Large Normal 204: BooneyToonz III - Calling All Cryptids!END

[FourTrouble]

Town of salem had an innocent child role and I said, hey lets lynch the IC for lulz

That warrants a mod-kill.

[FourTrouble]

PMysterious feels town.

I take back what I said about PM earlier.

You need more words on these

I thought PM's initial comment on the confirmation felt town. My response was similar ("wow, quick confirmation, too bad we didn't get the confirmation after more posting, after people took positions"). The rest of PM's posts changed my read. His posts are awkward, and over-qualifying his responses with shit like "honestly," which never sits well with me.

[FourTrouble]

But is it enough to jump on him for? Especially since it was the first vote of the day (and likely a troll vote). Seems kinda forced.

What's forced about it? He voted mod-confirmed town. Even if it's "troll," it's pro-scum, for the reasons I've already mentioned.

[FourTrouble]

Egg's probably town.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Oh yeah? VOTE: WhyMafia

He's right you are ruggedly handsome.

FTFY

You're like that dude in Logan. Wearied by the seasons, creases in the face, knees unbending. The character played by Patrick Stewart.

[FourTrouble]

VOTE: Crush

[pisskop]

I like you 40

[Egg]

PMysterious feels town.

I take back what I said about PM earlier.

You need more words on these

I thought PM's initial comment on the confirmation felt town. My response was similar ("wow, quick confirmation, too bad we didn't get the confirmation after more posting, after people took positions"). The rest of PM's posts changed my read. His posts are awkward, and over-qualifying his responses with shit like "honestly," which never sits well with me.

I like the thought process here. This is someone who wants to lynch the scums.

[Transcend]

VOTE: Crush

Quoi?

[Crush]

But is it enough to jump on him for? Especially since it was the first vote of the day (and likely a troll vote). Seems kinda forced.

What's forced about it? He voted mod-confirmed town. Even if it's "troll," it's pro-scum, for the reasons I've already mentioned.

Because troll votes don't serve any purpose. No one would ever lynch a confirmed town, it's not pro-scum because it leads to nothing, his vote doesn't benefit scum in any way. I would say it's actually more pro-town because it evokes interactions like the one we're having, and that's all D1 is about.

[Crush]

But is it enough to jump on him for? Especially since it was the first vote of the day (and likely a troll vote). Seems kinda forced.

What's forced about it? He voted mod-confirmed town. Even if it's "troll," it's pro-scum, for the reasons I've already mentioned.

Because troll votes don't serve any purpose. No one would ever lynch a confirmed town, it's not pro-scum because it leads to nothing, his vote doesn't benefit scum in any way. I would say it's actually more pro-town because it evokes interactions like the one we're having, and that's all D1 is about.

EDIT: I don't know the definition of evoke, let's keep it at leads to.

[PMysterious]

Reading through, and oh my goodness, Gamma really seems scummy this game.

I think it's the exclamation point.

Really an exclamation point makes you scumread me? How would you prefer I wrote it? The exclamation point adds a specific tone I was aiming for.

A case of overreaction. This post felt really unnecessary, as most of us likely know what you were trying to get across to begin with. Maybe it just felt "a little forced". More on that after the next quote.

Lame entrance. Feels a bit forced.
VOTE: platinum

This was kinda just more so rude than anything. A post just saying hello is just a post saying hello. I know this is Mafia and all, but this early in the game, we barely know each other. It's almost as if you're just looking for a reason to try and lynch someone to save your behind for a night.

I don't like either pmyst's or gamma's reaction to lapsa being confirmed town. Pmyst commenting on it being "quick" feels like he wasn't happy about it. Gamma is the exact opposite, seeming to exaggarate his happiness. It's weird how both initially took pisskop's "always town" comment so seriously too. Both players have made a post I liked though (26 and 33).

Fourtrouble, why should we lynch transcend?

And why does pmyst feel town?

(I see you retracted that)

Not a fan of pisskop buddying to ABR.

Tchill, why the naked vote on transcend?

Whymafia is coming off nervous, but also noticed a couple of the same things I did.

Gamma, what is forced about saying hi?

Theta, care to elaborate on your "reasons"?

Texcat, why don't you seem happy with a confirmed town?

Vote Gamma

Why are you asking me what's forced about it? Fifth Amendment bitch!
I was happy to start what seemed like an exciting game.

Well, this seems like another case of an overreaction. Plus, pleading Fifth Amendment in a game of Mafia really doesn't work.

I'm no expert at Mafia, but overreacting to people voting you or asking you questions of this type really does not scream town at all. That, and the completely jerkish move against someone who just wanted to say "hi" really doesn't help favors.

My vote against you was originally an RV, but now I'm sticking to my guns and saying that you are most definitely scum. My vote on you stays, unless you can convince me otherwise. So, please do tell, what reason do you have on a simple "hi" being so forced?

[FourTrouble]

Because troll votes don't serve any purpose. No one would ever lynch a confirmed town, it's not pro-scum because it leads to nothing, his vote doesn't benefit scum in any way. I would say it's actually more pro-town because it evokes interactions like the one we're having, and that's all D1 is about.

This doesn't answer my question. I articulated my reasons. You disagree with them. Disagreement doesn't make a vote "forced."

[pisskop]

meh, Im more into scumreading gamma cuz he's still trying to dick around than any overreaction. his rvs seems extended and steering away from content.

I mean, we're all more or less vets at mafia, overreactions are overrated.

[FourTrouble]

Quoi?

If you're asking why, because he's painting me as scummy despite having obviously-legitimate (i.e. non-scummy) reasons to vote you. He's assuming you're town in ways that don't square with the game while subtly looking for a mislynch (on me) for reasons that also don't square with the game.

[FourTrouble]

@Transcend - what do you think of PM?

[Transcend]

Didn't even realize crush posted

I thought you voted someone with 0 posts and was like \_O_/

Pm is prob town

[FourTrouble]

Pm is prob town

Why?

[Transcend]

Seems like eager town

[Transcend]

My username is based on a song by Group 1 Crew.

[Crush]

Because troll votes don't serve any purpose. No one would ever lynch a confirmed town, it's not pro-scum because it leads to nothing, his vote doesn't benefit scum in any way. I would say it's actually more pro-town because it evokes interactions like the one we're having, and that's all D1 is about.

This doesn't answer my question. I articulated my reasons. You disagree with them. Disagreement doesn't make a vote "forced."

Yes it does, I think it's a bad reason to vote for him (granted it was the beginning of the day so you need some reason to vote) but I don't like the fact that 4 people jumped on him. And no I'm not trying to paint anyone scummy, I just think the reason for the vote is bad, that's all.

[Transcend]

Can i just say something

[Transcend]

My vote was memes

It was not done to generate reactions of any kind

It was done just to meme

[pisskop]

so?

[Transcend]

VOTE: Crush

Gamma still scum but luckily there's more than one scum and i can use my vote as many times fit.