In post 1420, Tammy wrote:Well to be fair, I thought cabd and penguin were going to be playing in this game and I thought it was going to be a large (still grumbling about that one I really don't think it was right to blindside us with a blitz there's a reason I haven't signed up for blitz games!), so not thinking that part through doesn't concern me a whole lot.
I'm not sure that not picking up on that which could have been an RVS joke is a scum tell.
IDK I suppose, I'm just not sure I believe Nati went the fake dumbtell route.
It's one thing for it to be a different game type than you expected. It's another thing entirely to throw out something like that.
In post 1422, Tammy wrote:Although I kinda want to lynch good morning for the you don't lunch someone who has softed thing.
Except I didn't say that?
In post 1423, Cephrir wrote:what's wrong with not paying attention to the gamestate?
In post 1428, Imperium wrote:Then what did you mean by everyone ignores my posts and then thinks yeah let's lynch someone who's already softed, like that's a great idea?
In post 1381, pieguyn wrote:and yes I have thought about it and I doubt you actually are what you're softing. I think you're hoping you can backtrack out of it later without being called on it.
you can attempt to mischaracterize my posts all you want, btw, it's not going to work. not only should my role confirm me as town under the right circumstances, if you actually try and lynch me, I'll crush your face in. ~
In post 1383, pieguyn wrote:similar question about myself: do you have any reason at all to think I *could* be town here?
at the time you made your last post, that is.
Could, forseeably (something something 6 people in the pool) and I'm aware that I have both you/mala in it which is really sketchy. I don''t think (want to think) you both are scum here but you were flat out ignoring me for most of the game (and one post saying "I want to see more from him" does not a non-ignore make) and she was erally focused on making me do things which is something I know you'd guys expect me to want to see but also she really hasnt been pushing me that hard if she actually thought im scum she could pull up more than just "he isnt like this one game" an her doing that is really sketch.
I mean I'm not really imagining a world where both are you are scum because if you were both scum it would have been really easy for you two to get your hooks in me and make me dance but idk which of you is town or if you both are town but I'm not remotely confident in either woooooo
That being said I feel like I've been talking abotu how you should get the people I'm most scared of to wagon me if you really want to divine my alignment so uh
Okay I just remembered that Nacho made this post, which is the same kind of thinking I had in Butterfly when Mara and I were trackers. We didn't think there would be a cop in the game and so when Cabd claimed an amnesiac cop we thought for sure he was lying.
So, either he is the tracker or he was planning it since the beginning.
The thing is with Syry, I think that AP was questioning Nacho's reaction and read there? I might be misremembering the who's and the what's but that was exactly what I expected from a town Nacho with a potential scum Syr. Nacho does read some people based off of interactions and tone. In ADwD when Syr and I had a neighborhood I had given Syr a town read and said it was mostly because he was making me laugh and Nacho commented that it was a good way to read Syr in particular. In the open game when Syr was my partner, he interacted with Nacho all wrong when Nacho was pushing him and made Nacho 100% convinced that Syr was scum and he was right.
So, if Nacho is telling the truth and he is the town tracker, then scum do have a role blocker and he was kept alive for a reason. Yeah, they get to neutralize him with the role blocker - I left a tracker alive until LyLo once because I was a role blocker and he'd be completely neutralized. The role blocker can make sense for why there's two investigatives maybe? Neither one are particularly strong because they're only really effective either later in the game or if they get a positive. So, scum left him alive for another reason. Maybe to try to get him mislynched because he didn't think that Syr and his role existed as town? But no one is pushing that, so. IDK
I still do want him to answer why Pie is such a god tier town read for him when she hasn't done anything. And I want him to answer why if he was even slightly paranoid of me that he didn't poke at me even the tiniest bit before the day ended when he thought he was dying. He said earlier in the day that if he sees any weirdness from me or empire then he's going to try to solve that, so I don't know why he didn't.
I'm still feeling more likely town than not though, I think. Stay tuned.
I like this, actually. I feel the same way and I feel like it takes a bit to much prethought
(Even though I know i shouldn't underestimate him :/)
In post 1402, Tammy wrote:So, yeah, none of this makes any sense. I mean, if you were a meek little girl sure, but you have a tendency to drive the game in the direction you want it to go everyone else be damned so I'm not getting this you were afraid to push ap because you might get lynched instead mentality.
the difference here is that up until like 4-5 hours from now, I have been/will be actually busy enough where I can hardly post. I can't do any of this unless I'm actually able to post etc.
In post 1438, notscience wrote:Could, forseeably (something something 6 people in the pool) and I'm aware that I have both you/mala in it which is really sketchy. I don''t think (want to think) you both are scum here but you were flat out ignoring me for most of the game (and one post saying "I want to see more from him" does not a non-ignore make) and she was erally focused on making me do things which is something I know you'd guys expect me to want to see but also she really hasnt been pushing me that hard if she actually thought im scum she could pull up more than just "he isnt like this one game" an her doing that is really sketch.
I mean I'm not really imagining a world where both are you are scum because if you were both scum it would have been really easy for you two to get your hooks in me and make me dance but idk which of you is town or if you both are town but I'm not remotely confident in either woooooo
