/disagree with this, also.Thestatusquo wrote:Actually, the claim wasnt that you could be certain, it was that I don't think you can ever make the claim that X is NOT Y's scum partner. And since you take Shanba not being Patricks scumbuddy and Andy not being crubs as a premise, your whole case is flawed from the start.
Now, granted, I agree with you that it's significantly weaker when the players in question are highly experienced/advanced, but there are definitely things that I read as definitively genuine.
Bzzt.Shanba wrote:You're going to be disappointed, then. I may have a fairly defeatist attitude, but this is not indicative of my alignment. What would I, as scum, have to be defeatist about right now? We're in triple lylo. I'm probably not going to be lynched today. Unless you believe it's because I'm scum with Crub? That would follow. But even then, I would still have a very good chance of winning as scum.
First of all, re: "Unless you believe it's because I'm scum with Crub" made me laugh and cringe. I think I've stated no less than three times in the past two pages that I think both you and Crub are scum.
Now, you have every reason to be defeatest. The Cop is outed and has an innocent result (yours truly), with no counterclaims. That narrows the field of suspicion down significantly. If I happen to be the Doctor, it's all gravy for you. Kill me tonight, IH probably outs one more person, kill him tomorrow night. Pretty solid chance of mislynch in LyLo. However, if you believe that I am
Now, regarding the rest of your post: I will concede that you did make a point way earlier today about the "inactivity towards end-of-day" thing, but two things:
1) An assload of discussion has happened since then, and you have been distinctly lacking in analysis of said discussion.
2) You yourself are now becoming one of those "inactives" that you griped about earlier. When I asked for the last set of prods, I decided that I'd look to see who posted and then disappeared for 72 hours. You were the only such person. Like I said, definite minus points.