean. Do you have some suggestion for how I should interpret that statement? I find LQ a bit difficult to follow, so insight would be welcome.

-Cerb

[Cephrir]

You're smarter than that Mastin. It was one thing when kthxbye didn't wonder who Performer was the counterwagon away from, but

you

not knowing isn't like you.

Considering it was likely a town driven counterwagon (and that if scum you were clearly more valuable than obvscum performer).... why does it matter? How does that make you more likely town?

[Cephrir]

I'm certain that he would not phrase his reasons in either of those manners.

[LicketyQuickety]

Its pretty bad form to give an all Town Town list I think strategically speaking.

This statement disproves itself

I do like you for town though

Firebringer as well, that felt like a legitimate townslip to me

I was saying as Scum, you wouldn't want to give all Scum a town read or all Town a Town read because then people can pretty easily POE that rather successfully.

[Reasonably Rational]

I'm certain that he would not phrase his reasons in either of those manners.

So he has reasons that don't make sense to me, which you are privy to. Noted.

-Cerb

[Heartless]

ceph

matt, ceph, i don't think your votes are going to do what you're hoping.

if you want a pressure wagon, vedith is DEFINITELY the way to go b/c while he's been here he's very much been on the sideline and being very conservative with his pushes. let's make him get out here and do some dogfighting.

lickety, your vote is on no one. vote scum. vote vedith.

[LicketyQuickety]

Well I think I already had Vedith as Scum so I see no reason to put my vote there after a pretty much universally Town read player asks me to vote one of my Scum reads.

VOTE: Vedith

[Heartless]

...

is there a reason you're really self-conscious?

[LicketyQuickety]

...

is there a reason you're really self-conscious?

Early years of trauma I suppose.

[Heartless]

whatever. tth can deal with you.

i probably won't be around at all tomorrow. for efficiency's sake, i'll go ahead and have the frustrating conversation i know is sure to eventually arise.

vedith

: they're pushing an easy mislynch! aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaeeeeeeeeeeyyyyyyyyy

someone else

: well... surely vedith wouldn't push a universal townread like that

me

: he didn't push shit. he's been making jabs from the shadows and sitting on his ass from the get go.

someone else

: but... scum only make easy pushes

me

: oh yeah? who's vedith voted? let's see, the stiff hard targets of... fucking monkeyman and lurkaderp mastin hydra. oh, and the dead man walking yesterday. that one too.

someone else

: but ... but... but... he softclaimed

me

:

some other dipshit

: TOWN V TOWN

me

: i fucking hate you.

vedith

: :trollface: U MAD BRO

vedith's scumbuddy

: yeah, this whole thing is stupid and wasting time. GOSH

someone else

: but...but...but.but.aubbdsa./jflksadfo;esaijf;oajf3;oijaojeo3jwo3wijf
/someone else shits their pants and then chews a scab off their big toe
/i invent a new obscenity and throw a bottle at the wall

[end scene]

tth's turn in the barrel now.
night everybody.

[DeasVail]

VOTE COUNT

Botlane (1): Teridax
Teridax (5): MattP, Cephrir, Vedith, pisskop, Kthxbye
Vedith (3): Heartless, Spiffeh, LicketyQuickety
Not voting (8): BotLane, davesaz, Firebringer, HerryPanther, MonkeyMan576, PeregrineV, Reasonably Rational, TheWayItEnds

With

17

players alive, it takes

9

votes to lynch.

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2015-11-07 10:39:49).

[Teridax]

I can't speak for vezok, but I can certainly speak for myself in saying: since when have I ever cared about people voting me? I feel no need to give a reason not to be voted.

What I meant is that I should be townreading you by now.

If you say so.

[Firebringer]

Heartless, that was a great show.
VOTE: Vedith

Will we get a sequel sometime soon?

[Kthxbye]

Firebringer (4): HerryPanther, pisskop, Reasonably Rational
HerryPanther (1): TheWayItEnds
LicketyQuickety (1):

Performer

Performer

(11): Heartless, BotLane, Cephrir,

Kthxbye

, Spiffeh,

Maxous

, Vedith, PeregrineV, MattP, MonkeyMan576,

ika

Reasonably Rational (2): davesaz, Firebringer
Not voting (2): Teridax, LicketyQuickety

Botlane (1):

Teridax

Teridax (5):

MattP

,

Cephrir

,

Vedith

,

pisskop

,

Kthxbye

Vedith (3):

Heartless

,

Spiffeh

,

LicketyQuickety

,

Firebringer

Not voting (8):

BotLane

,

davesaz

,

HerryPanther

,

MonkeyMan576

,

PeregrineV

,

Reasonably Rational

,

TheWayItEnds

Green

: Current hard town reads

Blue

: Those who voted to lynch scum yesterday

Orange

: Those who did

not

vote scum yesterday

Dark Orange

: Those who ended on the counter wagon to scum yesterday

Yeah, I still like the Teridax wagon more.

When I has more time, I'm going to look at each vote on the Performer wagon and judge if they sound town or scum and go from there.

[Cephrir]

Do you always do VCA every other vote count?

VOTE: Vedith

[Vedith]

Scum save on Teridax wagon is too stronk.
WTB logic

[Cephrir]

Great argument I'm convinced

[davesaz]

Day started while I was on a camping trip. Caught up reading, not caught up understanding.

[LicketyQuickety]

Scum save on Teridax wagon is too stronk.
WTB logic

Great argument I'm convinced

Oddly enough I don't think that is alignment indicative for him. but I've only played one game with him so take it with a grain of salt.

[Spiffeh]

I'm pretty sure that was sarcasm.

Also I need to read this.

[pisskop]

Im hurt that kthnx has all of 3 scumreads and has the gall to put me in them.

[Kthxbye]

My mind hurts when I pull up your ISO. Wanna try to post something worth a shit?

[pisskop]

Nah. Bite me bro.

[Kthxbye]

Oh, and if you cared to read anything, you'd see those aren't my scum reads in dark orange....

[davesaz]

Other than your vote, have you stated any clear scum reads today?