The Thing Mafia - Game over!

[Skybird]

Whaat i just looked what did i.miss

It would only block Skybird's vend if he targeted you with it.

I wasn't reading his role correctly either. Good, I can show if Creature locked down the room you guys want me in.

If nobody else minds, I'd like to go to the LABORATORY. Mostly because I just like the sound of LABORATORY.

People who would like to join me could bring their candlesticks and maybe we could run into Colonel Mustard.

Since a room can only hold up to 7 people it would be best if everyone avoided the Labratory except for Tammy's neighbors so we can ensure they're all together.

I understand Spiffeh's point, but on the other hand, if everyone avoids it, then it's obvious who the neighbors are. I still feel we should keep the neighbors secret for as long as possible to keep scum guessing. If Tammy's hood is on point about scum, the neighbors will start dying. I want them to have to guess as much as possible to hit them. Tammy could choose two other people to join them for a total of 7 in the laboratory. (Tammy + 3 'hood members + Andrius + 2 more)

Oh yeah, I said it before but skybird is a very easy scumread and is mislynch bait a lot. I looked back at musical mafia the other night and my read on her was inconclusive but that she was lacking a certain oomph that I expected if she were town. I also said that I would only trust spiffeh's read on her, which I think I'm going to reenact in this game.

I had to go look because I couldn't even remember what I was in that game.

[Creature]

I just need to be reminded what room should I join when the day is about to end.

[Double Trouble]

Rules

10. Players who have not posted for 48 hours will receive a prod.

last Yume post :

Post #767 (isolation #5) » Thu Oct 20, 2016 4:46 pm

---

I didn't see a prod

does that mean Yume is posting, in scum chat? scumtell?


- Tammy I will get back to you with reads, I want to ISO a few ppl w/ their associations and then give a better assessment of my thoughts on a handful of players. Might be tonight but more likely tomorrow as I have been busy, still some things to do, and I'm tired already.

This post is downright despicable.

1) It requires the mod to be on 24-7 / 365 for prods which is not a required thing.
2) A good mod (which SirCakez is very likely) only does prods based on public thread activity.
3) 48 hours had not passed for Yume when SirCakez's post was made.
4) This reeks of gaming the mod rather than an attempt at scum-hunting.
5) If you think the mod made a mistake you discuss it in private not in a public place here first.


VOTE: drealmerz7

That post just quite frankly pisses me off.

[Double Trouble]

Rules

10. Players who have not posted for 48 hours will receive a prod.

last Yume post :

Post #767 (isolation #5) » Thu Oct 20, 2016 4:46 pm

---

I didn't see a prod

does that mean Yume is posting, in scum chat? scumtell?


- Tammy I will get back to you with reads, I want to ISO a few ppl w/ their associations and then give a better assessment of my thoughts on a handful of players. Might be tonight but more likely tomorrow as I have been busy, still some things to do, and I'm tired already.

This post is downright despicable.

1) It requires the mod to be on 24-7 / 365 for prods which is not a required thing.
2) A good mod (which SirCakez is very likely) only does prods based on public thread activity.
3) 48 hours had not passed for Yume when SirCakez's post was made.
4) This reeks of gaming the mod rather than an attempt at scum-hunting.
5) If you think the mod made a mistake you discuss it in private not in a public place here first.


VOTE: drealmerz7

That post just quite frankly pisses me off.

Math

[Double Trouble]

not that anyone cares but I'll be gone likely until tomorrow

my top reads for scum are:

andrius
spyrex
PV
spiff

Talk to me about why.

I think that Yume post was an attempted dodge to try to avoid talking about reads. So a supposed "scum claim" could be followed and if Yume flips town then he can say "Yume should have been prodded." Except at the time of SirCakez's post it was a few hours before the 48 Yume would have been eligible. It is just baaaaaaaad.

--Math

[SirCakez]

Flames682 requested replacement, seeking one.

[SirCakez]

Prodding Yume and Errantparabola

Yume wasn't prodded yesterday because she was under the two days time limit when I checked activity yesterday.

[drealmerz7]

I was trying to bait yume and I got a DT. Interesting.

