The Walking Dead Season 1 Finale (GAME OVER)

[Radja]

Day 4, VC 3

MagnaofIllusion (4)

-

Young and Witless, DrippingGoofball, MariaR, farside22

Xkfyu (4)

-

Wisdom, SirCakez, My Other Head Is Scum, Dwlee99

Wisdom (1)

-

MagnaofIllusion

MariaR (1)

-

BlueBloodedToffee

Not Voting (3)

-

Basic, Xkfyu, KuroiXHF

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch! Deadline is on September 23rd at 08:00 PM(GMT+1) or in (expired on 2016-09-23 20:00:00).

Mod Notes -
MagnaofIllusion is on V/LA until September 12
KuroiXHF is on V/LA until September 12

I swear I thought I did a VC yesterday.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

VOTE: Xk

[SirCakez]

Catching up now

[SirCakez]

MoI is still alive?????????????????

Blame wis and cakez.

BBT why are you dodging voting Kuroi or Xkfyu?

Because I don't think they're scum.

Ok, why not?

So basically your just here to tear apart case and push a lurker lynch

Xkfyu isn't a lurker lynch, there's a shitload of evidence indicating him being scum

To be honest, I really struggle to read MoI just because I'm not good at reading people who only post in walls. There's some stuff indicating he's town, some he's scum.
But I'm like 99% sure Xkfyu is scum and would much rather get rid of that then someone who is like 50-60% scum at best for me

[Wisdom]

who do you see as scum with xk?

[Wisdom]

I guess you'll say Kuroi, in which case do you think hebi's posts around 213 and Peregrine's posts around 1983 make sense with him as their buddy?

[farside22]

MoI is still alive?????????????????

Blame wis and cakez.

BBT why are you dodging voting Kuroi or Xkfyu?

Because I don't think they're scum.

Ok, why not?

So basically your just here to tear apart case and push a lurker lynch

Xkfyu isn't a lurker lynch, there's a shitload of evidence indicating him being scum

To be honest, I really struggle to read MoI just because I'm not good at reading people who only post in walls. There's some stuff indicating he's town, some he's scum.
But I'm like 99% sure Xkfyu is scum and would much rather get rid of that then someone who is like 50-60% scum at best for me

Why is he a scum read.
Don't say because he fence sat on max, because we had that discussion about max doing that with herbi.

[farside22]

no he didnt, he pushed Heat and didnt rethink it for one second - if anything he then pushed people for refusing to push Heat with him

And he didn't do that here.
He didn't even regard anyone else's views day 2.
What's your point?

he only let it go when he targeted him with his 3rd party cop and got inno

You also didnt answer my question

You were scum. Both cases he tunneled town.

The thing about MoI is not just that he's tunneling (although I have only ever seen that as scum). It's that he doesn't seem like he really believes his arguments, which was exactly the impression I got from his lackluster DGB push in Princess Bride that only went through because DGB completely lost it. Now rereading his Maxous push, he actually seemed to really believe it (or maybe really want it, because Maxous for all his pushing on us would have been an easy mislynch)... but I don't think the same can be said about his recent posting.

And @Wisdom I've played two games with him (one as his scumbuddy, another where we were both town and he replaced out) and modded one game (where he was a strong driving force for the town).
-smart

A 1,0000 x this!!!

you cant meta off two games, man. People have different playstyles even as the same alignment. You need to know how someone thinks in order to meta them and that requires a lot of games.

What arguments do you think he's not believing?

Your using meta off one game.
How is that different?

[Wisdom]

And he didn't do that here.
He didn't even regard anyone else's views day 2.
What's your point?

My point is he tunneled Heat just like he tunneled Maxous
He does tunnel
You still didnt answer my question, if I go through all of your games with town-him I won't find him tunneling on people?

[SirCakez]

@Wisdom 2930
Yeah Kuroi, if not him then Basic
Hebi's Kuroi vote only stuck for like 5 posts, so could be a buddy yeah
Peregrine's Kuroi push makes me less certain there though

I might go Basic instead of Kuroi for Xkfyu buddy

MoI is still alive?????????????????

Blame wis and cakez.

BBT why are you dodging voting Kuroi or Xkfyu?

Because I don't think they're scum.

Ok, why not?

