Blitz 3: Dead of Winter Mafia - Game Over

[Netherspite]

Official Vote Count

A Royal Saint

(4): Scorpious, gameplay506, The Silver Bard, Ranger

davesaz

(2): Davsto, Expedience

gameplay506

(2): Klingoncelt, davesaz

Scorpious

(1): A Royal Saint

Not Voting

(4): The Jester, pisskop, hiplop, Makoto Nanaya

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-11-07 13:53:56)

[Davsto]

VOTE: Ranger

My vote on that dude I showed suspicion of. Might as well park it on someone I have actual feelings towards overnight.

[Expedience]

It's a playstyle thing. Some people are confrontational, others use a more oblique approach. The trick is reading how people respond.
Lots of game links available on my wiki page, feel free to compare.

Well, I read some of your ISO in this one in which you were town. And surprisingly meta actually seems to be vaguely useful for once and I see your point. Like, I probably would've called you scum for the same reasons if I was in that game but you flipped town.

Looking at you as scum here, you actually seem more aggressive which is the opposite of what I would expect.

I am still not convinced that this makes you town, becuase meta can be changed, and you kind of ignored the other aspect of my accusation: the shallow pseudo-scumhunting. I'm not sure how to pursue this further, but I am not scumreading you much any more. I will retract my vote for now.

UNVOTE: davesaz

At the moment I am seeing Ranger, The Silver Bard and pisskop as town.

Maybe we should just lynch gameplay or Davsto or something, most of the active people actually seem pretty town to me. Davsto is not doing much and he just voted for someone who I am pretty certain is town.

[Makoto Nanaya]

Now that i understand ARS's read i can safely say it makes no sense, at leas not in a game with daytalk.
I think it's equally likely to be a town mistake as a scum push though, so no vote just yet.

[Makoto Nanaya]

I've got my eye on ranger for lack of reasoning with his reads, also he should post more.
Speaking of people who need to post more, Jester! He's had 1 post since his "I didn't get a role PM" post, and it was a joke. Not a good thing, guy.

[Klingoncelt]

Not a lot of things happening in this game anyway.

VOTE: gameplay506
Plenty going on and avoiding it is just wrong, especially with short days.

VOTE: gameplay506

[A Royal Saint]

Honestly I think the scum having day talk has no bearing on whether it is incorrect. Point was no townie would say it. And that it was meant for the day chat thread and posted in the wrong spot.

However out of the interest of town cohesion and not beating a dead horse I will move on. So I will move onto my third scumspect.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: gameplay506

[pisskop]

I can't vote for Pisskop anyway..

the puppies..

I know my avatar is pretty sweet, but what or why did you say this?

[pisskop]

ARS, would you say you play the same or different than Math? Or the same, like I do cause Im super consistent with my playthroughs.

[A Royal Saint]

I would say that this is a reminder to you that I am trying to use this alt for improvement so not to bring up that it is an apt.

Since you did however I would say I am trying to use it to improve my play. Therefore it will have some similarities but hopefully will have some differences. When I find something that sticks and works at finding scum I will generally stick with it. E.g. Hunting for pairs.

[pisskop]

Aye. My apologies.

If I were a lesser person, I'd be irritated at what I percieve to be a lack of content in this day. I feel like were focusing on babby stuff for lack of better stuff.

[pisskop]

Real tempted to PL Klingy. Because I think PLs are great and Im a great person.

[Scorpious]

UNVOTE:

[Scorpious]

@Saint, You seem like you're really trying hard,in a good way. I dont think you're scum,but you need to look elsewhere.

@Pisskop. It was a meaningless post about puppies,nothing there..

[Scorpious]

I think Klingoncelt is scummy..

@Klingon,is the quote the only reason you are voting gp?

[Scorpious]

@dav,nothing stands out to me about him,feeling town about him actually.

Why are you feeling town about him?

I dont feel anything stood out as scum..

[Titus]

Official Vote Count

A Royal Saint

(3): gameplay506, The Silver Bard, Ranger

gameplay506

(3): davesaz, Klingoncelt, A Royal Saint

Ranger

(1): Davsto

Not Voting

(6): The Jester, Makoto Nanaya, Scorpious, Expedience, hiplop, pisskop

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-11-07 13:53:02)

No prods needed. Hope you're having fun.

[A Royal Saint]

Real tempted to PL Klingy. Because I think PLs are great and Im a great person.

I would say no to a policy lynch of KlingonCelt because it is more than likely a post restriction. To policy lynch there must be a well policy why.

However policy lynching someone who isn't playing like game would probably be better

[Klingoncelt]

Real tempted to PL Klingy. Because I think PLs are great and Im a great person.

VOTE: pisskop

[Klingoncelt]

I think Klingoncelt is scummy..

@Klingon,is the quote the only reason you are voting gp?

VOTE: Gameplay506

[A Royal Saint]

Trying something.

KlingonCelt vote for yourself.

[Scorpious]

Nevermind. I'm an idiot. I get her (role imposed) shtick now.

[Expedience]

3: No useful observations.
88: No useful observations.
114: Asking for opinions on Silver Bard, implying that he doesn't agree with the wagon but not outright saying so.
119: The rhetorical quasi-questions are basically already answered by what Ranger has said: "While my scumread's weaker, this wagon's larger."
126: The vote almost feels like an afterthought put there so he doesn't look scummy for suspecting someone without voting them.

Davsto, is changing a vote off a stronger scumread and onto a lesser scumread really that bad considering the setup and time constraints? It's sometimes necessary to compromise.

If you think Ranger is scum, do you think her breaking the rules and saying her secondary wincon on the first page was fake?

[Klingoncelt]

Trying something.

KlingonCelt vote for yourself.

VOTE: Klingoncelt

[Davsto]

Davsto, is changing a vote off a stronger scumread and onto a lesser scumread really that bad considering the setup and time constraints? It's sometimes necessary to compromise.

Not on the first day of a three day limit.

If you think Ranger is scum, do you think her breaking the rules and saying her secondary wincon on the first page was fake?

Well I certainly think reading him as town for it is a bad idea. I find that town would probably want to keep it secret even if they didn't know that you weren't allowed to say it to avoid policy lynches on them for having some terrible one, whereas scum would totally try to fake one for towncred.