Mini 1881 - Cult of Kira [Game Over!]

[RadiantCowbells]

Votecount 1.15

ThinkBig (3) - KuroiXHF, Elena Fisher, Crystal Allies
Titus (3) - Creature, -Grey-, yessiree
-Grey- (2) - ThinkBig, Titus
Elena Fisher (1) - 1 Shot Vanilla Town
yessiree (1) - RadiantCowbells

Not Voting (2) - beeboy, FishytheFish

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Current deadline is Monday, February 27th at 9PM EST.

Mod Notes:

Seeking a replacement for Titus and ThinkBig, in that order.

_______________________________________


Can we just lynch the original cultist and end the game today?

VOTE: Yessiree

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

@Creature - 321

[yessiree]

Titus

it's still a long way to 3p lylo

[-Grey-]

Please don't replace? can we all take a break and hugs or something. Grey you're being way out of line here.

I wasn't out of line at all.

She responded to me like I was town, but she's pushing me.

That's bullshit.

So she's scum. I agree that she's more likely than not scum. That doesn't justify your behaviour here.

I refuse to apologize for a reaction test.

Threatening to gamethrow is not a reaction test.

You talked to me like I was town!

I busted your ass.

No need to be all sour grapes about it.

[yessiree]

RC

when was the last time you voted me?

[-Grey-]

I ain't feeling the AtE from Titus.

She knows damned well I do crazy shit as town to find scum. Instead of changing her read to reflect that undeniable fact, she goes drama queen and replaces out.

[RadiantCowbells]

I ain't feeling the AtE from Titus.

She knows damned well I do crazy shit as town to find scum. Instead of changing her read to reflect that undeniable fact, she goes drama queen and replaces out.

DUDE.

[Creature]

Okay, post more so I can get better reads.

[RadiantCowbells]

Keep your vote on her: sure. Keep thinking that she's scum: sure. I still think that she's more likely than not scum. What happened to not being a dick to people who are already down?

[yessiree]

RC thinks I recruited Titus and then proceeded to lynch her because loose ends?

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

RC thinks I recruited Titus and then proceeded to lynch her because loose ends?

Was Titus close to a lynch?

[-Grey-]

Keep your vote on her: sure. Keep thinking that she's scum: sure. I still think that she's more likely than not scum. What happened to not being a dick to people who are already down?

I'm getting fed up with constantly being targeted on d1.

The gloves are off.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Okay, post more so I can get better reads.

Keep ignoring my posts, sure.
It just shows that you can't explain your town read 317

[SnarkySnowman]

Mod: Replace me

RC is town too, and I'm not dealing with personal drama shit in another game.

Replace me please

Serious this time.

/last post.

Mod, everyone decided to collectively repalce out

Working on a replacement for Titus, then TB. Creature, I feel this

If anyone changes their mind, please let me know ASAP so I can stop looking for a replacement.

[yessiree]

RC thinks I recruited Titus and then proceeded to lynch her because loose ends?

Was Titus close to a lynch?

Oh, you think I'm voting her just for show

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Oh, you think I'm voting her just for show

Wasn't my question.
I'm not saying here that you are scum who recruited Titus. I'm asking if Titus was close to being lynched? Your post 359 suggests that a Titus lynch seemed the most plausible option.

[yessiree]

@Yesiree: All I care about re:setup spec is that people understand to play their cards close to their chest and I want to be able to understand how the whole passing off/lending the Death Note works. Also, how the cult recruit works in NAR is extremely important for people who may be able to stop it. All of this is info that I'm sure cult already has, so it only weakens us if we don't have it.

I don't think people needed to be reminded to understand what their roles are?

reads on Titus/Grey?

[yessiree]

no, Titus has like 2 votes

[Crystal Allies]

Titus is probably town and not recruited, given play so far, imo.

I don't know about Grey. I was originally reading Grey v Titus as a distancing gambit, but now it seems legit so I doubt that Grey and Titus are both cult or both Police.

People know what their roles are. People don't know how the cult recruit works in NAR. That's what is important to discerning how the roles will actually interact with, y'know, the unique game mechanic.

-V

[yessiree]

Fair enough, but do you think your vote is in a good place right now?

[Crystal Allies]

No; I didn't want to vote for Thinkbig--that's Yume's doing. With TB replacing out and seeming more like they didn't understand the point of my inquiry rather than being dodgy, I'm good with a vote change:
VOTE: FishyFish

Really want more from this slot.
I also find it really bothersome that FishyFish was complicit in inciting the Titus v Grey stuff.

Also, Snarky got back to my questions with edits to my posts. I'll quote them all here.

-V

[-Grey-]

VOTE: FishyFish

Really want more from this slot.

I also find it really bothersome that FishyFish was complicit in inciting the Titus v Grey stuff.

Please show where he did that.

fixed the quote, realizing that you didn't intend to vote.

[-Grey-]

VOTE: FishyFish

Really want more from this slot.

I also find it really bothersome that FishyFish was complicit in inciting the Titus v Grey stuff.

Please show where he did that.

Fixed

[Crystal Allies]

MOD

: What happens to a player when they are recruited into the cult?
How does the cult recruit resolve in NAR?
Does cult-recruiting count as visiting a player?
Outside of Police, what could possibly stop a cult recruit from happening?
Does being recruited into the cult change anything other than a player's win condition?

Win condition does change to the cult win condition when someone is successfully recruited, but otherwise I cannot answer any of those.

@SnarkySnowman/MOD:

You wrote that 'The Death Note can be passed off temporarily'--if this temporary Death Note Holder is killed during the night, does town win? Furthermore, who can the Death Note be passed off to--is this temporary pass to anyone or just cult?
You also wrote that 'no Death Note actions' can be taken if the Death Note passed off permanently. What qualifies as a 'Death Note action'? Can the permanent passing off of the Death Note only be done to other cult members or can anyone be passed the Death Note?

-V

I didn't miss this, but I forgot to answer. And my answer for question one, I cannot answer that. For the one about Death Note Actions, I can't tell you anything aside from the obvious, which is, killing is a Death Note action, and there may or may not be others. -Snarky

So:
We do NOT know how a player's role changes when recruited. Why does ThinkBig think they're made vanilla? Maybe I should go back to voting ThinkBig...
Mod did not say if a player who is given the Death Note gets recruited/has to be cult or not. :/ I would assume 'yes', otherwise this opens a whole can of worms.
It's curious that Snarky says 'killing' is a Death Note action, but leaves out recruiting, which seems to be the case. Regardless, this seems to indicate that there may or may not be other cult actions we don't know about.

Regardless, I think we should proceed as though the Cult Recruit resolves as recruitment would in NAR. That's the big thing here.

-V

[Crystal Allies]

Grey and Titus feel a little off to me. I want to think harder about them when I'm not sleepy.

Here, though I suppose Creature is just as guilty of pitting them against each other on the same page, though seems to be reacting to Fishy's position:

I'm fine with Grey and Titus being competing wagons.

I was trying to avoid that conflict rather than push it further, because I don't think it was getting us anywhere and, lo and behold, now we've got replace-outs.

-V