Mini 1907: Oddrole Mafia IV (Game over)

[boring]

Oh, and to reiterate.. TOWN should've also let it go. What I'm saying is that was more likely bad town play than bad scum play.

96 I think the pot's calling the kettle black here. You're probably right, regardless.

[Chickadee]

Well vig doesn't really seem like a very rare role to me... And if we are going to go over what might have happened last night, I will say that my role does not have the ability to protect itself or anyone else, so I have no information for you.

If we start claiming "who DOESN'T have the ability to protect people," you're gonna narrow down the pool for a night kill real quick.

^^ Possibly Town. I too was thinking why Java felt the need to declare that bit about his role. In fact, I could brush off Creature's Vig and Chicka's crumb at being a protective as being jokey, but I don't feel like Java was joking at all.

Well played, champ. (@Java)

I never crumbed to being a protective role. So I'm not sure what you're talking about. Either way, I think it should be dropped right now though.

[eagerSnake]

VC 1.07

Javajoe24 (2) [L-5]: Almost50, massive
massive (2) [L-5]: Creature, GuiltyLion
Chickadee (1) [L-6]: Desperado
SnarkySnowman (1) [L-6]: Rautherdir
Desperado (1) [L-6]: GinghamDog
Creature (1) [L-6]: podoboq

Not Voting (5): SnarkySnowman, Chickadee, Javajoe24, TheBrie, boring

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 deadline in (expired on 2017-05-19 12:33:03).

[TheBrie]

When did I give out role information?
Is it to early to make the observations I was?

Based on Creature's reply, I'm figuring he was only making a reference to the previous game.

[TheBrie]

And Java's information about his role seemed weird. If he didn't know anything, he shouldn't say anything.

[Almost50]

Oh, and to reiterate.. TOWN should've also let it go. What I'm saying is that was more likely bad town play than bad scum play.

96 I think the pot's calling the kettle black here. You're probably right, regardless.

Mate, it has been pointed out and highlighted already by the time I posted that. I do get your point, but it simply doesn't apply when you're commenting on someone who had commented on someone's bad move.

[SnarkySnowman]

VOTE: SnarkySnowman

Cause I didn't get to vote you in our last game together.

Which game was that?

vote: chickadee

post 8 is 100% scumtalk

Seriously though, this is BS.

you think congratulating everyone on still being alive is town?

...wrong game?

UNVOTE:

I have nothing against JavaJoe at the moment, so I don't see a need for there to be three votes on him right now.

I read this as town. I don't think scum would voluntarily do this, unless they are trying to get town cred, which is possible considering how they pointed it out along with the un vote.

Thoughts?

I know asking for thoughts was directed at pretty much anyone but me. Thought I'd share anyway.

I just didn't want a naked unvote out there.

methinks you care too much about your image for page 2... VOTE: chickadee

Chickadee (1) [L-6]:

Desperado

GuiltyLion (1) [L-6]:

podoboq

podoboq (1) [L-6]:

boring

SnarkySnowman (1) [L-6]:

Rautherdir

Desperado (1) [L-6]:

GinghamDog

Almost50 (1) [L-6]:

TheBrie

I might vig one of the bolded players.

dayvig: creature

Well vig doesn't really seem like a very rare role to me... And if we are going to go over what might have happened last night, I will say that my role does not have the ability to protect itself or anyone else, so I have no information for you.

If we start claiming "who DOESN'T have the ability to protect people," you're gonna narrow down the pool for a night kill real quick.

^^ Possibly Town. I too was thinking why Java felt the need to declare that bit about his role. In fact, I could brush off Creature's Vig and Chicka's crumb at being a protective as being jokey, but I don't feel like Java was joking at all.

Well played, champ. (@Java)

You're talking a lot
but you're not saying anything
when I have nothing to say
my lips are sealed
say something once
why say it again?

I've collected a few random things of interest.

And kudos to everyone for not dying!

I wouldn't read much from that. Maybe she was involved in trying to kill someone. Maybe she helped saved them. Maybe neither.

VOTE: GuiltyLion

We've never been on the same team and I don't expect it to start now. We should just hydra at some point, GL.

I've heard that GL knows Podo's scum game. So if he reads Podo as town either Podo is or they're both scum.

Atleast I didn't become a Lich.

Does this mean he already is a lich? If there is one. This sounds a little self conscious to me. But maybe too obvious.

