Beeboy's deliberate failure to take a stance is pretty towny. In Freedom's Call, beeboy was constantly pushing on whatever he could find and being dodgy and sidestep-y, and Suzune was super defensive. Here they feel for the most part straightforward, though I will agree that that interaction with shotty does feel pretty weak. Although slips don't exist so I don't think that's why they would have done that.
@Mollie: I've seem both beeboy and Suzune become obvtown when under pressure. Their alignment was very obvious in Freedom's Call, and I expect it to be obvious here.
My read on GL is sinking.199 reminds me of the nitpicky stuff he used as scum in College Mafia.
I dunno I think that's mostly personality. He seems to be posting in the same standoffish but motivated manner that he had in Brass & Shrapnel and Word Sneak 2. However, I've never seen him as scum so if I get a chance I'll go look at his ISO from College.
My read on GL is sinking.199 reminds me of the nitpicky stuff he used as scum in College Mafia.
I dunno I think that's mostly personality. He seems to be posting in the same standoffish but motivated manner that he had in Brass & Shrapnel and Word Sneak 2. However, I've never seen him as scum so if I get a chance I'll go look at his ISO from College.
I have experience with him as town and I read him correctly (pretty old though). It's pretty fresh in my mind, I'll see how he continues to post.
My read on GL is sinking.199 reminds me of the nitpicky stuff he used as scum in College Mafia.
I dunno I think that's mostly personality. He seems to be posting in the same standoffish but motivated manner that he had in Brass & Shrapnel and Word Sneak 2. However, I've never seen him as scum so if I get a chance I'll go look at his ISO from College.
I have experience with him as town and I read him correctly (pretty old though). It's pretty fresh in my mind, I'll see how he continues to post.
By the "pretty fresh in my mind" I meant his scum game, that was kind of unclear.
I wish BBT would post more too
In post 201, SirCakez wrote:My read on GL is sinking.199 reminds me of the nitpicky stuff he used as scum in College Mafia.
What's nitpicky about it exactly? Do you disagree with what I said?
In post 204, SirCakez wrote:I have experience with him as town and I read him correctly (pretty old though).
Also I'm pretty sure we've never been town together (in Molla's Grand Idea Mafia Mini you were scum), so what experience were you referring to here?
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
In post 201, SirCakez wrote:My read on GL is sinking.199 reminds me of the nitpicky stuff he used as scum in College Mafia.
What's nitpicky about it exactly? Do you disagree with what I said?
In post 204, SirCakez wrote:I have experience with him as town and I read him correctly (pretty old though).
Also I'm pretty sure we've never been town together (in Molla's Grand Idea Mafia Mini you were scum), so what experience were you referring to here?
Things like "feels embellished and like they're over justifying their vote" feel really nitpicky to me. And I do disagree, I'm leaning town on them.
GIM was multiball so reads were mostly legit there.
In post 210, SirCakez wrote:Things like "feels embellished and like they're over justifying their vote" feel really nitpicky to me. And I do disagree, I'm leaning town on them.
GIM was multiball so reads were mostly legit there.
So Cakez, you agree with this?
In post 87, WhiteLight wrote:Shotty scum reading SS feels like scum that cannot afford to lose a mislynch
Because to me that looks like a really contrived narrative, and I'm pretty shocked so many people are TRing WhiteLight for it
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
Hmm. So I looked at GL's ISO in College and it didn't look that similar, although that may have been confbias. When I tried to quantify it a little further, I found that in College almost every post was some sort of direct response to another player, and he didn't seem to be doing much unprompted analysis. I didn't think that was the case here but looking back his play is actually kind of like that. Another thing in College was that his posts lost that somewhat unfriendly edge that I recall them having in Brass & Shrapnel and Word Sneak 2, and I did see that in his push on me (that may also be confbias because I don't liked to be pushed).
Back me up here (or don't) SirCakez, you were actually in that game and interacting with him, and I wasn't. I noted several potential sources of confbias, and I know I form much better reads when I can manage to keep an open mind.
I would definitely like to see more content from WL before forming a solid read on them, that is true. It's annoying that they have to coordinate exactly what they're going to say, though. They weren't like that before.
Hmm... I wonder if they thought they were obvscum because they didn't coordinate in Freedom's Call and they don't want to be obvsc again...
In post 214, Something_Smart wrote:It's annoying that they have to coordinate exactly what they're going to say, though. They weren't like that before.
In post 216, WhiteLight wrote:I also have reads on 5/8 players so.... >_>
Like this lack of content stuff just feels really made up.
~Bee
except you don't have 1 on me which is bad cos I figured that I wld be the player you have the most experience with.
@ ss
was he scum or town in that freedom game
In those games I was scum or you where in a hydra so I didn't take a lot out of how you played and the last time we played and I accused you of being scum and I drove a mislynch since you where actually town and I was 100% certain you where not playing to your town game so I am incredibly wary of my ability to read you to be perfectly honest despite our play time together.
In post 216, WhiteLight wrote:I also have reads on 5/8 players so.... >_>
Like this lack of content stuff just feels really made up.
~Bee
except you don't have 1 on me which is bad cos I figured that I wld be the player you have the most experience with.
@ ss
was he scum or town in that freedom game
In those games I was scum or you where in a hydra so I didn't take a lot out of how you played and the last time we played and I accused you of being scum and I drove a mislynch since you where actually town and I was 100% certain you where not playing to your town game so I am incredibly wary of my ability to read you to be perfectly honest despite our play time together.
~Bee
good answer
however I am pretty sure I am obvsly town here. I have no idea what you thought you saw in pokemon but that was a really bad read :/