Newbie 1769: Happy New Year! (Post-Game)

[RadiantCowbells]

I wonder if there's a dictinct change in your tone after I replace in if you find the prospect of facing me as scum as stressful as you said before.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

no the distinct change in my tone is not something i'm comfortable talking about online and has nothing to do with you or this game

[gigabyteTroubadour]

i kind of just need to put my head against a wall and meditate. not sure what i believe in any more

going to catch up starting from post 659 in a bit but like (posting here so i know what post i left off at)

this game is really fucking surreal. feel like this table is going to bond together from it in the end.

rask is a bad lynch unless the PR wants to CC. honestly it should be up to them, as long as they don't wait until LYLO or MYLO (when we have no mislynches left).

matt bringing up the meta gives him huge townpoints btw, I knew of it but I don't read it as AI because tracker is the safest claim whether you're a town PR or scum. i really cannot see newbie scum deciding to dig up dirt on Rask like that to discredit him, it's town.

^ this was before you replaced in and basically when it started

[gigabyteTroubadour]

-grey-? waaaay too towny. aggressive af and not in the least bit afraid to go out on a limb to find them scums

what was the trajectory that lead from this...

to

guys, i want to move that pressure onto -Grey-, seriously. yes the mistakes stated so far are someone elses, and arguably shouldnt be held against the slot, but creature stated awhile back iirc: if a slot seems scummy at first and later looks more town, its PROBABLY still scum. im vibing with that statement now. im gonna make a -Grey- masterpost next to back this up tho. consider moving votes around, please.

...?

@cassie

was it just reading grey/gayreen's iso because you wanted to make a post on them?

[gigabyteTroubadour]

cassies walls are really hard to parse without the post buttons lol

[schadd_]

i'm here my darlings

[RadiantCowbells]

You should contribute something then.

[schadd_]

should i, though?

[schadd_]

we have so many fun endgame things to do

[RadiantCowbells]

Cass isn't here and I don't feel like I'll get any thing further out of talking to GBT at this point.

So yes, if you want to change my current read on GBT!scum then you should do something.

[schadd_]

wanna hammertest? or something

[schadd_]

i'm not in an especially productive state of being right now, for a few reasons

[gigabyteTroubadour]

i'm doing a post on it but i highly recommend reading cassie's masterposts from D1

especially the ones on the grey slot

very uh

enlightening

to say the least

wanna hammertest? or something

hammertest me...???

or rc (please say rc)

[RadiantCowbells]

No, I want you to contribute reasons why you think that Cass is scum over GBT.

[schadd_]

???

why would i want to hammertest you

[RadiantCowbells]

Okay then. I will probably not post much here until you do something significant or Cass starts posting then.

[schadd_]

No, I want you to contribute reasons why you think that Cass is scum over GBT.

you're not allowed to want me to do things yet

[gigabyteTroubadour]

#107 implies scum mindset: asking about townreads and why no ones talking about them. remember, scum know everything.

Is it a bad idea to say who your townreads are, or are you guys just opting to not say them

this is a huge leap that i don't get, probably from actually knowing gayreen is scum

#137 is a sudden jump in content at a critical point and a CRITICAL break in character for GAYreen. GAYreen asks about putting the l-1 vote on TB here. note the following: 87 and 91 imply that he DOES NOT BUY potential arguments vs. TB. there is no change by this point, nothing has come up implying he changed his mind. and #101 states a wariness/dislike of naked votes, when schadd_'s vote arguably was higher content than GAYreen's uhh... intent to l-1? (its not even l-1 vote or intent to hammer, its like the hammer vote and l-1 got mixed up and he was stating intent to l-1) this post (#137) is WILDLY out of character with previous actions, in a way that is, ok, NAI -- but if you parse it town, says badtown, and if you parse it scum feels p damn scummy.

there are just a lot of bits where cassie points out scummy stuff gayreen/grey did but tries really hard to not commit to a read on it

contrast me where i strongly townread gayreen

#534: FIRST post worth commenting on??? commenting on MBG's list at 239, not saying a word about those weird ass claims and such prior? arguably this is NAI leaning town but im suspicious af about there being nothing to comment on from 135 to 160-ish just for example. #535 still leaning on MBG but it is valid and in order here.

??

here too

so cassie is suspicious of grey not commenting on anything before the first post he quoted but also leans town on it...?

#197 continues casting shade at schadd_. it IS a light towntell for noobs but leans NAI for experienced players. REMINDER: GAYREEN IS NOT A NOOB. the shade-casting continues in #199 and #202, #202 is buzzwordy, and the remaining 6 posts are nearly contentless except for #361 trying to cast doubt on creature's conftown status.

this is still overstating gayreen's experience when i kept saying he was basically a newb

like she really wants to find gayreen scummy

#552 seems to be a scumslip? town can easily see the paranoia that would lead to #431, no one else questioned it, even mbg seemed to take it in stride, treat it as fair.

This looks really reckless for scum, but what bothers me is that he took 13 mins to make post 240.

What's your opinion?

Seriously? How is that even a concern?

I'm not overly keen on his slot, but that's hella nitpicky.

how is this a scumslip in any way, shape, or form

same with 568??

i'm not done going through each point but i'm not crazy in thinking that cassie's scumread of grey is just not something someone uninformed sees

like

it reads as though she wanted to scumread him or knew that he was scum already

[gigabyteTroubadour]

getting water i'm kind of excited

[schadd_]

i don't see myself doing anything other than hanging out here for another while. notepad document isn't caught up thru day 3, nor curated at all. and my shoulders are too tense from {other thing} to finish it.

how are things going, you guys. RC, what % gut would you say your read is right now?

[gigabyteTroubadour]

the only negative interaction between grey and casserole though WAS the ego fight right

because other than that i think the cassie/grey interactions are a lot worse (in terms of hinting they're partners) than i remember

i don't see myself doing anything other than hanging out here for another while. notepad document isn't caught up thru day 3, nor curated at all. and my shoulders are too tense from {other thing} to finish it.

how are things going, you guys. RC, what % gut would you say your read is right now?

im doing kind of well actually i feel like i have a leg to stand on now

[gigabyteTroubadour]

schadd_ have you read casserole's masterposts now knowing that grey is scum?

[schadd_]

maybe i just want cass to come in and have another case of the vapours after seeing i'm town

schadd_ have you read casserole's masterposts now knowing that grey is scum?

oh, have i

[schadd_]

masterpost theatre

[schadd_]

^ see that is what i am useful for rn