So basically your just here to tear apart case and push a lurker lynch

Xkfyu isn't a lurker lynch, there's a shitload of evidence indicating him being scum

To be honest, I really struggle to read MoI just because I'm not good at reading people who only post in walls. There's some stuff indicating he's town, some he's scum.
But I'm like 99% sure Xkfyu is scum and would much rather get rid of that then someone who is like 50-60% scum at best for me

Why is he a scum read.
Don't say because he fence sat on max, because we had that discussion about max doing that with herbi.

Because he dodged the Hebi wagon and has done fuckall to make me think he's town

[Wisdom]

Your using meta off one game.
How is that different?

im not using meta at all
All my points towards Magna being town are things that have happened in this game

[Wisdom]

Hebi's Kuroi vote only stuck for like 5 posts, so could be a buddy yeah

it was a shitpush though, it doesnt feel like it was on buddy
And then there's Kuroi's push on hebi that started the hebi wagon

Basic doesn't make much sense as an xk buddy either given his push on him

[Wisdom]

You were scum.

i also dont know why you keep repeating this when we're talking about magna

[Wisdom]

@Cakez Basically my problem right now is that I am townreading everyone but Xk and Basic but I think that those two don't make sense as scum together

[farside22]

And he didn't do that here.
He didn't even regard anyone else's views day 2.
What's your point?

My point is he tunneled Heat just like he tunneled Maxous
He does tunnel
You still didnt answer my question, if I go through all of your games with town-him I won't find him tunneling on people?

I just recall him doing it as scum.
Idk about town wise. The few game we played he will tunnel if he thinks a player is scum but he does think more and is less bitchy as town.

[farside22]

Your using meta off one game.
How is that different?

im not using meta at all
All my points towards Magna being town are things that have happened in this game

So you vo5ed him at the beginning because??

[farside22]

You were scum.

i also dont know why you keep repeating this when we're talking about magna

Oh and I said that because in that game you were scum. Like I said, town moi analysis more around him.

[Wisdom]

Your using meta off one game.
How is that different?

im not using meta at all
All my points towards Magna being town are things that have happened in this game

So you vo5ed him at the beginning because??

Because I didnt like his Maria push, like I said

[Wisdom]

You were scum.

i also dont know why you keep repeating this when we're talking about magna

Oh and I said that because in that game you were scum. Like I said, town moi analysis more around him.

I was scum, Magna wasnt
So I dont get it

[Wisdom]

And he didn't do that here.
He didn't even regard anyone else's views day 2.
What's your point?

My point is he tunneled Heat just like he tunneled Maxous
He does tunnel
You still didnt answer my question, if I go through all of your games with town-him I won't find him tunneling on people?

I just recall him doing it as scum.
Idk about town wise. The few game we played he will tunnel if he thinks a player is scum but he does think more and is less bitchy as town.

So basically he does it as town and as scum and you're confbiasing

[farside22]

You were scum.

i also dont know why you keep repeating this when we're talking about magna

Oh and I said that because in that game you were scum. Like I said, town moi analysis more around him.

I was scum, Magna wasnt
So I dont get it

I didn't say moi was scum that game.

And he didn't do that here.
He didn't even regard anyone else's views day 2.
What's your point?

My point is he tunneled Heat just like he tunneled Maxous
He does tunnel
You still didnt answer my question, if I go through all of your games with town-him I won't find him tunneling on people?

I just recall him doing it as scum.
Idk about town wise. The few game we played he will tunnel if he thinks a player is scum but he does think more and is less bitchy as town.

So basically he does it as town and as scum and you're confbiasing

Didn't say thay.

You are scum with him.

Look at you totally misrep my point.

[Wisdom]

can you be less stubborn for a moment or two and realize you are just in a deep tunnel
its not hard
it will feel good afterwards

[farside22]

can you be less stubborn for a moment or two and realize you are just in a deep tunnel
its not hard
it will feel good afterwards

Sure when you stop putting words in my mouth I didn't say.

[Wisdom]

Im not. Im trying to tell you that he tunnels as town and you're just disregarding it because you want him to be scum

[Wisdom]

I just recall him doing it as scum.
Idk about town wise. The few game we played he will tunnel if he thinks a player is scum but he does think more and is less bitchy as town.

Look what you said. You are not denying the possibility he might be tunneling as town, in fact you say that he *will* tunnel if he thinks a player is scum. That's why I responded to this as "so basically he tunnels as town and scum and you're confbiasing" because that's what the gist of this argument is. You are pushing the "he tunnels as scum, he doesn't as town" argument when essentially you don't actually believe this.