Open 662: Fire and Ice (Game Over)

[culted]

This catchup is terrible so far.

Btw I'm back from v/la guys how are ya!

[KuroiXHF]

btw gamma is still scum but he can get lynched d2 this time

VOTE: nn30


catch-up was awful

{Io, Not_Mafia}

{Joshz, culted}

{Realeo}

{BK201, PenguinPower, Clemency}

{Rory}

{SnarkySnowman}

{Gamma Emerald, nn30}

smt like this feels a-ok

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Same reaction. Why aren't you lower?
VOTE: SnarkySnowman
I usually wait until after I've caught up but I've decided that even if in ten pages, you pop up to be an innocent child and I accidentally hammered up, we wouldn't be losing much.

On another note, I feel pretty good so far about Kmd being town.

I don't like his early attempts at finding four people to peg as scum.

That's the point of the game

Sure, but pegging all 4 at once is laughably bad. It's an easy way to fake scum hunt.

VOTE: Not_Mafia

WTF do you change your vote every post? This is coming across as bad town, but have

some

back bone.

[Transcend]

hey culted

[KuroiXHF]

This catchup is terrible so far.

Btw I'm back from v/la guys how are ya!

My catch up is actually for me, but I feel you guys can know what's going through my head as I move forward.

[Transcend]

hey kuroi did you know that nn30 got d1'd

[Joshz]

spoiler alert?????
asshole

[KuroiXHF]

hey kuroi did you know that nn30 got d1'd

I did, but I forgot.
At least my read was right about him.

[Transcend]

hey kuroi did you know that nn30 got d1'd

I did, but I forgot.
At least my read was right about him.

VOTE: KuroiXHF

[KuroiXHF]

hey kuroi did you know that nn30 got d1'd

I did, but I forgot.
At least my read was right about him.

VOTE: KuroiXHF

It took you like three posts since I've come in to vote me. I can't tell if you're town or finally not sucking as hard as you usually do.
Either way, keep it up.

[Transcend]

ouch

[KuroiXHF]

Hi all! I'll read this after work methinks.

Now, would people stop footing over the thermostat please! I like room temperature, not this fire - ice - fire - ice bullshit! That's how you get a cold!

Glad to see you, Aris!

Don't have a cow man

Hah. I get it.

Culted is obvtown

It's not obvious just because you think he is. Quoting to make fun of you if you're town and he's scum.

Bad vote

Being superficial all the time isn't helping anyone, including you.

???

Transcend is playing dumb now. And I don't think he's dumb.

VOTE: Transcend

You don't know him well, do you?

NN-Rory Team

Of towns? Yes.

[Transcend]

how often do you get mislynched btw

[KuroiXHF]

VOTE: nn30

I'm gonna comment a little more in depth on 523 in a bit but I'm a little conflicted, because most of the reads look town driven but a few of them have me a little confused / suspicious. When I'm at a PC ~

Rory wasn't bad early on, but recent posts are severly lacking in quality and really just one liners or not very strong stances for the most part.

Yeah, I'll join Josh for pressure.

VOTE: Rory

Not a bad vote, considering what Rory brought. Thing is, there's plenty of people here who deserve it a hell of a lot more than Rory/I does/do.

nn is at least contributing to town. even IF he is scum, which i still think is a possibility, in this setup id rather he stayed alive and productively helped us lynch the other scum team. id still lynch scum if i was confident but im less confident in my scum read of him than i was and in a setup with competing scum reads i dont feel confident enough to lynch an active poster who is improving in towniness.

unvote and VOTE: rory

his interactions with me have been awful, he hasnt done much else this game. not really being a productive townie either and #563 is also a thing.

omg you have to be joking.

Nah, I actually disagree with Rory. I don't blame Josh, except for what's posted above.

Could vote Rory but i also dig a gamma lynch.

To be fair, Gamma is kind of lynch baity. That's too easy and he's likely to be town.

[KuroiXHF]

how often do you get mislynched btw

All the fucking time.

[BK201]

ftr pretty sure I never defended gamma in this game, but I could be mixing games up

What are you reads??

And SS did defend Gamma D1 multiple times, which would be kind of odd for scum to do when there were 4 other players scum-reading him. There's some town-cred to be earned there if Gamma is town.

