In post 131, tojam2 wrote:Also, I doubt I'm the first person to delay moving their vote. It was Jae's comment that reminded me to move it, 81 was my reasoning.
I read you as scum for a different reason which you haven't cared to address (not even briefly, to point out the flaw in it as a more experienced player), the gutread was parenthetical and is a tiny fraction of my overall content so far. So I dislike that justification. If you're voting for me simply for a parenthetical gutread, why haven't you voted bowdown? There's even less justification in "feels forced" than in "seems like he may have misrepresented something". Because the read was against you? (See 65 below.)
In post 65, bowdown wrote:- Finally, I'm pinged by TriangleShark's entrance - the add on "Because everyone deserves some love" feels forced.
In post 131, tojam2 wrote:81 - noobscum would pick someone to apply pressure to before the game, like a plan of action as if mafia has a strict order.
I'm a noob, I've recently been scum, and I didn't do this. I'm pointing this out because your arguments don't seem to have depth, or you haven't fully elaborated them yet. E.g., you still haven't explained why a Mafia wouldn't want to drum up conversation in order to seem towny.
Why don't you care about Titus' posts? I don't feel like there's been much explanation about anything from you. Maybe it should be obvious and I'm just not seeing it because I'm a noob? Either way, I'd love to hear about your reasons from you, rather than just assuming what they are. I'm not sure how to get reads otherwise!
In post 125, GuiltyLion wrote:Further, I think he may have slipped knowledge of town!Lemons here:
In post 103, bowdown wrote:Seeing who jumps and doesn't jump on the lemon wagon and their reasons for doing so could be illuminating. Extreme case is that two others quickly jump on Lemon with poor reasons - d2 we look strongly at them.
I've also been assuming that EL is Town based on my read of him, so I feel like this could just be newbishness as easily as it could be a slip. It could even be a slip by you for pointing out that it could be a slip by him, couldn't it?
My reads:
Tojam - I dislike the consistent lack of explanations, so:
slightly scummy, a weak read
Titus - some weird behavior, I don't know how to read it, but intuition suggests she'd not behave this way as maf, so:
townie, a weak read
EL - inconsistent and defensive, but seems newbish more than anything, so:
townie, a weak read
Jae - seemed to hijack Titus' naked vote thing, if the purpose of the vote was to test newbscum (?) then this could be Jae defusing it, so, if true:
scummy, a weak read
*
bowdown - hasn't addressed
125, so:
slightly scummy, a weak read
GL - hasn't hestitated to point out people's mistakes, which is probably:
nulltown
Sparkles - I don't have a read
Triangle - I don't have a read
*This read on Jae is further complicated by the fact that it's really hard to tell whether or not they were in teacher mode or player mode with the responses to Titus. I'd hate to read it as scummy when all they were doing was trying to help us newbs.