OK...from the start read through catchup:
Page 1 misc RVS crap (
plus a claim?)
Is DRK being cheeky scum here?
I'm considering the Eddie "lovers" claim legit. Just saying.
Not a fan of
Imp's Post 47. IAWS has done virtually nothing (i.e. most of his wagon at this point is RVS I assume) and yet Imp is giving CMM some shit for moving off IAWS.
CoolDog....oh me oh my....LAMIST post 51? A quick ISO makes me think CooLDoG is more a TR than a SR for me.
UNVOTE: CooLDoG
I definitely see the point of others who think CD was trying to come off as town with his reaction...but I'm going to believe it. If I'm scum and someone claims early unnecessarily (and if I believe them)...then I'm just playing it off and I'll consider how to handle it that night. Like I said...it does come across a little LAMIST to me but I'm choosing to believe it for now.
Townreading Hans so far.
IAWS was at l-3 before he had even made his first post.
Kind of feeling Desully is town.
Kind of feeling horrordude is town.
@ Imp...
Why are IAWS and Boon scum?
Imp
shines a little shade (IMO) on Hans...
OK...so imp is probably calling Boon scum for OMGUS (yes?)...but decides to get off his scum!IAWS wagon and hop on the wagon scum!Boon just exited. Also happens to be the largest wagon.
@Hans...I think at this point in the game we had been out of RVS for a bit.
Liking horror a bit.
implosion makes nice well-reasoned posts but I'm not sure that they are getting anywhere. Kind of like a butterfly just flittering around looking for a good spot to land.
Kind of TRing DRK from her "sheeping" exchange with Hans. Still TRing Hans as well btw.
204 by Eddie is a compelling case for CooLDoG. Whether I believe Cool or not...I can't find too much fault in those that have voted him.
So Eddie...
222are you definitively saying the lover claim with you and Boon is fake? If so...I need to relook at both of you. I still TR you but I would need to look Boon over again. And when you are saying CooLDoG attacked you are you are referring to his indignation that could be construed as coming from town...yes? Not attack in the sense that he wanted to kickstart a wagon on you or Boon...yes?
I really didn't like WhemeStar's posts
227 and
228. Nor his response to me asking him about it. I left it alone because 1) I didn't think questioning him was going to get any further and 2) I
assumed he was saying Darklyn was claiming fruit vendor....hence the rough spot. But as the role is NAI regardless of whther my assuming is right or not...I'm not going to consider it.
@Boon...the trouble with joking (or in this case fakeclaiming) is that bad shit can happen to town. Fakeclaims can result in real PRs claiming. Fakeclaims can get the ire of town and result in TvT wagons/attacks. Sure...there could be instances where scum could be baited into NKing a no-low PR townie that fakeclaimed...but anything that interjects unnecessary WIFOM is an unnecessary pita.
Nice observation by Eddie....making me rethink my rethinking of CooLDoG.....
@Hans...I do not recall seeing you ask me a question about CooLDoG. If you mean the general question horror answered....because it was a general question and horror answered it.
@imp...why does having nothing to do with your vote make you happy? If I'm being "opaque" ask me a question. At least I am (was) voting someone I suspect. More than what a few can say atm. I voted CooLDoG initially on the tails of a good post by Eddie that made sense to me + pressure. On closer reread this morning I am less sure about Cool though. I've gone back and forth on him. As for my questions...not a lot. Mostly just clearing up others comments so I would better understand them. In the case of the question I asked you...I asked it out of context and once I realized it there was no reason to ponder it more.
@WhemeStar...do you have any completed scum games on this site? If "dat's how you play" describes your play so far in this game and others...you are going to continue being scum's best friend every time you don't roll scum. Which is TBD in this game.
@WhemeStar...so
CooLDoG is scum for voting you, the player you were voting (DeSully) I assume
you'd still like to see lynched, and horror is
scum for trying to push a PL mislynch. And so you decide to vote me. WTF? And how are two questions you didn't provide any response to AI towards me? smh....
VOTE: WhemeStar
Other persons of interest at this point are IAWS, CMM, implosion....and CooLDoG.
@Hans...did I need to give you special attention?
Also...if I post anymore today it will be short phone snippets as I will be traveling most of today and another game (and RL) needs my attention before I leave in a few hours.