So a supposed "scum claim" could be followed and if Yume flips town
--Math

because the entire majority of players was about to go:

"OMG drealmerz7 is right! what an amazing scum-finder!" and hop on the 3:10 train to yume and depart+ arrive before anyone could stop it

your ire stinks of false ire

I have a really hard time understanding someone being that upset at my remark, and it feels like you're trying to cause other people to be more upset about it by your reaction than is reasonable.

I suppose it could just be culture clash, and if that is the case, let's discuss the issues.

doing my ISOs now (which btw DT, I could have simply not included the RE: to tammy in that msg and simply asked the question I did about yume)

[Espeonage]

Best post you've made.

[Yume]

Trust no one. Believe no one.

[Generation X]

I asked the mod: you can't see who is in rooms you are not in.

[Yume]

Wait, there's room PTs open already? I don't see one.

[Fire Assassin]

Okay, I guess skybird is town.
Not liking that development. Really thought I had something there.
UNVOTE: Skybird

[Fire Assassin]

I find Peregrine a bit underwhelming.

Everyone almost always does. Read his first few posts in this game. He basically tried to start a fight with me over nothing.
No idea why he would do that as scum beyond just to appear more active.

[Fire Assassin]

Fire Assassin, does your Gen X scumread in 935 come from 932?

Yes. Its not much at all to it, it could just be annoyance disguised as scummy.

[Skybird]

Wait, there's room PTs open already? I don't see one.

No, we are just discussing who should be with whom in the rooms. I was of the opinion we needed other people in the Laboratory besides Tammy, the neighbors, and Andrius so it wasn't obvious who the neighbors were 'cause I think we should keep them private as long as possible. If what Gen X says is true, then the general population won't be able to see who's in the room. Then the question becomes do any of the roles allow a person to see who's in a room.

@mod, can you confirm that players can't see who is in what room?

[Wraith]

Did people not assume from the start that we couldn't see who went to what room? We'll be relying on testimony. Hence why it's important to have at least three to a room.

[drealmerz7]

apply logic

[Errantparabola]

strong townread on drealmerz.
Fire is also most likely town.

How about we force Goatmeal to vig Flames?

i dont like this plan.
scum dgb is likely going to vig whoever she wants
lynch today

Also, Errantparabola's entry was just a lot of "lynch gen x". This feels like an awkward attempt to get thoughts out and achieve a non-awkward state. Like, he wanted to put out an opinion to force the game into a state he could handle.
~GE

i am right now at my laptop, struggling to put into words how scummy i think this is

VOTE: gen x

am i already voting you? i hope i'm already voting you
like i literally get why you name-dropped transcend earlier because he is a lot better at not being obvious scum

[Errantparabola]

i actually want to deny a vig shot more than a scum blocker here.
VOTE: goatmeal

[Generation X]

strong townread on drealmerz.
Fire is also most likely town.

How about we force Goatmeal to vig Flames?

i dont like this plan.
scum dgb is likely going to vig whoever she wants
lynch today

Also, Errantparabola's entry was just a lot of "lynch gen x". This feels like an awkward attempt to get thoughts out and achieve a non-awkward state. Like, he wanted to put out an opinion to force the game into a state he could handle.
~GE

i am right now at my laptop, struggling to put into words how scummy i think this is

VOTE: gen x

am i already voting you? i hope i'm already voting you
like i literally get why you name-dropped transcend earlier because he is a lot better at not being obvious scum

Haha my meta is I get in deep shit as town then bs my way/clear myself into a townread
~GE

[Generation X]

Thoughts on the fact EP voted 2 posts in a row? Looks scummy to me, as they're changing their mind from "blatant OMGUS vote" to "I don't want a vig". What's the problem with vigilantes? Afraid the shot will hit you or one of your buddies?
~GE

[Errantparabola]

i'm stepping away because i'm legitimately getting angry at how obtuse you are being
read my fucking posts and you'll see why

[Goatmeal]

Unvote; Vote: Errant

1. Agree with Gen X on the votes. Rings of him proving a point, rather than voting for suspicion.
2. No progression on his vote on us, nor gives a reason for why he thinks our slot is scum.
3. His #1022 sounds fake. It doesn't line up with the feeling of anger.

[Goatmeal]

I think that Yume post was an attempted dodge to try to avoid talking about reads.

I believe it is because he doesn't actually have anything solid on them. It's mostly for disagreement, which is why he is ISO'ing and can't give a reason at the top of his head.