alright guys listen up
First off, more attention needs to be paid to the fact that Chickadee
stole massive's vote
. I don't see why anyone would read that as town given that she LITERALLY STOLE FROM HER COUNTERWAGON and still isn't voting him or pushing him as scum today. If we assume the same dueling wagons as most of D1 were to play out today, Chickadee's made it significantly harder to lynch herself and much more likely massive gets lynched, yet hasn't even cast any serious suspicion towards him today. If you're a town vote thief, you steal from your scumreads and you get them lynched. You don't steal from someone and then just ignore them and open the day by voting someone else, and later say this:
In post 828, Chickadee wrote:I did take Massive's vote, since Brie announced it for those that didn't put the dots together. I chose him because he was the likely lynch target yesterday. I figured that would be a good place to use my action since he was found scummy by most everyone in the game.
There's no real scumread on massive here. Chick is still playing nice and avoiding conflict.
Next, there are all the things I've been calling out. I don't see any genuine sorting from her, still. Her read on Creature went from "his vote on me was the worst" to "I don't remember what he's done" to "he's town by posting" without any consistent reason as to why it changed from point A to B to C. She's townreading me despite the fact that I've been pushing her the hardest since mid/late D1. These are opportunistic and safe reads.
I also don't understand why on earth Almost50 is townreading her. He's avoiding her wagon but he's never actually done this with any real passion or reasons given for townreading her. And Chick has Almost at the top of her lynchpool, which is a classic scum-scum distancing tactic. One townreads the other, one scumreads.
Then you have java who is coasting and making shallow posts like
884 where he's down to lynch pretty much everyone who hasn't yet made some kind of verifiable claim. There's no way someone can genuinely be on both sides of the massive/Chickadee fence.
Lynch today is between Chick/Almost/Java, I'll vote any of them and I'm interested to see if they'll vote eachother.
As for this:
In post 898, Chickadee wrote: In post 896, GuiltyLion wrote:Yesterday you said he was null and his vote on you was terrible. Are you seriously now saying he's town just because he's posting? This is what a fake townread looks like
I said I was conflicted.
Have you seen Scum!Creature? He's not invested at all.
His play has been really weird, yea, but I'm torn. Leaning town. And when I said his vote was bad, it was. And it was early in the day.
Didn't know I couldn't change my mind.
Did I say you couldn't change your mind? This is a misrep. The point is that there's no organic or visible progression in your Creature read, the reason you gave for townreading him could have applied far earlier in the game yet you said nothing about townreading him then, rather the points where you change from scumread to nullread to townread seem entirely arbitrary based on what the thread vibe seems to be.
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"