Revan wrote:VOTE: EL
I don't want EL in LYLO anyway
I've been feeling sympathetic toward Revan because he seems confused to me and is just trying to scumhunt ineffectively, but some of his later posts have been making me uneasy. It seems to me at this point that he's sheeping the experienced players to get town points, exhibit one ^.
Especially considering that this was posted not too long before he voted for me, it's starting to seem like he's trying too hard to appear town.
In post 362, bowdown wrote:Something that I think is lost in the conversation about Lemon is that Lemon is new. I think I am the only one of the noobs with prior forum mafia/werewolf experience.
nancy had a post about her experience in forum mafia and werewolf, and there is speculation about Revan having prior experience, but he isn't exactly acting calm and composed. I've already quoted nancy's post and I have brought it up more than once I think. This is also blatantly ignoring the fact that as a complete and utter newb to forum mafia, I was being voted up super early on D1.
Let me explain what I didn't like about tojam's claim. He claimed one-shot town without much provocation. If he isn't scum, now scum knows to avoid him because he won't die the first time they attack him. Plus, now they have more clues about what other townies are in the game. It doesn't make sense to reveal this early in the game, much less give the scum that much information, which is why I didn't think it was genuine.
Now that I think about it, no one else has been trying to run him up, which makes me think no one else is the one shot town, so I'll unvote for now.
But I'd still like to point out that according to Cakez' matrix, there isn't necessarily a bulletproof town in the game at all.
UNVOTE: tojam2
Titus completely ignored my question about whether she expected a newb town to act in a different way than I did the first time I was being voted up, by the way, and I'd like an answer to that.