Large Normal 204: BooneyToonz III - Calling All Cryptids!END

[Lexa]

Lore has hints of town. Theta doesn't.

Funny enough that would almost make me vote Lore first

[FourTrouble]

Lore has hints of town. Theta doesn't.

Funny enough that would almost make me vote Lore first

That's not a bad instinct. I'm trying to get something going on Theta but I'm not opposed to a competing wagon on Lore.

[MuttonChopMagic]

the thing about theta is this
yes his posts are piss
when I was new my town game was really shitty like that
my scum game was always on attack
it's a lot easier as long as you have daychat + a decent team
not sure if daychat is present but almost every large has it it seems
you can get advice plus help
so thetas posts being thst bad is meh
I understand where you're coming from but like
even his gamma wagon hedging is not scum type
I don't really agree with the premise of the case
it's alright, and theta!scum has a place
but I'm much more confident in red lore
and with a lore flip either way I have lots in store
whereas I'm not sure where id go on a theta green
seems pretty useless, not much info to glean
theta red means town!4
that's about it, *info galore*
lore being a stronger scumread plus more info
I've been gunning for him since my intro
but I think he's objectively better
so from my pov die hed better

[FourTrouble]

You shouldn't decide who to lynch based on how much information it gives you.

[MuttonChopMagic]

that is up for debate day one
plus I already said I scumread lore significantly more son

[Theta Alpine]

i have another game people can read for meta
in other news i should be able to get back into this game

my read on gamma was both gut and my thoughts of him in another game
however as gamma has not flipped in that game i am reluctant to bring any more information up

give me some time to actually read through the game and i can form a reads list for once

p-edit
yeah you actually should day 1

[Egg]

Reading a little. Some quick thoughts:
-I don't think texcat answered my question
-Transcend has too many town reads
-lore's "it will be obvious you're scum when I flip town" line is gross
-lexa's lore vote might be even worse than lore's post

I'll try to catch up in about an hour.

[Tchill13]

I really, just like 4 troubles case. I just wanted you to go into more detail 4 trouble I didn't understand what you meant and it didn't look like you had a lot to me. I guess I town lean 4 trouble for now...

VOTE: theta

I understand there were separate wagons earlier for rvs reasons. I don't see why a lore wagon and a theta wagon wouldn't be useful here.

[Egg]

I'm actually going to 180 on that last lexa comment I made. I was thinking about it in the shower and, well, why does it seem like a bad vote? It gives off an opportunistic vibe. But what does an opportunistic vote actually look like? It's usually either bad reasoning or completely naked in an attempt to fly under the radar at the end of a wagon. This vote was early on the wagon with the words "I like bandwagons". As bad as it sounds at first glance, I think it's more likely to come from town than scum.

Back to reading. We'll see how far I get. Should be able to get fully caught up tomorrow.

[Egg]

Lexa's further posting confirms my thoughts that the lore vote wasn't scummy. I like the intent of generating info as coming from a town mindset. I would like to see more from lexa later though. And a quick ISO glance shows that lexa gave a wall post so we'll see how that looks when I get there.

Pisskop, to be perfectly honest the most I saw from ABR was about 1-2 years ago if I'm not mistaken. So it's possible he's changed in that time, but he is matching my perception of his town meta. You seem to have a good understanding of his meta. Did I miss your read on him somewhere? I don't understand your question about multiple teams.

Whymafia, the blending vibe came from your early posting. You voted gamma while calling the transcend wagon easy. Neither of those stands out on their own, but together it's hard to see how you can believe in both. And then a lot that followed was short simple questioning without much to back it or any follow up and then some things you agreed with. Your posting just felt like it lacked something. Like I said, more blending than genuine scum hunting. And skimming your ISO to see a point where that stopped, I really don't see one. Your point that ABR could be scum playing to his town meta is fair, but does he stand out as scum to you? Because he doesn't to me.

I know I didn't get far, but I need to stop there.

[FourTrouble]

Lexa's wall confirms her as town.

[Gamma Emerald]

Egg seems to be truly sorting here
Townread on Rgg

[Gamma Emerald]

Lexa's wall confirms her as town.

I don't particularly object but why exactly?

[FourTrouble]

Lexa's wall confirms her as town.

I don't particularly object but why exactly?

Shows a sort of in-depth thinking that scum don't just do.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think Penguin; I guess you think Theta. But scum could easily be Vifam or Platinum. I'd like to lynch into that pool of 4, but it wouldn't tell us much and so is probably not the best lynch on Day1.

and with that - texcat qualifies as town. congratulations!

Also do you think that that was the same reason Lapsa made this post?

[FourTrouble]

I have no idea what Lapsa was thinking, nor do I care too much. I've mostly been skipping Lapsa's posts.

[Gamma Emerald]

Why
He's conftown

[PMysterious]

I was looking through everything whilst the whole debate was going on, and I don't see Lore as being scum. I'll look through again to find out a few more things, but I'm staying with Gamma as my vote of choice for the time being.

What is your opinion on my reaction to my wagon and my points on you?

I know I'm late with this Gamma, but here are my answers to your questions.

1. Your reaction to the wagon was interesting to say the least. I never knew anyone who would use the Fifth Amendment as an excuse (sarcastic or not). When the numbers racked up, you were like "holy crap, this is getting way too close". It's usually at this point, where some people break down, but you didn't. It was interesting, but at the same time, intriguing.

2. The points you had on me, while valid in some areas, it felt lackluster. The vote felt a little out of the blue, and the whole scumread was a bit bizarre to me too, but other than that, everything you said was pretty legitimate.

Now, back to reading again.

[Tchill13]

There was a reason I voted lapsa before I realized he was conf town.

[FourTrouble]

I already know Lapsa's alignment. Been focusing my energy on people I'm unsure about.

[Gamma Emerald]

You should listen to what he has to say since you know he's not deceiving

[FourTrouble]

You should listen to what he has to say since you know he's not deceiving

He's also the guy that's been voting you most of the game. Strange that you'd urge anyone to listen to him.

[Gamma Emerald]

He has? I don't recall that.

[Tchill13]

Gamma what do you think of crush and massive?

[Gamma Emerald]

Crush: while I'm not a fan of his reaction to Transcend's IC vote (takes it extremely seriously) I don't really have an opinion on him otherwise
massive: had light townfeels on him so far