No, I'm just saying AT LEAST it gave us real substance to talk about.

I agree, though as town lost the game where we had info based on n0 deaths, this might turn out better. We have the knowledge that kills were blocked.

Overall I haven't got much to go on though I might start finding Creature annoying. If annoying=scum this game would be much easier.
UNVOTE:

Why are we making such a big thing of this

wasnt this game a day start or did I miss something

[Chickadee]

Why are we making such a big thing of this

wasnt this game a day start or did I miss something

This game was a night start.

You seem very out of touch with everything so far. It doesn't sit right with me.

[podoboq]

Why are we making such a big thing of this

wasnt this game a day start or did I miss something

This game was a night start.

You seem very out of touch with everything so far. It doesn't sit right with me.

That's just Snarky

[boring]

VOTE: Chickadee between my tingling and Snarky's vote, I'm cool here. He's a low-poster, but he has a good eye.

[Creature]

VOTE: Chickadee

[eagerSnake]

VC 1.08

Chickadee (4) [L-3]: Desperado, SnarkySnowman, boring, Creature
Javajoe24 (2) [L-5]: Almost50, massive
massive (1) [L-6]: GuiltyLion
SnarkySnowman (1) [L-6]: Rautherdir
Desperado (1) [L-6]: GinghamDog
Creature (1) [L-6]: podoboq

Not Voting (3): Chickadee, Javajoe24, TheBrie

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 deadline in (expired on 2017-05-19 12:33:03).

[Almost50]

VOTE: Chickadee between my tingling and Snarky's vote, I'm cool here. He's a low-poster, but he has a good eye.

Your reasoning is "because SS voted there"???

VOTE: Chickadee

And I guess yours is "because boring said she voted there because Snarky voted there"?!

OK.. intent to vote Chicadee because I want to sheep Creature who is sheeping boring who is sheeping Snarky who got a vote on Chicadee out of nowhere. Boy, that sounds like the best reasoning ever.

[Creature]

My reasoning is because it was a great opportunity to begin with a wagon.

[Almost50]

Then why didn't you join me & massive on javajoe earlier? Anything special about Chica as opposed to java? Or is there anything special about being the 4th voter rather than the 3rd?

[Creature]

I didn't feel JavaJoe24 would be a good wagon.

[Creature]

Or is there anything special about being the 4th voter rather than the 3rd?

Yes, 4-votes wagon > 3-votes wagon.

[Javajoe24]

I didn't feel JavaJoe24 would be a good wagon.

Why not? This sounds like you are trying to buddy me which is scummy to me. Honestly I would have joined a wagon against me if I were in your position.

[TheBrie]

My reasoning is because it was a great opportunity to begin with a wagon.

And we want to build wagons just because?

Not that there couldn't be aanything going on with Chick. I don't see anything solid though. The game is looking really murky. 8 is the most people I've sorted before.

[Creature]

And we want to build wagons just because?

Otherwise players won't do anything and scum will easily blend in.

[Creature]

We need to find activity. Maybe we can find activity by putting non-active players under the threat of being lynched?

[Javajoe24]

You didn't answer my question creature. I agree that putting pressure on people is needed to get information, but I do not like that you completely ignored my question.

[Creature]

I believed you would eventually be sorted better without a wagon.

[GuiltyLion]

VOTE: Chickadee between my tingling and Snarky's vote, I'm cool here. He's a low-poster, but he has a good eye.

Your reasoning is "because SS voted there"???

VOTE: Chickadee

And I guess yours is "because boring said she voted there because Snarky voted there"?!

OK.. intent to vote Chicadee because I want to sheep Creature who is sheeping boring who is sheeping Snarky who got a vote on Chicadee out of nowhere. Boy, that sounds like the best reasoning ever.

did you see post 99? It looks to me like boring pretty specifically said she didn't like Chickadee's friendly tone, so I feel like your first section here is a misrep. And why are you making assumptions about Creature's motives?

also speaking of Creature this is looking like his townplay on first pass

[GuiltyLion]

And we want to build wagons just because?

Not that there couldn't be aanything going on with Chick. I don't see anything solid though. The game is looking really murky. 8 is the most people I've sorted before.

I mean what would count as "solid" in the first 4 pages of a game? Do you think the votes on Chickadee are good or bad?