Newbie 1770: Water Game Over

[mhsmith0]

Votecount 1.12

MooginSoosy (1)

TierShift ,

nydushermain (1)

RadiantCowbells ,

Fykus (2)

Pepchoninga , -Grey- ,

JackChaos (1)

MooginSoosy ,

-Grey- (2)

JackChaos , Fykus ,

TierShift (2)

nydushermain , Formerfish ,

Day one deadline is

Monday

Wednesday January 25th, 2 PM PST. (expired on 2017-01-25 15:00:00)

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

[/size]

[Formerfish]

Oh fuck. We've entered into an "only scum would say that" hole.

The only thing that'll bring us out is a scum lynch.

[-Grey-]

My two biggest scumreads are voting me.

This is hilarious.

[nydushermain]

I told my friend about what was happening just now and he told me I have to lynch the first person to break the chain. Is the mod lynchable?

[-Grey-]

Just look at the energy that is being spent in attempting to distract from Fykus scumclaiming all over the place.

[MooginSoosy]

Let's try it, no mod needed here hahaha.

Also holy cow these votes are ALL OVER and there's about 2 days left. I feel pretty good about keeping my vote on Jack though

[nydushermain]

Just look at the energy that is being spent in attempting to distract from Fykus scumclaiming all over the place.

I'm not calling him townie but I just don't see it. He doesn't seem like obvious scum to me.

[-Grey-]

Just look at the energy that is being spent in attempting to distract from Fykus scumclaiming all over the place.

I'm not calling him townie but I just don't see it. He doesn't seem like obvious scum to me.

What part of voting his highest townread strikes you as attempting to solve the game?

[nydushermain]

Let's try it, no mod needed here hahaha.

Also holy cow these votes are ALL OVER and there's about 2 days left. I feel pretty good about keeping my vote on Jack though

Yeah it's kinda tragic. I'd say we should all come to a general consensus by tomorrow but it'll just end up with me having to compromise pretty sure on you, jack, or fykus...

Anyone have a strong read/opinion on pep?

[nydushermain]

Just look at the energy that is being spent in attempting to distract from Fykus scumclaiming all over the place.

I'm not calling him townie but I just don't see it. He doesn't seem like obvious scum to me.

What part of voting his highest townread strikes you as attempting to solve the game?

He didn't say that the person he was voting was his strongest town read if I recall. Felt like people skimmed through his post. Correct me if I'm wrong but I believe he said that within people of the same colour categories, the order didn't reflect the strength of his reads.

[nydushermain]

You're right though, I forgot he voted on a townread because I overlooked t thinking people were overreacting.

[-Grey-]

He didn't say that the person he was voting was his strongest town read if I recall

He admitted it when I called him on it.

[nydushermain]

He didn't say that the person he was voting was his strongest town read if I recall

He admitted it when I called him on it.

Hm. Maybe I should reread the last couple of pages. My memory of earlier events is much stronger.

[nydushermain]

What do you think of my case on TS?

[Fykus]

VOTE: TS

Also shes probably ranked lowest of my town reads tbh.

[-Grey-]

VOTE: TS

Also shes probably ranked lowest of my town reads tbh.

You're still admitting to voting a townread, and town doesn't vote townreads!

[-Grey-]

What do you think of my case on TS?

Effort is not indicative of alignment.

[Fykus]

And mafia doesnt admit to voting on their "townreads" either.

[nydushermain]

What do you think of my case on TS?

Effort is not indicative of alignment.

I meant do you disagree or agree with it. I don't care about your read on me.

[-Grey-]

This is when you, TS, tried to divert attention away to moogin.

<snip>

So your claim that

you tried to divert pressure away from toto and onto moogin

just to nullify the argument between the two

<snip>

Funny enough, I think that moogin is still leaning scum

Your TS case is bogus, because you are accusing your scumread of diverting attention

onto a scumlean

.

The only way your case adds up is if you are reading moogin as town, because scum would not draw attention to their newbscum partner.

[nydushermain]

This is when you, TS, tried to divert attention away to moogin.

<snip>

So your claim that

you tried to divert pressure away from toto and onto moogin

just to nullify the argument between the two

<snip>

Funny enough, I think that moogin is still leaning scum

Your TS case is bogus, because you are accusing your scumread of diverting attention

onto a scumlean

.

The only way your case adds up is if you are reading moogin as town, because scum would not draw attention to their newbscum partner.

But what if moogin is town... I'm not claiming in any way that they're partners. I'm claiming that his progression is not natural and he's just as inconsistent, if not more, than fykus

[-Grey-]

But what if moogin is town... I'm not claiming in any way that they're partners. I'm claiming that his progression is not natural and he's just as inconsistent, if not more, than fykus

If your case was real, you'd HAVE to be calling moogin town, BUT YOU DIDN'T.

Saying " this guy is scum for bringing pressure to bear on this other guy that may also be NEWBscum" in a singleball game does not compute.

And that is why I believe the scumteam lies within {Jack, Fykus, Nydus}

Those are the only three I'll Lynch today.

[nydushermain]

But what if moogin is town... I'm not claiming in any way that they're partners. I'm claiming that his progression is not natural and he's just as inconsistent, if not more, than fykus

If your case was real, you'd HAVE to be calling moogin town, BUT YOU DIDN'T.

Saying " this guy is scum for bringing pressure to bear on this other guy that may also be NEWBscum" in a singleball game does not compute.

And that is why I believe the scumteam lies within {Jack, Fykus, Nydus}

Those are the only three I'll Lynch today.

Incorrect. He diverted pressure to both fykus and moogin and I claimed that he could be partners with toto/RC. You're claiming that I'm making a case where I HAVE to only have TS and his partner as scum. That's not the case. I don't think people have been playing very townie this game and thus have many people as scum. However, these are the people I think have been the scummiest, namely TS. I'm disappointed because you came across as someone who was reading carefully.

[-Grey-]

Not buying the act.

TS' actions would clear Moogin if your case was legit. You're only concerned with finding ways to keep lynch options open.

[nydushermain]

Not buying the act.

TS' actions would clear Moogin if your case was legit. You're only concerned with finding ways to keep lynch options open.

It clears moogin if I thought I was 100% correct. For the record, I've noted that moogin's push on TS made her townie in my eyes. You're suffering from reading my ISO without context.