And this...really. Did you read the post? I'll quote it for you, and bullet point it for you to see clearly. Even though you've quoted from this post, it doesn't seem like you've read it.In post 2662, Vedith wrote:Your scum read is based on him and Clumsy not talknig to one another, where Infinity joined after the Clumsy lynch.In post 2660, DrippingGoofball wrote:I have a scumread that no one shares on Infinity.
Give me other reasons to change my opinion. Other reasons in this game.
- Mollie's ignoring the fact that DGB would be able to manipulate Mollie if DGB were scum.In post 2660, DrippingGoofball wrote: I think there is a measure of this happening here. mollie is dipping into the well ofPERSONAL AUTHORITYfailing to consider that were I scum I would, like majiffy, know exactly how to pat her down and make her feel real comfy. I have a scumread that no one shares on Infinity. Some people are hard-core defending him like Spiffeh was hard-core defending hiplopscum in that game yesterday. He's tossing all kinds of shoot-from-the-hip statements that sound really good on the surface but leave me struggling trying to explain how his TONE is all wrong. Like that certain disregard you have for people when the game forces you to lie to them and paint them in an unfavorable light. Like that nasty kind of aggression that just shuts people down instead of considering a different viewpoint. It's effective; it makes townies lose their footing, second guess themselves, and retreat. When a player does that as town, it wins games for scum. When a player does that as scum... it wins games for scum, too.
You guys seem to think that it's impossible for Infinity to be scum. I urge you to reconsider this. I may be wrong. But punishing discussion, different ideas, and most of all appeals toPERSONAL AUTHORITYleads to unhealthy game states that favor the scum.
- People are defending Infinity.
- Superficial play from Infinity.
- DGB questions Infinity's tone.
- Infinity is ignoring people's points because everything he's saying is false.
- Infinity's being aggressive and shutting down discussion.
We can talk about whether these things are wrong or right and I'm happy to do so. But she's clearly presenting points which have occurred in this game. Your request is answered in the same post you've quoted.
Discussion:
For example, I think DGB's point about Infinity ignoring other people's viewpoints is questionable. At the beginning of the day, at least, he seemed to be more open to this. Also, confbias is an explanation which Infinity has confessed to and which town players suffer from. Similarly, Infinity is shutting down discussion but this could be because he's confbiased and just wants to see my alignment now. This is lazy but also something that town players can do (
XTOXM
.)
