Open 645: C9++ - Game Over

[texcat]

Although a bunch of people wanted to kill him on D1 before the push on Ira.

Tru but I was one of the wholehearted advocates of NOT doing that.

VOTE: a plain farmer

Huh? Can you explain what changed your mind?

[LicketyQuickety]

I might be blacklisting Ranger depending on the way she flips.

[Zachstralkita]

Although a bunch of people wanted to kill him on D1 before the push on Ira.

Tru but I was one of the wholehearted advocates of NOT doing that.

VOTE: a plain farmer

Huh? Can you explain what changed your mind?

oh i thought you were referring to LQ with that conversation

if you look at my day 1 I wanted to kill a plain farmer but I switched to Ranger

NOW I AM BACK

[Titus]

VOTE: texact

Cuz I feel like texact is all whine and LQ is spewing.

[texcat]

oh i thought you were referring to LQ with that conversation

if you look at my day 1 I wanted to kill a plain farmer but I switched to Ranger

NOW I AM BACK

[texcat]

Oops. Only got the quote without saying...
Thanks, this makes so much more sense now

[Zachstralkita]

Psst. Sheep my vote!

[LicketyQuickety]

VOTE: texact

Cuz I feel like texact is all whine and LQ is spewing.

Let me be clear: I would be blacklisting Ranger if they turn out to be Town and pre assigning a Scum read on me without looking at anything I do.

[texcat]

VOTE: texact

Cuz I feel like texact is all whine and LQ is spewing.

Cuz that's a reason? Ok so that means that the reasons for voting are a sparse iso and because Titus thinks I'm whining? Does anyone actually have a reason for thinking I'm scum???

[Zachstralkita]

I'm also trying to defend LQ so...

[Bins]

VOTE: texact

Cuz I feel like texact is all whine and LQ is spewing.

Let me be clear: I would be blacklisting Ranger if they turn out to be Town and pre assigning a Scum read on me without looking at anything I do.

Jesus not explaining a read as reason for a blacklist man

Tbh LQ's reaction here is so frustratedly ignorant it's probably town
What kind of scum defends himself this way

If you are town man you're gonna realize that not having a case isn't scummy and having a case doesn't clear you. Like you've made cases and had reasons but they've been shit sooooooo... what's really better here? Gut is a valid reason. Tone is a valid reason. I feel for Ranger at this point even tho she isn't clear.

UNVOTE:
Looking at Tex tomorrow

[Bins]

Because if you know you're town, and you are actually behaving the way I say you are, then that behavior is ipso facto townish from your perspective, so it's kind of dumb to suspect me for calling it townish when it actually is.

Pretty sure this is a logical fallacy. Forget the name of it though.

She can only be gf, SK, or town.

And I have gone on record to say I would NEVER, EVER choose investigation immune over bulletproof as a serial killer. Because, you know...I'm

Ranger

. I tend to get nightkilled a lot...even as scum. So, not a serial killer, aside from the obvious lack of second nightkill. Also, one reason I love this setup? It is very much easily broken with simple logistics. We know there's an absolute maximum of 5-Ts, so the only possible iterations where I'd be a Godfather are {0 T, 1 T, 2 T, 5 T}. Of those, half have a serial killer. A lack of second nightkill indicates a lack of one. Leaving the only possible setups where I'd be a Godfather as {0 T, 2 T}. Time will tell with those, as will time tell with a lack of a serial killer. (Which is an assumption at this point.)

Of course, strictly speaking, objectively, there's the option I'd be scum with Titus, but in that case, lynch Titus first. Regardless, that pretty much tells you that I'm town. Titus is town. So lynch scum.

I actually like this defence.

[RadiantCowbells]

Transcend/Smither still makes sense without LQ ftr.

Just putting that out there in case this doesn't go well today.

[Ümläüt]

Prod-dodge!