White knighting isn't odd. It's actually pretty common.

I'm aware of the tactic. I don't know if you're right about it being pretty common though. And honestly no offense to SS but he doesn't seem like the type to employ any clever scum tactics.

tbqh I think scum would do a desperation lynch on the NK if it canceled out

I could see that, but you realize that makes me the failed NK as my lynch is desperate af.

Desperate for towncred are we?

Sure love all the towncred I can get, as either alignment.

But seriously I was just mentioning a fact that my wagon is desperate, and I do think I am one the possible double NK targets if it's not you. From rory/io perspective, it makes perfect sense to NK either you or myself. Scum!Io was afraid of me, so it makes sense to NK me, and she was trying to fear-lynch me day 1 and 2. Rory would make sense to NK me because I was gunning for him Day 1. So perhaps these scum thought I was scum.

I still think you're the most likely double NK because you had at least 2 scum on your two different wagons of 4, yet you weren't lynched (read: difficult to lynch). You had 2 of the largest wagons besides the guy who was actually lynched, and some RVS style speed wagon, yet you were treated like you don't even exist as a possible wagon Day 2. I think there was multiple scum on your Day 1 wagons, Gamma. You should trust me and vote with me.

BK, claiming a town read on a widely suspected player isn't necessarily what I would call a "clever tactic". It's basic scum play to know that you can't just jump every single wagon.

Maybe I'm underestimating SS, either way if he's scum he will slip up eventually. Not my priority right now.

UNVOTE:

what is it with fire and ice games and a massive amounto f replace outs. pretty much every slot in my game had more than 1 person in it.

This really doesn't matter for the game, unless you think replacing out in this format has some implication on alignment.

Hey guys! I am definitely not scum, and I'm sticking to that story!

I'll catch up as soon as I can. Hopefully tonight. Probably not.

Welcome to the game, scum. Go ahead and vote me, I know it's tempting.

VOTE: transcend

What? You're seriously going to vote Transcend over Rory/Kuroi or Io/Fitz? Or hell even over SS?

[BK201]

how often do you get mislynched btw

All the fucking time.

You don't have to worry about getting mislynched this time at least.

[Joshz]

io/fitz is town

[Transcend]

how often do you get mislynched btw

All the fucking time.

UNVOTE:

then i'll give you botd because i'vescumread you in like every single game i've played with you and been wrong every time.

[BK201]

how often do you get mislynched btw

All the fucking time.

UNVOTE:

then i'll give you botd because i'vescumread you in like every single game i've played with you and been wrong every time.

So you're not allowed to scum-read him until you falsely town-read him? Am I right?

[BK201]

io/fitz is town

Far from it. How can you even think that?

[Joshz]

because io/fitz is town.

since someone is finally going on my ss wagon

VOTE: ss

transcend, not mafia, snarky snowman... too many anti town players

[Transcend]

why is io/fitz scum?

[BK201]

why is io/fitz scum?

I'm really not going to explain it to you. Read my posts, I'm pissed if you haven't been reading my posts man.

[BK201]

because io/fitz is town.

since someone is finally going on my ss wagon

VOTE: ss

transcend, not mafia, snarky snowman... too many anti town players

You're being anti-town too by saying Rory is town, when you said yourself he was scum and is town now because you told mafia teams to shoot Rory. Anti-town if I ever saw it from someone who wasn't trolling.

[KuroiXHF]

how often do you get mislynched btw

All the fucking time.

UNVOTE:

then i'll give you botd because i'vescumread you in like every single game i've played with you and been wrong every time.

This doesn't make any sense to me.

This is how my brain just read that.

As Transcend

*Sees KuroiXHF in previous games*
*Finds him scummy*
*votes him*
"Oh shit. He's town."
(Keep in mind the words "Every single game." Meaning more than one. Probably at least three.)

*Sees Kuroi replace into the new game.*
*Finds his posts to be scummy*
"Oh, he OBVIOUSLY must be scum!"
*Votes him.*
"Woah, hold on a minute there, Transcendy! There's a possibility he could be town!"
(To Kuroi) Heya there, Champerino. Are you ever mislynched?
*Receives response*
"Well I better give him a chance then!"

I kind of want to vote you right now and you can join Snowy in the doghouse called "Solid Scumville"