Still here, sorry I haven't had anything useful to add this weekend. I discovered Kerbal Space Program and... yeah.

Probably get back to serious posting tomorrow, I'm already pretty tired tonight.

[LicketyQuickety]

Because if you know you're town, and you are actually behaving the way I say you are, then that behavior is ipso facto townish from your perspective, so it's kind of dumb to suspect me for calling it townish when it actually is.

Pretty sure this is a logical fallacy. Forget the name of it though.

She can only be gf, SK, or town.

And I have gone on record to say I would NEVER, EVER choose investigation immune over bulletproof as a serial killer. Because, you know...I'm

Ranger

. I tend to get nightkilled a lot...even as scum. So, not a serial killer, aside from the obvious lack of second nightkill. Also, one reason I love this setup? It is very much easily broken with simple logistics. We know there's an absolute maximum of 5-Ts, so the only possible iterations where I'd be a Godfather are {0 T, 1 T, 2 T, 5 T}. Of those, half have a serial killer. A lack of second nightkill indicates a lack of one. Leaving the only possible setups where I'd be a Godfather as {0 T, 2 T}. Time will tell with those, as will time tell with a lack of a serial killer. (Which is an assumption at this point.)

Of course, strictly speaking, objectively, there's the option I'd be scum with Titus, but in that case, lynch Titus first. Regardless, that pretty much tells you that I'm town. Titus is town. So lynch scum.

I actually like this defence.

Really? I think it looks more like IIoA.

[LicketyQuickety]

If you are town man you're gonna realize that not having a case isn't scummy and having a case doesn't clear you. Like you've made cases and had reasons but they've been shit sooooooo... what's really better here? Gut is a valid reason. Tone is a valid reason. I feel for Ranger at this point even tho she isn't clear.

UNVOTE:
Looking at Tex tomorrow

I have more reason for blacklisting Ranger than just that they won't explain their read on me. Feel free to ISO my sitewide posts and you might just get it. There are stipulations to it, if Ranger is Scum, then there's no reason to blacklist her, if she's Town, I have no inclination that she is ever going to stop Scum reading me right off the bat and making baseless pushes on me in every game we play in, so, yeah.

[Titus]

Transcend/Smither still makes sense without LQ ftr.

Just putting that out there in case this doesn't go well today.

VOTE: RC

Why do you have to be scum in our last game together?

[LicketyQuickety]

Why do you have to be scum in our last game together?

What's this about?

[a plain farmer]

You have played a fairly analysis heavy game up to this point. Why the gut read now?

I suppose that's how I've looked so far, but gut has informed all of my prior reads as well even when they were also based on other things. Right now I feel like my texcat scumread is simply stronger than any of my others.

[a plain farmer]

Transcend/Smither still makes sense without LQ ftr.

Just putting that out there in case this doesn't go well today.

Are you thinking it's not going to go well today?

[texcat]

You have played a fairly analysis heavy game up to this point. Why the gut read now?

I suppose that's how I've looked so far, but gut has informed all of my prior reads as well even when they were also based on other things. Right now I feel like my texcat scumread is simply stronger than any of my others.

This looks like a load of crap.

[Zachstralkita]

You have played a fairly analysis heavy game up to this point. Why the gut read now?

I suppose that's how I've looked so far, but gut has informed all of my prior reads as well even when they were also based on other things. Right now I feel like my texcat scumread is simply stronger than any of my others.

This looks like a load of crap.

Vote him

[LicketyQuickety]

You have played a fairly analysis heavy game up to this point. Why the gut read now?

I suppose that's how I've looked so far, but gut has informed all of my prior reads as well even when they were also based on other things. Right now I feel like my texcat scumread is simply stronger than any of my others.

This looks like a load of crap.

Vote him

Indeed.

[Bins]

Prediction : plain farmer is just gonna be the Ira of d2

[Zachstralkita]

Prediction :

LQ

is just gonna be the Ira of d2

FTFY!